Key Points

  • A Section 1983 claim seeking compensation for a regulatory taking of real property is subject to the four-year limitations period in R.C. 2305.09(E), not the two-year period in R.C. 2305.10.
  • The court rejected the Northern District of Ohio's 2024 decision in Riveredge Dentistry Partnership v. City of Cleveland, which applied the two-year period, as elevating form over substance.
  • After Knick v. Township of Scott, an owner may bring a Section 1983 takings claim in an Ohio court without first seeking a writ of mandamus to compel appropriation proceedings.
  • An owner with a final zoning board decision may seek a declaratory judgment that zoning is unconstitutional as applied without first filing an R.C. Chapter 2506 appeal; the Twelfth District overruled Welsh Dev. Co. v. Warren Cty. Regional Planning Comm. to the extent it held otherwise.
  • A request to declare a taking without seeking compensation does not terminate the controversy and was properly dismissed; the judgment was affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.

An Ohio appeals court held Monday that property owners have four years, not two, to sue local governments under a federal statute, 42 U.S.C. 1983, over zoning rules that amount to a taking of their land. The ruling revived an electrical services company's compensation claim and rejected a 2024 federal court decision that applied the shorter deadline.

The Twelfth District Court of Appeals ruled unanimously that such claims fall under R.C. 2305.09(E), a provision added to Ohio law in 2004 that sets a four-year limit for claims "[f]or relief on the grounds of a physical or regulatory taking of real property." Judge Mary Donovan, a retired Second District judge sitting by assignment, wrote the opinion. Presiding Judge Robin N. Piper and Judge Mike Powell concurred.

The panel also held that owners may bring those federal claims in Ohio courts without first seeking a writ of mandamus, a court order forcing the government to start condemnation proceedings under state law. And it overruled its own 2010 decision in Welsh Development Co. v. Warren County Regional Planning Commission to the extent that Welsh suggested an owner must file an administrative appeal before suing to have zoning declared unconstitutional. Together, the holdings reinstate two of three counterclaims that Jackson & Jackson, LLC, filed after the county sued over its business use of residentially zoned land.

Jackson & Jackson provides commercial electrical and emergency response services to help governments restore power lines after storms. In November 2021 it paid $270,000 for about nine acres in Madison Township zoned R-1 "Suburban Residence District," which does not permit commercial uses. The land had nonetheless housed a golf driving range, a pizza business and a church.

The company parked its trucks there and used existing office space. In May 2023 the county ordered it to stop. That August, the county Board of Zoning Appeals denied its request for a use variance, which is permission to use land in a way its zoning does not allow. The company did not appeal but kept operating, and Zoning Inspector Dennis Dickard sued to enjoin it.

Jackson & Jackson counterclaimed in May 2024. Its amended counterclaim, filed in December 2024, sought declarations that the zoning was unconstitutional as applied and that it amounted to a regulatory taking, which occurs when a regulation goes so far that it is treated as taking property. A third count sought compensation under Section 1983.

The Butler County Court of Common Pleas dismissed all three counts. The county had argued that the Section 1983 claim was barred by Ohio's two-year statute of limitations for personal injury claims. It also argued that the company "failed to bring its claims in the form of a writ of mandamus to compel appropriation proceedings."

On the deadline, the county relied on Riveredge Dentistry Partnership v. City of Cleveland, a 2024 decision by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio. That court applied the two-year limit to a Section 1983 takings claim, citing case law that such claims are "best characterized as tort actions." Judge Donovan wrote that the federal court "engaged in no substantive legal or textual analysis as to why a Section 1983 takings claim would not be subsumed within the plain language of R.C. 2305.09(E)."

"We conclude that Riveredge elevated form over substance," Judge Donovan wrote. "This is precisely what the Ohio Supreme Court has held we may not do in assessing the applicability of a statute of limitations."

The panel found a 2003 Sixth Circuit decision the county cited, Trzebuckowski v. City of Cleveland, "of limited import" because it did not appear to involve a takings claim and predated the four-year provision. Under that provision, the court held, the company's claim was timely whether it accrued at the 2021 purchase or at the August 2023 variance denial.

On mandamus, the county argued that Knick v. Township of Scott, the U.S. Supreme Court's 2019 decision letting owners bring takings claims in federal court without first seeking compensation in state court, opened only federal courthouses. Knick, the county said, "did not abrogate the requirement for state litigants to utilize adequate and available state law procedures to request and obtain compensation in state courts."

The appeals court disagreed, citing Ohio Supreme Court precedent that common pleas courts share jurisdiction with federal courts over Section 1983 claims. The panel said the Ohio cases requiring mandamus were decided under the old federal rule, and it held that "Knick has changed the legal landscape and the exhaustion of state remedies, including pursuit of mandamus in Ohio, is no longer a predicate to commencing a Section 1983 takings claim."

The panel then revived the company's request for a declaratory judgment, a ruling that settles the parties' legal rights, that the zoning is unconstitutional as applied. Relying on Ohio Supreme Court precedent, it held that the variance denial was a final decision that made the challenge ripe, so the company did not need to file an administrative appeal under R.C. Chapter 2506 first. "To the extent that Welsh suggests otherwise, it was not an accurate statement of Ohio Supreme Court precedent and is overruled," the court wrote.

The panel upheld dismissal of the second count, which sought a declaration of a taking without asking for compensation, because such a declaration would not end the dispute.

Lawyers for Jackson & Jackson included John P. Burleigh of Suder, LLC. The county was represented by Butler County Prosecuting Attorney Michael T. Gmoser.

The case now returns to the Butler County Court of Common Pleas, where, the opinion said, "Count Two remains dismissed, but Counts One and Three may be pursued in further litigation." Before the appeal, the parties had agreed that the county would be entitled to judgment on its injunction suit if the dismissal were upheld. The appeals court taxed costs 35% to the company and 65% to the county.