Key Points

  • Judge Jennifer L. Rochon denied the grocers' amended motion for a preliminary injunction barring the city from selecting private operators for the N.Y.C. Groceries stores.
  • Assuming without deciding that the 30% discount would set prices below rivals' average variable costs, the court held the grocers could not show a dangerous probability that the city would recoup its losses.
  • The court declined to set aside the recoupment requirement for a taxpayer-funded government market entrant, holding that the Sherman Act's predatory pricing rules apply to a government actor as to any actor.
  • The court also found the grocers could not show specific intent to monopolize and that the balance of hardships and the public interest weigh decidedly against an injunction.
  • The court found the grocers' claimed irreparable harm speculative but did not conclusively resolve that factor.

A federal judge on Nov. 20 refused to block New York City's plan for five city-backed grocery stores that will sell a core basket of food at a 30% discount, ruling that private grocers who called the program illegal predatory pricing had not shown a dangerous probability that the city would recoup its losses by later raising prices.

U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon of the Southern District of New York denied a preliminary injunction sought by the National Supermarket Association and two supermarket operators. They had asked the court to bar the city and the New York City Economic Development Corporation from selecting private operators for the stores until their Sherman Act claims are decided.

The ruling turned on recoupment, which the Supreme Court made one of two prerequisites for predatory pricing claims in Brooke Group Ltd. v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp. A plaintiff must show that a seller pricing below cost has a dangerous probability of making back its losses by charging monopoly prices once rivals are gone. The grocers asked Rochon to drop that requirement for a government entrant whose losses are covered by taxpayers. "The Court declines to adopt Plaintiffs' novel approach," she wrote.

The city announced the program, N.Y.C. Groceries, on July 27, 2026. It calls for one store in each borough offering a 30% discount on a "core basket of goods that will include fresh produce, meat, fish, seafood, plant-based proteins, pantry staples, and other nutritious foods." Private operators will manage the stores, but the city will select sites, fund construction, provide operating subsidies, set pricing standards and waive real estate and property taxes for the operators. It had allocated $70 million to the program as of July 2026.

Two sites have been chosen, at Hunts Point in the Bronx and in East Harlem, with openings targeted for 2027 and 2029. Under the city's request for proposals, operators must charge prices comparable to "typical retail prices" for products outside the core basket.

The association represents more than 150 members who run more than 400 supermarkets in the city. The other plaintiffs, R&E Corporation and the Real Chance Inc., operate supermarkets near the planned Bronx and Manhattan stores that each draw 60% of their sales from core basket goods. Their Sept. 9 complaint alleges that the city's solicitation of bids is attempted monopolization under Section 2 of the Sherman Act and that accepting any bid would create a conspiracy to monopolize.

Rochon assumed, without deciding, that the grocers were likely to satisfy the other prerequisite by showing the discount would set prices below other retailers' average variable costs. "The heart of the dispute, however, lies in Plaintiffs' ability to meet the second prerequisite: a dangerous probability of recoupment," she wrote. "Plaintiffs cannot make that showing here."

The program requires the stores to keep the discount in place, and at a Nov. 12 hearing the grocers conceded there was no basis to find the city would abandon it and later charge supracompetitive prices. The grocers pointed to city statements that the program would cut prices "in ways the private market alone cannot" and serve as "a model for future programs." Rochon called those "errant statements" that did not suggest the city intends to eliminate competition and raise prices later, noting the city's lack of a profit motive.

In asking Rochon to set aside recoupment, the grocers argued that traditional concerns about rational private actors and chilling price competition "simply do not apply when the predator is funded by compulsory taxation." The city responded that they offered no authority for disregarding the requirement "against decades of precedent."

"Without a recoupment prerequisite, Plaintiffs effectively seek to flatten predatory pricing claims to impose liability if a government actor intervenes in a private market resulting in prices below average variable cost," Rochon wrote. Such a rule, she added, "would undermine the federal antitrust laws that exist to promote consumer welfare."

The judge acknowledged that the lower prices at issue do not result from competitive forces. Even so, she wrote, the court "declines to interpret the Sherman Act as condemning conduct that brings about lower prices without a demonstrable harm to competition that disserves consumers."

Rochon also found that two Supreme Court decisions the grocers cited, including a 1941 ruling that a Kansas municipality violated a federal railroad rebate law, did not support a different rule for governments. "Union Pacific does not support the argument that the Sherman Act is applied differently in the context of a government actor," she wrote.

For the same reasons, Rochon found the grocers could not show the specific intent to monopolize that both claims require, a failure she called "fatal to both claims." Because the claims are "clearly foreclosed by established and binding precedent," she held, they also raise no serious questions that could justify an injunction under the more lenient "serious questions" standard.

Rochon further found that the balance of hardships and the public interest "weigh decidedly against granting an injunction," citing food access and affordability problems that are "particularly pressing" in the Bronx and the risk that an injunction could delay the program and raise costs for taxpayers.

On irreparable harm, Rochon wrote that the grocers only speculated that Palero Food, an association member that submitted a bid, would be selected, and that the city had agreed bidders could withdraw if an injunction issued. She said she need not conclusively resolve that question because the grocers failed on the merits.

Eric P Heichel of Eiseman, Levine, Lehrhaupt & Kakoyiannis, P.C. represented the National Supermarket Association. Michelle Soo Yeon Lee of the New York City Law Department represented the City of New York.

The order directs the clerk of court to terminate the motion. The grocers' complaint seeks a permanent injunction and a declaration that an accepted bid would violate Section 2.