Key Points
- The court granted Arlington County's motion for a preliminary injunction and said it would enjoin the defendants from taking any actions to begin construction of the 250-foot arch at Memorial Circle.
- The court found the arch is likely a commemorative work under the Commemorative Works Act, citing the Park Service's own description of it as a "major commemorative feature," and noted the defendants conceded they did not follow the act's procedures.
- The court held that a 1925 statute approving Memorial Bridge, whose plan called for "two stately columns" 166 feet high, did not authorize a 250-foot arch that would interfere with protected views.
- The county is also likely to succeed on its claim that the arch violates the Park Service's Organic Act, which requires direct and specific congressional authorization for actions inconsistent with the agency's conservation mission.
- The court found the county has standing and faces irreparable harm from construction-related traffic disruptions to its emergency services, and rejected the government's venue objection.
A federal judge in Alexandria, Virginia, on Nov. 20 barred the National Park Service from beginning construction of a 250-foot "Triumphal Arch" in Memorial Circle at the western end of Memorial Bridge, ruling that the agency likely planned the project "in an arbitrary and capricious manner" and without the approval from Congress that federal law requires. The court rejected the government's position that a 1925 law approving the bridge already covered the arch.
The memorandum opinion granted Arlington County's motion for a preliminary injunction, a court order meant "to preserve the status quo until there is a trial on the merits." The court said it would issue an order enjoining the defendants "from taking any actions to begin construction of the Arch," and found that all four factors for such relief "overwhelmingly favor the County."
The ruling stops the project before work begins. The court found that the arch is likely a commemorative work under the Commemorative Works Act, which bars such works in the area that includes Memorial Circle unless "specifically authorized by law," and that a century-old approval of "two stately columns" on the bridge did not authorize a far larger structure. "Congressional approval from 100 years ago for an aspect of a plan that was not implemented did not provide a blank check," the opinion said.
The county sued on Oct. 8 and amended its complaint on Nov. 6. The amended complaint asserts eight counts under the Administrative Procedure Act against the Park Service, the Interior Department, Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Jessica Bowron, the Park Service's comptroller and acting director. The county alleges that the approval of the arch was arbitrary and capricious, exceeded the agency's authority and violated its Organic Act, the Commemorative Works Act, the National Environmental Policy Act and the National Historic Preservation Act.
According to the opinion, the defendants "conceded that they did not comply with any procedures required by the CWA," such as having Congress designate a sponsor who must consult an advisory commission on "alternative sites and design concepts." They argued instead that the law did not apply because "the Arch is forward-looking in design, intended to perpetuate American greatness, not backwards-looking to commemorate something."
The court called that argument "plainly rebutted by defendants' own statements." It pointed to the agency's Revised Environmental Assessment, which describes the arch as a "major commemorative feature" and as a monumental structure "honoring the nation's 250th anniversary." The court found the arch was designed to celebrate and commemorate "the country's independence and founding principles."
The government's second argument rested on a 1925 statute that authorized Memorial Bridge, set a $14,750,000 budget and let a bridge commission change the design within that cost. The commission's plan for the area that is now Memorial Circle called for "a park" and "a plaza," with "two stately columns" on the bridge, "166 feet high," framing the view of the Lincoln Memorial from the Lee Mansion. Works authorized by laws enacted before Jan. 3, 1985, are exempt from the Commemorative Works Act.
The court held that even assuming the 1925 law could authorize a commemorative work a century later, the arch "is significantly different in size and kind from the authorized structure and would interfere with the very views Congress wanted protected." The opinion read the act to require that Congress approve a specific proposed structure, so the old plan did not let the defendants "build a structure" in the same general area without going back to Congress.
The county is also likely to succeed on its Organic Act claim, the court held. That law requires the Park Service to conserve scenery and leave park resources "unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations," and, under Fourth Circuit precedent quoted in the opinion, bars actions inconsistent with that mission unless Congress has "directly and specifically" authorized them. The government pointed to decades of agency construction in Washington without further approval, but the court found those projects, including U.S. Park Police facilities and public parks, "appear consistent with NPS's conservation mandate," while the arch "will impair the scenery and the purpose of the 1925 Plan that the Arch is purported to implement."
On standing, the court relied on the agency's own assessment, which anticipates "reducing westbound traffic from Arlington Memorial Bridge to two lanes" during construction. A county declaration says the fire department responded to about 978 incidents in its area around the cemetery and the circle from Jan. 1 to Nov. 5, 2026, about 200 of which "were in Memorial Circle itself or on its ramps." The court found the closures would disrupt emergency routes, including to Reagan National Airport, and consume county staff time. "Diverting the County's finite resources is an irreparable harm," the opinion said.
The court also rejected the government's venue objection, which relied on a provision barring plaintiff-based venue where real property is involved. That reading "contravenes the overwhelming weight of precedent," the opinion said, because the county challenges a final agency action, not ownership or control of Memorial Circle.
On the balance of harms, the court said the defendants "failed to provide any persuasive reason for needing the construction to commence immediately, especially considering that they argue the Arch was first authorized over 100 years ago." It added that any claimed national defense need for the arch "lacks credibility," because it was first raised after the litigation began and the agency did not consider national security uses during its review.
Gregory Martin Cumming of Democracy Forward Foundation represented the County Board of Arlington County, Virginia. Benjamin Timothy Hayes of the Department of Justice represented the National Park Service.
The opinion said it is in the public interest "to stop construction of the Arch before it begins rather than to have to undo the harms if plaintiff prevails on the merits." The injunction keeps the defendants from beginning construction while the case proceeds toward a decision on the merits.