Key Points
- The Fourth Circuit held that Kreitzer and Safeco settled her underinsured motorist claim for $25,000, as shown by a $25,000 demand, a $25,000 offer and the parties' joint motion stating the policy claim was resolved.
- Kreitzer's theory that her coverage should be reformed to $100,000 fell within the settled claim for policy proceeds, not the extracontractual claims the parties left open.
- A party's prior representations may be used as evidence at summary judgment without invoking judicial estoppel.
- A policyholder does not substantially prevail under Hayseeds when she sues without negotiating and the insurer's higher payment follows evidence she developed later in litigation; an insurer's offer is judged on the information available when it was made.
- The WVUTPA claim failed because Kreitzer showed no unfair settlement practice, let alone a general business practice.
A policyholder who eventually won a $25,000 judgment for the full limit of her underinsured motorist coverage cannot make her insurer pay her attorney's fees, a federal appeals court ruled Nov. 13, because she sued two weeks after the insurer invited further negotiations and drew the higher offer only after her hired experts produced new reports.
A three-judge panel of the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed summary judgment for Safeco Insurance Company of America against policyholder Maura Kreitzer. Circuit Judge Quattlebaum wrote the published opinion, joined by Circuit Judges Rushing and Benjamin. The panel also rejected her bid to raise her coverage to $100,000 and her state unfair trade practices claim.
The fee claim turned on West Virginia's Hayseeds rule, named for a 1986 West Virginia decision, which lets a policyholder who "substantially prevails" against her own insurer recover attorney's fees, economic losses from delay and damages for aggravation and inconvenience. The panel held that the policyholder must show the insurer's handling of the claim made a lawsuit necessary, and that a higher offer prompted by evidence developed in litigation does not make that showing. "Hayseeds is for parties who substantially prevail, not those who do so forcibly," Judge Quattlebaum wrote.
Kreitzer was rear-ended in March 2018 and said she suffered a concussion, cognitive deficits and other injuries, including a jaw-joint disorder known as TMJ. After the other driver's insurer offered $45,000 of its $50,000 limit in September 2022, Kreitzer asked Safeco for the full $25,000 of her underinsured motorist coverage, which applies when an at-fault driver's insurance cannot cover a victim's damages.
About a month later Safeco offered $4,000. It excluded her TMJ treatment, which began more than two years after the crash, and explained the basis for its valuation. Counting the other driver's insurance payment, the court noted, the offer put her total recovery at $49,000, more than her documented medical bills. The doctor who treated Kreitzer's concussion had "[a]nticipate[d] she will continue to improve and reach full recovery," and she had received no accident-related care other than for TMJ in nearly three years.
Kreitzer's counsel rejected the offer and said she would sue. Safeco's adjuster asked for any "counter demand/response to [the] offer" and repeated the company's "willing[ness] to discuss the case further." Kreitzer filed suit two weeks later in state court, and Safeco removed the case to federal court in Wheeling, where U.S. District Judge John Preston Bailey presided.
In September 2024, Kreitzer produced a report from Dr. Timothy Saar, a hired expert who attributed memory and attention declines to the crash and recommended seven years of counseling. Six weeks later a second hired expert, Dr. Richard Bowman, put her care plan at roughly $700,000. Two days after receiving the Bowman report, Safeco offered the $25,000 limit.
The parties then filed a joint motion to amend the schedule stating that "[t]he Parties have resolved Plaintiff's claim for policy proceeds, leaving Plaintiff's claims for extracontractual damages and bad faith." Kreitzer's counsel had replied to Safeco's draft, "Looks perfect!"
At summary judgment, Kreitzer argued for the first time that her policy should be reformed to $100,000. West Virginia requires insurers to offer underinsured motorist coverage equal to a policy's liability limits, and absent proof that the insured knowingly rejected it, the coverage rises to that amount by operation of law. Kreitzer had $100,000 in liability coverage and had left blank the box rejecting matching coverage.
The panel held that the settlement disposed of that theory, because reformation concerns the terms of the insurance contract and the parties had settled the "claim for policy proceeds." "She cannot keep the part of the settlement she likes—the $25,000 payment—while discarding the part she now regrets—that the payment resolved her claim," Judge Quattlebaum wrote.
Kreitzer had argued that the district court effectively applied judicial estoppel, a doctrine that bars a party from contradicting an earlier position that misled a court to gain an unfair advantage, without finding its required elements. The panel disagreed. "A party's prior representations can be used as evidence on summary judgment without invoking judicial estoppel," the opinion said.
On fees, the panel found that Safeco investigated promptly, made a reasonable offer and explained it. Hayseeds, the court wrote, "does not allow a policyholder to manufacture the necessity for litigation by cutting short an otherwise reasonable adjustment process and suing." An insurer's offer, the panel held, is judged against the information available when it was made, not against stronger proof produced years later.
"New evidence may justify a higher insurance payout; it does not retroactively prove that litigation was necessary to get it," Judge Quattlebaum wrote. He added that Kreitzer's position "would turn every policy-limits demand into an ultimatum—pay it now or risk enhanced damages if a plaintiff discloses experts later on that will value the claim higher."
The panel relied in part on Bristol Springs Custom Homes v. Argo Group, an unpublished July 24, 2026, decision denying Hayseeds damages where counsel "failed to engage in settlement negotiations." A footnote stated that Kreitzer's counsel was the same lawyer in that case and in a 2025 case in which the court rejected similar claims against Progressive, which had tendered full policy limits after receiving new medical records.
West Virginia's unfair trade practices statute reaches settlement misconduct only when it occurs often enough to indicate a general business practice, which a plaintiff can show from a single claim involving multiple discrete violations. The panel rejected Kreitzer's arguments that Safeco should have routed her claim to a complex claims unit, misrepresented her medical costs and ran a bonus program that rewarded underpaying claims. "None of this establishes even an isolated unfair settlement practice, much less the 'general business practice' West Virginia law requires," the court wrote.
Kreitzer was represented at argument by George Nico Sidiropolis of Injury Rights Law Firm, with Jordan M. Laird of Laird Law, PLLC, on the brief. Elise N. McQuain of FBT Gibbons LLP argued for Safeco, Liberty Mutual Insurance Company and Marisa Culbertson, with William M. Harter of FBT Gibbons on the brief.
The decision, in No. 25-1765, leaves in place the district court's $25,000 judgment for Kreitzer on her contract claim and its summary judgment for Safeco on her Hayseeds and unfair trade practices claims.