Key Points
- The court granted in part the SEC's motion for final judgments against Alec Vagnozzi, Albert Vagnozzi and Michael Tierney, agent fund managers in CBSG's unregistered offerings.
- The court ordered disgorgement of $128,500 from Alec Vagnozzi, $920,334.62 from Albert Vagnozzi and $603,315.43 from Tierney, plus prejudgment interest.
- The court held that Albert Vagnozzi's Section 17(a)(2) violation was not complete until he received the money, so $336,398 he received after the limitations cutoff stayed in the disgorgement award.
- The court imposed second-tier penalties of $236,450 each on Albert Vagnozzi and Tierney, citing their securities licenses, but imposed a first-tier penalty of $11,823 on Alec Vagnozzi based on his testimony about his limited role.
- Personal living expenses, income taxes and post-operation accounting costs were not deductible as legitimate business expenses under Liu.
A federal judge in Miami on Nov. 19 ordered three men who raised investor money for Complete Business Solutions Group, a company the court described as "a $500 million Ponzi scheme," to pay the Securities and Exchange Commission about $2.3 million combined in disgorgement, interest and civil penalties. The court held that the compensation each man collected for raising money for the company was ill-gotten gain the agency was entitled to recover.
The U.S. district judge in the Southern District of Florida granted in part the SEC's motion for final judgments against Alec Vagnozzi, Albert Vagnozzi and Michael Tierney, whom the agency charged for their roles as "agent fund managers" in CBSG's unregistered securities offerings. It ordered each man to disgorge the full amount the SEC sought and imposed the requested penalties on Albert Vagnozzi and Tierney, but rejected a $75,000 penalty against Alec Vagnozzi and assessed him $11,823 instead.
The order answers the question the three men's settlements left open: how much each would pay. Under consent judgments entered in July 2025, each accepted a permanent injunction against further securities-law violations and agreed that the allegations of the SEC's amended complaint would be "accepted and deemed true" when the court set monetary remedies. The SEC, in turn, agreed to dismiss its scienter-based claims.
According to those allegations, CBSG made short-term loans to small businesses from 2012 to 2020 and sold promissory notes through "Agent Funds" that sales agents created. The funds issued their own notes to investors, pooled the money and sent it to CBSG twice a month in exchange for CBSG notes paying higher interest. The "spread" between the two rates was the compensation CBSG paid the funds and their managers.
CBSG was led by Joseph LaForte, who had two prior felony convictions, and state regulators in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Texas disciplined the company between 2018 and 2020, the complaint alleges. LaForte and several CBSG principals were indicted in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania in May 2023 and have since pleaded guilty, according to the complaint. The complaint alleges that the three managers told investors their offerings complied with the securities laws without disclosing the state actions.
Disgorgement, an equitable remedy for recovering "ill-gotten gains," is "simply meant to restore the status quo," the court wrote. Relying on SEC bank records, it ordered Alec Vagnozzi to disgorge $128,500 that Pisces, the fund he co-owned and co-managed, paid him; Albert Vagnozzi to disgorge $920,334.62 from his fund, Capricorn; and Tierney to disgorge $603,315.43 from his fund, Merchant.
Tierney testified at a Nov. 2 evidentiary hearing, and the court noted that his 2019 Form 1040 showed $785,177 from Merchant that year alone. The testimony and evidence presented at the hearing, the court wrote, "only further corroborate what he was paid by Merchant." It refused to deduct his living expenses and income taxes, holding that "personal living expenses are not legitimate business expenses that may be deducted under Liu," the Supreme Court's 2020 decision limiting disgorgement to net profits after legitimate expenses.
Albert Vagnozzi argued that $336,398 of his total should be excluded because it came from notes sold before Sept. 29, 2018, five years before the SEC sued, placing it outside the five-year statute of limitations. The SEC argued that his violation of Section 17(a)(2) of the Securities Act, which bars using misstatements or omissions "to obtain money or property" in the offer or sale of securities, was not complete until he was paid.
The court agreed with the SEC. "Because obtaining money or property is an element of the violation based on the plain language of the statute, Albert Vagnozzi's Section 17(a)(2) violation was not complete until he received the money from the sale of the promissory notes," the court wrote. It also refused to deduct $43,923.24 he paid for accounting and tax preparation for his funds from 2021 through 2025, because those costs came after the funds stopped operating.
On penalties, the SEC sought second-tier amounts from all three, a level the statute reserves for violations involving "fraud, deceit, manipulation, or deliberate or reckless disregard of a regulatory requirement." The court found that each man "acted at least negligently" and wrote of each: "There is no doubt that this conduct was an egregious violation of the federal securities laws that created substantial losses to investors."
Alec Vagnozzi, however, "credibly testified that he had a limited role at Pisces and lesser involvement in the sales offering of CBSG investments," the court wrote. It held that equitable considerations supported a first-tier penalty, the lowest of the statute's "three tiers of escalating amounts," of $11,823 rather than the $75,000 the SEC sought.
The court imposed the $236,450 the SEC sought from each of the other two, citing their licenses. Albert Vagnozzi held Series 7 and 66 licenses and had been registered as an investment adviser representative in four states, and Tierney held a Series 7 license and a license to serve as an investment adviser. "These previous affiliations add to the egregiousness of Albert Vagnozzi's conduct," the court wrote, concluding of each man that he "either knew or should have known that his failure to disclose CBSG's regulatory history to investors and prospective investors violated the federal securities laws."
Both men also pointed to their purported reliance on attorney John Pauciulo. "Reliance on counsel does not negate the allegations in the Amended Complaint," the court wrote, noting that each had expressly agreed those allegations would be deemed true.
Under the consent judgments, prejudgment interest runs from Oct. 1, 2023, at the Internal Revenue Service's underpayment rate. The SEC sought interest only through Feb. 28, 2025, and the court awarded $15,002.82 against Alec Vagnozzi, $95,186 against Albert Vagnozzi and $70,439.16 against Tierney. In all, Albert Vagnozzi owes about $1.25 million, Tierney about $910,000 and Alec Vagnozzi about $155,000.
Russell Koonin of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission represented the SEC.
The court said it will enter final judgments against each of the three men by separate order, and that a permanent injunction will issue against each consistent with the judgments entered in July 2025.