Key Points
- The Connecticut Appellate Court affirmed a judgment upholding a human rights referee's finding that Charter Communications fired Latoya Council because of her mental disability, PTSD, in violation of the Connecticut Fair Employment Practices Act.
- Substantial evidence supported a prima facie case because Charter received a doctor's note confirming Council's PTSD diagnosis and medical marijuana recommendation six days before firing her.
- The referee permissibly found Charter's drug-policy justification false because there was no credible evidence Council used or possessed marijuana on company property or worked under its influence, and because Charter added new reasons for the firing at the hearing.
- The panel held that a finding of falsity, combined with the prima facie case, is sufficient to establish pretext under the highly deferential substantial-evidence standard.
- The referee had ordered Charter to pay Council $62,530 and reimburse the state $9,646.
The Connecticut Appellate Court on Tuesday upheld a state ruling that Charter Communications LLC illegally fired an employee because of her post-traumatic stress disorder, rejecting the company's position that it dismissed her for testing positive for marijuana under its drug-free workplace policy.
The three-judge panel affirmed a Superior Court judgment sustaining a human rights referee's decision in favor of Latoya Council, a strategic accounts coordinator. Charter fired her on June 15, 2016, six days after her doctor faxed the company a note confirming her PTSD diagnosis and her recommendation for Connecticut's medical marijuana program. Judge Pierson wrote the opinion, and Judges Westbrook and DiPentima concurred.
The referee had ordered Charter to pay Council $62,530 and to reimburse the state $9,646 for unemployment compensation and dependency allowances paid to her. The panel held that the referee could find Charter's drug-policy explanation false. No credible evidence showed that Council used or possessed marijuana on company property or worked under its influence, the conduct the policy prohibits. The panel also relied on new reasons Charter offered for the firing at the agency hearing.
Council began working full time for Charter on August 12, 2014. In the court's summary of the referee's findings, "Aside from some incidents of tardiness, Council was an excellent employee who worked hard, completed her assignments, achieved expected performance, and was willing to take on additional assignments." Charter's policy prohibited employees from being under the influence of marijuana while working and from possessing or using it on company property, and it made a positive test grounds for immediate termination.
On May 23, 2016, an advanced practice registered nurse, Jane Buckley, determined that Council met the criteria for chronic PTSD. Two days later, Dr. Judith Major confirmed the diagnosis and recommended Council for the state's medical marijuana program.
On June 8, 2016, Council went out to the company parking lot during a break to check her car's oil. Two co-workers, Norm Sherents and Noel Machado, stopped to help her with the dip stick and smelled marijuana coming from the car. Neither saw her smoking or possessing marijuana. Sherents reported what he had noticed to his supervisor.
The next day, Jennie Barbot, Charter's human resource officer, questioned Council. Council said she had not used marijuana on company property or at work and was not the only person who used the car. She acknowledged using marijuana within the previous 30 days and said she had applied for the state program. She did not mention her PTSD because she did not feel comfortable doing so. Barbot asked Dr. Major to verify Council's status, and Dr. Major faxed a note disclosing the diagnosis. Council took an oral saliva test on June 10, tested positive on June 15 and was fired that day.
Council filed a complaint with the Commission on Human Rights and Opportunities in October 2016 under the Connecticut Fair Employment Practices Act. The referee ruled for her on May 17, 2023. On November 1, 2024, Judge Budzik of the Superior Court affirmed the finding of intentional discrimination. Judge Budzik vacated the referee's separate conclusions under the federal Americans with Disabilities Act, finding that Council's PTSD did not substantially limit a major life activity as that law requires.
The state law's definition of mental disability covers mental disorders listed in the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, and the panel noted that the manual recognizes PTSD. Charter argued that the referee had wrongly found that it "regarded" Council as disabled. The panel called that argument "inapposite," because the referee had found that Council actually has a disability.
Charter also contended that "[t]he only reasonable inference from the evidence in this case is that . . . Council's diagnosis played no role in" the firing. The panel stressed the narrow scope of its review, under which an agency's factual findings stand if substantial evidence in the record supports them. Quoting a 2023 decision of the Connecticut Supreme Court, Judge Pierson wrote that "[o]ur deferential standard of review allows for the record to contain competing evidence that would allow a different fact finder to reach a different conclusion." The timeline of the diagnosis, the fax and the firing, the court wrote, allowed the referee to find that Charter "was aware of both Council's disability and referral to the medical marijuana program" when it fired her.
On pretext, the court pointed to the shifting explanations the referee identified. Before the hearing, Charter's only stated reason was the drug policy. At the hearing, the company also cited Council's tardiness and her inaccurate statement on June 9 that she already had a medical marijuana card. The panel cited a federal appeals decision stating that "[i]nconsistent or even post-hoc explanations for a termination decision may suggest discriminatory motive."
The court also endorsed the referee's finding that Council had not broken the policy at all. Council "was not observed smoking marijuana. She did not slur her words. She was not observed in the possession of any drugs," the referee wrote. "There was no evidence of any impairment impacting her work." The referee also found the co-workers' accounts inconsistent: Machado thought Council seemed "giggly, silly, and under the influence," while Sherents first testified that she was not under the influence and later testified that she was.
"The referee's finding of falsity, taken together with Council's prima facie case, is sufficient to establish pretext," Judge Pierson wrote. The court rejected Charter's argument that the referee had improperly placed the burden on the company to prove its reason was genuine. It also declined Charter's request to reweigh the evidence.
Elizabeth McKenna argued for Charter. Catherine M. Spain represented the commission.
The Appellate Court affirmed the judgment. Under the notice printed with the opinion, the November 17 official release date starts the time periods for filing postopinion motions and petitions for certification.