Key Points

  • Judge Contreras granted the Federal Defendants' motion to dismiss all four of the Center for Biological Diversity's claims for lack of jurisdiction.
  • The court held that the Endangered Species Committee's national-security exemption was a decision under subsection (h) of the Endangered Species Act, which Congress made reviewable in the courts of appeals.
  • The court rejected the Center's argument that the committee's alleged failure to follow subsection (h)'s procedures took the decision outside that provision.
  • Claims over withheld records and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's national-security finding were dismissed because they did not challenge final agency actions separate from the exemption.
  • The mandamus claim for committee records was dismissed because the Freedom of Information Act provides an adequate alternative remedy, a point the Center did not answer.

A federal judge in Washington on Friday dismissed a conservation group's lawsuit against a national-security exemption that frees certain oil and gas activities in the Gulf of Mexico from the Endangered Species Act, holding that Congress sent challenges to such exemptions to the federal appeals courts rather than to district court.

U.S. District Judge Rudolph Contreras granted the federal defendants' motion to dismiss all four claims brought by the Center for Biological Diversity, concluding that the court lacked jurisdiction over each of them. The statute lets any person seek review "of any decision of the Endangered Species Committee under subsection (h) in the United States Court of Appeals." Contreras held that the committee's exemption was such a decision because "subsection (h) is the only legal authority under which the Committee actually grants exemptions," quoting the court's Nov. 16 ruling dismissing a related suit by the Natural Resources Defense Council.

The ruling rejects the Center's argument that a committee that skipped subsection (h)'s procedures could not have acted under that provision. Under the decision, the Center must bring its challenge to the exemption in the courts of appeals. Separately, petitions from both industry and environmental groups have been consolidated in parallel proceedings before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

The Endangered Species Act generally requires federal agencies to ensure that their actions are "not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of any endangered species or threatened species." Congress created the Endangered Species Committee as a pathway to exemptions from those requirements. Before granting one, the committee typically must follow the steps in subsection (h), including a formal hearing and a finding that "there are no reasonable and prudent alternatives to the agency action."

A separate provision, subsection (j), states that "the Committee shall grant an exemption for any agency action if the Secretary of Defense finds that such exemption is necessary for reasons of national security."

According to the amended complaint, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth notified Interior Secretary Doug Burgum in March 2026 that exempting "all Gulf of America oil and gas exploration and development activities associated with" certain federal programs was necessary for national security. In Hegseth's view, environmental litigation over those programs could delay projects and undermine national security. The committee convened on March 31 and voted unanimously to grant the exemption.

In its published decision, the committee said it acted "pursuant to subsection (h)." It concluded, however, that the statute's application requirements and standards do not apply once the defense secretary finds an exemption necessary for national security. The committee told challengers to seek review "exclusively in the U.S. Courts of Appeals for the Fifth or Eleventh Circuits."

The Center, a national conservation organization, alleges that Gulf oil and gas projects can be "lethal" to endangered species, "including the critically imperiled Rice's whale." It also alleges that the committee released no documents before or during its meeting and that the public stream began a half-hour after the scheduled start, from which the group infers an "unlawful closed session." The complaint claims that "the Committee followed none of the procedures and made none of the discretionary findings" that subsection (h) provides.

The Center argued that "under" means "subject to" or "governed by," so a decision that ignored subsection (h)'s requirements was not made under that provision and could be heard in district court. Contreras disagreed. "Congress, not the Committee, decides which statutory provisions govern the Committee's actions," the judge wrote. Courts routinely hold that a statute governs an agency's decision even when the agency failed to comply with it, Contreras added, and that is exactly what the Center asks the court to do on the merits.

The group also argued that appellate review made little sense without the detailed fact-finding a subsection (h) proceeding would produce. "But Congress created no such off-ramp for its remedial scheme," Contreras wrote. Quoting the NRDC ruling, the judge added that if an appeals court needs a fuller record, "it may remand the decision for the Committee to conduct further proceedings."

The remaining claims fell for related reasons. A claim that the committee unlawfully withheld records and failed to hold a public hearing before voting targeted what the Supreme Court has called "subsidiary decisions" that "merge into the final agency action," Contreras wrote, citing the high court's 2026 decision in Mullin v. Doe. Because the court cannot review the exemption, it cannot review those decisions either.

A claim attacking Hegseth's national-security finding as arbitrary and capricious failed because the finding was not a final agency action, the only kind the Administrative Procedure Act generally lets plaintiffs challenge. Relying on Dalton v. Specter, a 1994 Supreme Court case over the closure of a naval base, Contreras reasoned that until the committee acts, the defense secretary's finding carries "no direct consequences" for the Center. "It is the Committee who grants the exemption," the judge wrote.

Contreras also dismissed the Center's request for a writ of mandamus, which sought release of the committee's records. Mandamus is unavailable when a plaintiff has another adequate remedy, and the government argued, "albeit briefly and obliquely," that the Freedom of Information Act provides one. "The Center offers no response to this argument," the judge wrote, noting that a "near unanimous chorus" of courts in the circuit has rejected using mandamus to compel agencies to turn over records.

The court had denied the Center's request for a temporary restraining order in March, before the committee voted, concluding then that it "likely lack[ed] subject matter jurisdiction" over the group's claims. The American Petroleum Institute, an intervenor defendant, joined the motion to dismiss.

Contreras issued a separate order alongside the memorandum opinion. A third related suit, Healthy Gulf v. Burgum, is also before Contreras, and the consolidated petitions in the Fifth Circuit are docketed as No. 26-60240.