Key Points

  • U.S. District Judge Noël Wise granted Fredy Abimael Lopez Perez's ex parte motion for a temporary restraining order and ordered the respondents to release him from custody on Nov. 18, 2026.
  • The judge found he had shown serious questions going to the merits, a balance of hardships tipping sharply in his favor, and a likelihood of success on the merits.
  • Applying Mathews v. Eldridge, the order holds that due process requires his release, and notice and a pre-detention hearing before a neutral decisionmaker before any re-detention; it also bars his removal from the United States until further order.
  • The order recounts that the I-200 form later shown to him bore a supervisory officer's digital signature time-stamped at 6:48:04 a.m., at least 14 minutes after the arrest.
  • The order remains in effect until 8 p.m. on Nov. 25, 2026, the day of a 9 a.m. videoconference hearing on the habeas petition and the request for preliminary relief.

U.S. District Judge Noël Wise on Nov. 18 ordered the immediate release of a landscaper pulled over in San Rafael, California, and arrested that morning by officers with "ICE" printed across their chests, finding that the Fifth Amendment's guarantee of due process required both his release and a hearing before a neutral decisionmaker before he could be taken back into custody.

Wise, of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, granted an ex parte motion for a temporary restraining order filed by Fredy Abimael Lopez Perez. He had also filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. The judge found that he had shown "serious questions going to the merits" and that "the balance of hardships tips sharply" in his favor, and that he was likely to succeed on the merits of his claims.

The order bars the respondents from re-detaining Lopez Perez without notice and a pre-deprivation hearing before a neutral decisionmaker, and from removing him from the United States until further order of the court. Dated 8:30 p.m. on the day of the arrest, it remains in effect until 8 p.m. on Nov. 25.

According to the order's account, which draws on Lopez Perez's filings, he was driving to his landscaping job with a coworker when individuals in a "large dark car with police lights and a siren" pulled him over. They showed him a photograph and said the person pictured had his first name, last name and date of birth. He told them it was not him. As soon as he got out of his car, they told him they had a warrant for his arrest and that he was under arrest.

The individuals did not show Lopez Perez a warrant, and his coworker did not see them present a warrant or any other document, the order says. The coworker, a lawful permanent resident, was allowed to drive away after showing his ID. He called their supervisor at 6:34 a.m., according to a timestamp in his phone, to report the arrest.

Once Lopez Perez was handcuffed in their vehicle, the officers told him he was right that he was not the person in the photograph, the order says. After he mentioned that his daughter is in the military, they asked for his work address so they could drive him there. But "after apparently speaking with someone else," they took him to Larkspur, California, and then to the Immigration and Customs Enforcement field office at 630 Sansome Street in San Francisco.

Only at the field office, Wise wrote, was he shown a purported warrant for his arrest: an I-200 form with no "A-number" listed, "and that bore a supervisory officer's digital signature time-stamped at 6:48:04 a.m." The document, she wrote, "was therefore created at least fourteen minutes after the officers arrested Petitioner on the pretense of having a warrant."

Wise rested the ruling on the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment, which provides that no person shall be "deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law." She quoted the Supreme Court's 2001 decision in Zadvydas v. Davis: "Freedom from imprisonment—from government custody, detention, or other forms of physical restraint—lies at the heart of the liberty that Clause protects."

She then applied the three factors of Mathews v. Eldridge, which weigh the private interest at stake, the risk of an erroneous deprivation and the value of added safeguards, and the government's interest, including the burdens those safeguards would impose. Those factors, Wise wrote, "require that Petitioner be immediately released from custody, and that they be given notice and a pre-detention hearing before a neutral decisionmaker prior to being taken back into custody."

"Petitioner has a substantial private interest in remaining out of custody, which would allow him to take care of his family, and continue his employment," the judge wrote, citing Morrissey v. Brewer. The order says Lopez Perez has lived in the United States for about 22 years, since 2004, and lives with his wife and four U.S. citizen children. The oldest serves in the U.S. Army Reserve after recently completing a period of active duty; the others are 14, 11 and 7.

He has held the same landscaping job for 10 years, according to the order, which quotes his filing: "Apart from a few traffic stops that have been resolved, he has no criminal record."

Wise found the requirements of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65(b)(1) met, writing that his attorney had set out specific facts showing that immediate and irreparable injury "may result before the adverse party can be heard in opposition." "In this case, in light of the minimal risk of harm to the government, the Court determines that security is not required," she wrote.

The order does not set out any position from the respondents, Sergio Albarran and others named in the caption, whose counsel Wise directed to promptly enter notices of appearance.

The respondents were to file a status report by noon on Nov. 19 verifying what time Lopez Perez was released, and to respond to the habeas petition by Nov. 20. That response must include his full Forms I-213, any custody warrants or notices and other relevant portions of his A-File. Wise wrote that a failure to respond on time would be construed as a non-opposition.

Lopez Perez may reply by Nov. 24. Wise set a hearing for 9 a.m. on Nov. 25 by videoconference and said she would evaluate the merits of the habeas petition at the same time as the request for preliminary injunctive relief. In the meantime, she ordered the parties to meet and confer to see whether they can resolve the matter "without further judicial intervention."