Key Points

  • The Fifth District reduced a Madison County jury's $10 million disfigurement award and $10 million loss-of-normal-life award to $5 million each, finding both exceeded the evidence, and gave the plaintiff 30 days on remand to accept the reductions or face a new trial on those damages.
  • The court affirmed $5 million for pain and suffering, $2 million for emotional distress and $75,000 in punitive damages.
  • The court held that evidence that a driver without the right of way crossed into lanes of right-of-way traffic supported a willful-and-wanton punitive-damages claim under section 2-604.1, and that such rulings made without an evidentiary hearing are reviewed de novo.
  • The court upheld the exclusion of the plaintiff's near-daily marijuana use under Illinois Rule of Evidence 403.
  • The court held a "Russian roulette with traffic" closing argument was fair comment, and a "champagne bottles" remark was improper but not substantially prejudicial.

An Illinois appeals court on Nov. 19 cut $10 million from a $27.5 million jury verdict for a motorcyclist struck by a pickup truck that pulled out from a stop sign, holding that the jury's awards for disfigurement and loss of normal life went beyond what the evidence showed. The same panel upheld $75,000 in punitive damages, finding the evidence supported a claim of willful and wanton conduct, which Illinois courts describe as conduct that "exhibits a conscious indifference to consequences."

Writing for a three-justice panel of the Fifth District Appellate Court, Justice Bollinger reduced each of the two $10 million awards to $5 million, concluding that "the $10 million disfigurement award falls outside the range of fair and reasonable compensation this record supports." Presiding Justice Cates and Justice Clarke concurred. The court affirmed $5 million for pain and suffering and $2 million for emotional distress awarded to the plaintiff, Grayson Klucker, against the driver, Ashton Zobrist.

The ruling, which affirmed in part and reversed in part, leaves Klucker a choice. A remittitur, the opinion explained, is a plaintiff's agreement "to remit to defendant that portion of the damages that is excessive, and to accept the sum the court has determined is properly recoverable." If he declines, he faces a new trial on those two categories of damages.

The crash happened on July 4, 2023, at the intersection of Broadway and Route 160 in Madison County. Klucker was riding his motorcycle westbound on Broadway while Zobrist sat at a stop sign on northbound Route 160 in a Ford pickup, intending to cross. Zobrist admitted that cross-traffic had the right of way. One eyewitness testified that his truck appeared to "lunge forward" three or four times before it went on to "gun it through the rest of the intersection."

Klucker, who had recently graduated from high school, suffered open fractures of the tibia and fibula and underwent four surgeries. After a four-day trial in November 2025, the jury returned a verdict of $27,496,213.56, including $421,213.56 in stipulated medical expenses. Zobrist's lawyer had asked the jury, if it found fault, to award $821,213.56 in total.

On disfigurement, the panel said the proof, "while genuine, was limited." The jury saw photographs of the leg taken right after the injury and the surgeries, but "no witness described the present appearance, size, number, or location of plaintiff's scars; plaintiff did not display the leg to the jury; and no photograph of the leg as it appeared at trial was admitted." Justice Bollinger set $5 million as "the outer limit this evidence will bear."

The loss-of-normal-life award, which compensates for a diminished ability to enjoy life, met the same fate. The court credited Klucker's month-long hospitalization, his inability to hunt or to kneel to play with young relatives, and the difficulties that led him to withdraw from the University of Alabama. But it noted that the evidence also showed he "is under no medical restrictions, drives, socializes, is employed, and is again enrolled in school and enjoying his studies."

On punitive damages, Zobrist argued that this was "a simple accident case, not a punitive damages case." Under section 2-604.1 of the Illinois Code of Civil Procedure, a court shall allow a plaintiff to add a punitive claim on a showing of "a reasonable likelihood of proving facts at trial sufficient to support an award of punitive damages." Relying on two Illinois intersection-collision cases, Hering v. Hilton and Yelinich v. Capalongo, the panel held that Klucker met that bar.

"This was not a situation where defendant misjudged the distance of approaching vehicles and reasonably believed he had time to safely enter the intersection," Justice Bollinger wrote. Instead, the vehicles turning left with the right of way "were directly in front of him, and he chose to travel ahead into approaching traffic." Calling that decision a mistake, the court said, quoting Hering, "does not free it from the taint of wilful and wanton misconduct." The panel called the $75,000 punitive award "relatively modest."

The court also held that such rulings get de novo review, without deference to the trial judge, when made "without an evidentiary hearing at which witnesses testified or their credibility was weighed."

The panel upheld the exclusion of testimony from Zobrist's psychiatric expert, Dr. Michael Stachniak, that Klucker's near-daily marijuana use showed he was self-medicating for PTSD before the crash. "The incremental probative value of the marijuana evidence was slight," the court wrote, because the jury had already heard about Klucker's preexisting anxiety, depression and family trauma, and Stachniak himself conceded the PTSD predated the collision. Jurors "may punish a party for perceived moral shortcomings unrelated to the elements of the claim or defenses," the opinion said, citing a 2014 Fifth District decision, Bruntjen v. Bethalto Pizza, LLC.

Klucker's lawyer told jurors that Zobrist's driving "was like a version of Russian roulette with traffic," which the panel called "a permissible rhetorical characterization of the trial evidence, not an appeal to passion." In rebuttal, the lawyer said that if the award came in $1 million under $10 million, the defense was "going to be popping champagne bottles tonight."

The panel held that the champagne remark "was improper as it was not based on the evidence," but that it did not warrant a new trial. The comment concerned damages rather than liability, the court said, and the evidence of liability "was not closely balanced."

Brian J. Talcott of Dinsmore & Shohl, LLP represented the appellant. The appellee was represented by John G. Simon of Simon Law Firm. P.C.

The Fifth District directed the Madison County Circuit Court, where Judge Patrick G. King presided, to give Klucker 30 days from the entry of its order to accept the reduced awards. If he accepts, the trial court will enter judgment on them; if not, it must order a new trial on damages for disfigurement and/or loss of normal life.