Key Points

  • The Eighth Circuit dismissed Gregg B. Colton's appeal of an order striking his class allegations for lack of Article III jurisdiction.
  • A stipulated judgment entered on the parties' joint proposal is a voluntary termination of the named plaintiff's claims, like a settlement, and ends his personal stake in the class allegations.
  • A clause in the stipulation reserving the right to appeal the class ruling could not confer jurisdiction, because parties may not by agreement confer jurisdiction.
  • The court noted that an order striking class allegations was appealable under Rule 23(f) before the stipulated judgment, and Colton did not seek that review.
  • Colton's continued ownership of mineral interests and his cost-shifting argument, raised first at oral argument, did not preserve a live controversy.

A federal appeals court ruled Nov. 16 that a mineral-interest owner who agreed to a $20 judgment covering all of his individual damages could not then appeal the order that had stripped the class allegations from his royalty lawsuit against Lime Rock Resources.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit dismissed Gregg B. Colton's appeal for lack of jurisdiction. Judge Benton wrote the opinion for a panel that also included Judges Kelly and Justin D. Smith.

The court held that Colton's consent to the judgment ended his personal stake in the class claims, just as a settlement would have. It also held that a clause in the stipulation preserving his right to appeal could not keep the case alive. The court pointed to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(f) as a route to review that Colton had available before he agreed to judgment and did not use.

Colton sued Lime Rock on behalf of a class of mineral-interest owners, alleging that the company failed to pay statutory interest on late royalty payments in violation of N.D.C.C. ยง 47-16-39.1. He later added a second class, alleging Lime Rock breached mineral-interest leases by deducting post-production costs of natural gas from oil royalties.

U.S. District Judge Daniel L. Hovland of the District of North Dakota dismissed Colton's declaratory judgment claims and struck the class allegations from his first amended complaint. Colton revised the class definitions in a second amended complaint and did not reassert the declaratory claims. Judge Hovland struck the class allegations again, finding the classes could not satisfy the typicality and predominance requirements of Rule 23. Colton did not appeal that order under Rule 23(f).

Four months later, the parties filed a stipulation for entry of judgment. It awarded Colton "Twenty Dollars ($20.00)," which the parties said "represents the full measure of damages claimed by Colton on his individual claims in the Second Amended Complaint." The stipulation also stated that "the parties do not intend to waive their right to appeal any order previously entered by the Court in this case," naming the order striking the class allegations. Judge Hovland adopted the stipulation and entered judgment.

On appeal, Colton challenged only the order striking the class allegations. Lime Rock argued the appeal was moot. Under Article III of the Constitution, federal courts may hear only live cases and controversies, and a case becomes moot "when the issues presented are no longer 'live' or the parties lack a legally cognizable interest in the outcome," Judge Benton wrote, quoting Supreme Court precedent.

Colton relied on two 1980 Supreme Court decisions. In Deposit Guaranty National Bank v. Roper, the defendant offered the named plaintiffs the damages they could recover, and the district court entered judgment for them over their objections. The Supreme Court allowed their appeal of the class-certification denial. In United States Parole Commission v. Geraghty, an inmate who challenged parole guidelines for a class was released during his appeal, and the Supreme Court held that his class action did not become moot.

The Eighth Circuit has read those cases to turn on whether the plaintiff's claims ended voluntarily. A named plaintiff who "voluntarily settles his claims no longer has a personal stake, mooting any appeal of class-certification issues," Judge Benton wrote. When the end is involuntary, Roper and Geraghty control. The opinion noted that the Geraghty court took "no view as to whether a named plaintiff who settles" could appeal a denial of class certification.

The question in Colton's case was whether a stipulated judgment, entered without a separate settlement agreement, counts as voluntary. The panel held that it does. Quoting a 1986 Supreme Court decision on consent decrees, Judge Benton wrote that when parties consent to judgment, "it is the parties' agreement that serves as the source of the court's authority to enter any judgment at all." He added: "Colton has no personal stake because the court adopted the parties' jointly proposed stipulation of judgment."

The panel rejected Colton's argument that he kept a stake because he still owns Lime Rock mineral interests. A plaintiff may keep a stake where a claim may arise again, the court said, but that principle applies to disputes too short to litigate before they end. "Colton's interest ended because he stipulated to judgment, not because the challenged actions were too short in duration to litigate," Judge Benton wrote.

Colton also argued, for the first time at oral argument, that he had an interest in shifting litigation costs to a class. The court held the argument waived and, in any event, foreclosed by a 2013 Eighth Circuit decision that found such an interest insufficient.

The reservation clause fared no better. "[P]arties may not by agreement confer jurisdiction," the court wrote, quoting its 2003 decision in Potter v. Norwest Mortgage. The panel added that Colton could have appealed earlier, citing the Supreme Court's 2017 decision in Microsoft Corp. v. Baker for the point that "an order striking class allegations is 'functional[ly] equivalent' to an order denying class certification and therefore appealable under Rule 23(f)."

The court also noted that even if Colton retained an interest in his dismissed declaratory judgment claims, he never appealed their dismissal. "Under these circumstances, Colton has no continuing personal stake in the class allegations," Judge Benton wrote.

Sandy River Energy, LLC and Sandy River Resources, LLC filed as amici supporting Colton. The defendants were seven Lime Rock entities, which the opinion referred to collectively as Lime Rock.

Because it found no jurisdiction, the panel did not reach whether Judge Hovland correctly struck the class allegations. It denied a pending motion to take judicial notice that addressed the merits and dismissed the appeal.