Key Points

  • Judge Sarah M. Davenport ordered the government to file, by 5 p.m. Mountain Standard Time on Nov. 25, 2026, a status report backed by a sworn declaration from an ICE official with personal knowledge of Agbor's current removal arrangements to Cameroon.
  • The judge held that without evidence of a confirmed departure or a timetable for removal, the court cannot assess whether Agbor's continued detention remains reasonably related to effectuating his removal under Zadvydas v. Davis.
  • The order cites the government's acknowledged blocking of Agbor's self-arranged December 2025 trip to Brazil, its use of a longer domestic connection for a March 2026 Nigeria departure, and its admitted error listing him as Nigerian, without resolving the factual disputes.
  • The court refused to treat the government's supplemental briefing as a motion to lift its transfer and removal restriction, required any such request to be made by separate motion, and kept the April 17, 2026 restrictions in effect.
  • The court reserved determination of Agbor's habeas claims and did not review the validity of his final removal order or his eligibility for immigration relief.

A federal judge in New Mexico has ordered U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement to file a sworn account of whether and when it can remove a Cameroonian man it has detained for about 21 months, ruling that the government's filings left her unable to tell whether his continued detention is still tied to deporting him.

U.S. District Judge Sarah M. Davenport gave the government until 5 p.m. Mountain Standard Time on Nov. 25 to answer specific questions about its plan to send Mathias Etengeneng Agbor to Cameroon, the country where he alleges he was persecuted. The order, filed Nov. 18, recounts that ICE had stopped Agbor from using travel he arranged himself to Brazil, then booked him on a trip to Nigeria with paperwork that wrongly identified him as Nigerian.

"Without that evidence, the Court cannot meaningfully assess whether Petitioner’s continued detention remains reasonably related to effectuating his removal," Davenport wrote. The order keeps in place the restrictions imposed by the court's April 17 order, refuses to treat the government's supplemental briefing as a request to lift them, and reserves ruling on his habeas corpus petition, which challenges the legality of his detention.

The judge grounded the order in Zadvydas v. Davis, a 2001 Supreme Court decision. Under that decision and 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(6), she wrote, "post-removal-period detention must remain reasonably related to effectuating removal." After six months of detention following the start of the statutory removal period, if a detainee gives good reason to believe removal is not significantly likely in the reasonably foreseeable future, the government must respond with evidence sufficient to rebut that showing, the order says.

Davenport stressed the limits of her review. The court "recognizes the existence of a final removal order and does not undertake to review its validity or adjudicate Petitioner’s eligibility for immigration relief," she wrote. The government contends Agbor's removal order became final in January 2026; the judge said she was not deciding when the statutory removal period began.

According to the order, Agbor entered the United States in February 2025 and has been in immigration custody since his apprehension. He sought protection after allegedly suffering persecution arising from humanitarian work in Cameroon. His declarations describe threats against him and his family, violence against relatives and the destruction of his property, and he submitted a purported wanted notice and medical records documenting injuries he attributes to abuse in Cameroon.

Agbor previously received a positive credible-fear determination for Cameroon. Davenport wrote that the determination "does not establish entitlement to protection from removal," but that "the seriousness of his allegations underscores the importance of accurate representations concerning the Government’s proposed removal arrangements."

On Nov. 20, 2025, an immigration judge granted Agbor voluntary departure to Brazil, with Cameroon designated as the alternate country of removal. The government acknowledged that Agbor obtained his own transportation to Brazil for Dec. 9, 2025, and that ICE prevented the trip because the itinerary included an unescorted domestic connection in Houston.

The government later blamed difficulties with Agbor's Brazilian visa or refugee documentation. Agbor maintains his visa remained valid, and the judge wrote that the record does not establish whether Brazilian authorities would have refused to admit him.

On March 23, 2026, ICE arranged Agbor's departure to Nigeria through Atlanta, with a domestic connection longer than the Houston connection it had rejected, the order says. The government's travel paperwork incorrectly identified him as Nigerian. Agbor testified that he was asked to sign documents misidentifying his nationality, while Pedro J. Perez Sr., an ICE acting supervisory detention and deportation officer, stated in a declaration that to his knowledge Agbor was not asked to sign any documents.

Davenport did not resolve those disputes. But she wrote that the government's "acknowledged prevention of Petitioner’s departure to Brazil, its differing treatment of domestic connections, and its admitted error concerning Petitioner’s nationality raise substantial concerns about the handling of his removal efforts."

After an Oct. 27 hearing, the judge denied the government's emergency motion without prejudice and ordered supplemental briefing. The government's Nov. 6 filings, she wrote, "do not adequately reconcile these events or establish that Petitioner’s unsuccessful departures were attributable to his own conduct." The filings represent that arrangements have been made to remove Agbor to Cameroon, but Davenport wrote that they do "not identify a currently confirmed departure or provide sufficient evidence establishing when removal can be accomplished."

"The Court expects accuracy, diligence, and candor from the United States," Davenport wrote, noting that Agbor has been in custody for more than 20 months after coming to the United States to seek asylum and that the government now proposes returning him to the country where he alleges persecution. She directed the government to address the discrepancies directly and to support its account with evidence, "including facts unfavorable to their position." She added: "They have had ample opportunity to address the Court’s concerns. The Court expects better."

The Nov. 25 status report must be supported by a sworn declaration from an ICE official with personal knowledge of Agbor's current removal arrangements. It must say whether a flight to Cameroon is booked or confirmed, with the departure date, itinerary and supporting documentation, and "If none is confirmed, they must state so expressly," the order says.

The report must also confirm whether all necessary travel documents and authorizations have been obtained, including any required arrangements with Cameroonian authorities, and identify remaining obstacles and an anticipated timetable supported by specific facts. The government may seek leave to file sensitive operational information under seal.

The judge also ruled that any request to modify or lift the court's existing restriction must come by a separate motion supported by evidence and legal authority. "The Court will not construe Respondents’ supplemental briefing as such a motion," she wrote. The April 17 restrictions remain in effect pending further order, and the court has reserved its decision on Agbor's habeas claims.