Key Points
- The en banc Fifth Circuit, voting 9-8, held that the House violated the Quorum Clause when it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 by counting absent members present through proxies.
- The court held that the enrolled-bill rule does not bar review because Texas's challenge turned on the legal meaning of the Quorum Clause, not on any disputed fact about the bill's passage.
- The court affirmed a permanent injunction barring enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas and said its decision extends no further than that relief.
- The majority did not decide whether the Quorum Clause requires physical presence or whether participation by videoconference would satisfy it.
- Judge Graves, for seven judges, dissented on the merits, and Judge Haynes dissented separately.
The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held on Nov. 20 that the House of Representatives violated the Constitution when it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 by counting absent members as present through proxies. The Constitution's Quorum Clause provides that a majority of each chamber "shall constitute a Quorum to do Business," and the court said proxies cannot supply that majority. "An absent Member's assignment of his or her proxy cannot render that Member present for purposes of the Quorum Clause," the majority wrote.
The 9-8 decision affirmed a permanent injunction barring the federal government from enforcing one part of the 2023 law, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, or PWFA, against Texas. Judge Cory T. Wilson wrote for the majority, joined by Chief Judge Elrod and Judges Jones, Smith, Willett, Ho, Duncan, Engelhardt and Oldham. Judge James E. Graves Jr. dissented, joined by six judges, and Judge Haynes dissented separately.
The court also rejected the government's argument that judges could not review the House's quorum count at all. That argument rested on the enrolled-bill rule, which, the majority wrote, "instructs that a bill's passage through the legislature is conclusive proof of its authenticity." The ruling reinstates the trial court's result after a divided three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit vacated the injunction in 2025. The majority said its decision "extends no further than affirming the relief awarded by the district court."
The House adopted its proxy rule, House Resolution 965, in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic. When the House passed the act on Dec. 23, 2022, by a vote of 225 to 201, 226 of the 427 members who recorded a vote did so by proxy, according to the opinion. Fewer than a majority of members were physically present.
During the vote, Rep. Chip Roy said the bill was "moving off the floor without a physical quorum present." The presiding officer, Rep. G.K. Butterfield, answered that "under the rules of the House, a quorum was, indeed, present," because members recording their presence by proxy were counted. The opinion said it was "uncontested" that the House reached a quorum only by counting proxies.
Texas sued the Justice Department, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and their officials. After a bench trial, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas found that Texas had standing to challenge the PWFA, citing compliance costs the state bears as an employer, but not a $20 million Homeland Security pilot program. The court enjoined the PWFA's enforcement against Texas and denied a declaratory judgment.
On appeal, the government invoked Marshall Field & Co. v. Clark, an 1892 Supreme Court decision. Wilson wrote that the enrolled-bill doctrine governs what evidence courts may use to determine which bill Congress passed, and does not apply when the facts are agreed. "Texas's challenge rests on no disputed facts; the issue is a question of law properly brought before the judiciary," he wrote. Rulings from the Second, Seventh and Tenth circuits that the government cited involved factual disputes over whether a quorum was present, the majority said.
The government had warned of the "uncertainty and disruption" that could follow if courts struck down laws over quorum defects. The majority answered that judges may not let "extrajudicial considerations" shape their reading of the Constitution. "'Too big to be unconstitutional' is not an accepted canon of constitutional interpretation," Wilson wrote.
On the merits, the majority framed the question narrowly. It did not decide whether the clause requires "physical, bottom-in-a-seat presence," or whether Congress may use proxy voting. It decided only whether a proxy can make an absent member present for quorum purposes. The court pointed to the clause's grant of power to a minority "to compel the Attendance of absent Members," and reasoned that an absent member therefore is not counted.
The majority also relied on history. The government conceded that neither chamber used proxy presence to reach a quorum until 2023, the court said. "Surveying congressional practice between 1789 and 2023, the evidence of use of proxies for quorum purposes can be summarized succinctly: Crickets," Wilson wrote. The court noted that at oral argument the government acknowledged its reading would let every member designate the Speaker as a proxy.
The majority said Congress's long practice of acting by unanimous consent fits its reading, because that practice presumes a quorum only until a member raises a point of no quorum or a recorded vote shows that a quorum is absent. The court left open whether members' participation by videoconference would count, calling that "a question not presented in this case."
Graves agreed that the enrolled-bill rule did not block review, but rejected the majority's reading of the clause. "I cannot agree with their addition of a new requirement to the Quorum Clause," he wrote. He relied on United States v. Ballin, an 1892 Supreme Court decision that let the House choose "any method which shall be reasonably certain to ascertain the fact" of a quorum. He also cited the Senate's use of unanimous consent since 1789, often with less than a majority of senators present.
Graves wrote that more than 99% of House members took part in the vote. He also questioned the remedy. "There is no explanation offered to explain why, if the entirety of the statute was unconstitutionally passed, this court's judgment should be limited only to one small sliver of the multi-trillion dollar bill," he wrote. He added that the majority did not explain how Texas could challenge the PWFA "despite accepting millions of dollars" under the same law. "Simply put, the majority's decision is illogical, inexplicable, and invalid," Graves concluded.
In a brief separate note, Haynes said she does not think it is appropriate to "throw out the Federal House of Representatives in this arena," and that she appreciated Graves's dissent.
The decision leaves the district court's injunction in force. Texas did not appeal the denial of declaratory relief or the dismissal of its challenge to the pilot program, so the court treated those issues as abandoned. The majority stressed that Texas never sought, and the trial court never granted, an injunction against the rest of the act.