Key Points
- The Second Circuit reversed the denial of qualified immunity on Reynolds's post-2017 due process claim, holding that his asserted right to an individualized reclassification process and meaningful annual review was not clearly established.
- The court relied on the jury's special-interrogatory finding that each official reasonably believed Conn. Gen. Stat. § 18-10b required Reynolds's conditions of confinement at Northern.
- The court held that enforcement of a presumptively valid statute creates a heavy presumption in favor of qualified immunity, which Reynolds did not overcome.
- The court dismissed for lack of jurisdiction the appeal of the new-trial order and of the denial of immunity on the Eighth Amendment claim, because that immunity defense turns on disputed facts.
- The appeal as to the October 2010 to April 2017 due process claim was dismissed as moot after the parties stipulated to that claim's dismissal.
A federal appeals court ruled on Nov. 13 that three Connecticut prison officials are shielded from a jury's finding that they denied due process to Richard Reynolds, a former death-row inmate who spent 26 years in solitary confinement, because the right he asserted was not clearly established when they acted.
Chief Judge Lohier of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit wrote for a panel that also included Judges Kearse and Wesley. The court reversed a ruling by Judge Underhill of the U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut that had denied the officials qualified immunity, which shields government officials from money damages unless they violated a clearly established statutory or constitutional right. The panel also dismissed, for lack of jurisdiction, the officials' challenge to a new trial the district court ordered on Reynolds's Eighth Amendment claim.
The decision removes the only claim on which the jury found the officials liable, while leaving Reynolds's cruel-and-unusual-punishment claim headed back toward trial. In reaching it, the panel relied on the rule that "enforcement of a presumptively valid statute" such as the Connecticut law at issue "creates a heavy presumption in favor of qualified immunity."
Reynolds was convicted of the aggravated murder of a police officer and sentenced to death in 1995, according to the opinion. The Connecticut Legislature later abolished the death penalty for future crimes and replaced it with a statute, now section 18-10b of the Connecticut General Statutes, that mandates confinement in a Special Circumstances Unit for capital convictions. After the Connecticut Supreme Court held in 2015 that the death penalty was unconstitutional under the state constitution for sentences already imposed, Reynolds was resentenced to life without the possibility of release and made subject to the statute's conditions.
Reynolds sued current and former Department of Correction officials under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 over his confinement at the Northern Correctional Institution. The defendants are Angel Quiros, a regional warden; Edward Maldonado, a warden at Northern; and Scott Semple, a commissioner of correction.
The case was before the Second Circuit for the second time. In a 2021 decision, the court vacated summary judgment for Reynolds on his Eighth Amendment and due process claims because disputed facts remained, while leaving intact rulings in his favor on other claims, including equal protection. In that decision, the court invalidated the statute as an unconstitutional bill of attainder.
On remand, the district court split the due process claim into two periods: Reynolds's time on death row before 2017, and his confinement in the Special Circumstances Unit from 2017 on. The jury found the officials not liable on the Eighth Amendment claim and the pre-2017 due process claim, but liable for the period from 2017 on. In answers to special interrogatories, the jury also found that each official "reasonably believed" the statute "required Mr. Reynolds to be housed under the conditions of confinement at Northern."
Judge Underhill then denied the officials' motion for judgment as a matter of law, granted Reynolds a new trial on the pre-2017 due process claim, and ordered a new trial on the Eighth Amendment claim. The district court concluded that its pretrial ruling excluding evidence on whether Reynolds's conditions fit the definition of solitary confinement, and its jury instructions, were erroneous, and that the errors rendered "the jury's verdict against the weight of the evidence and a miscarriage of justice."
The officials appealed before final judgment, arguing that undisputed facts from the trial entitled them to immunity on the Eighth Amendment claim. The panel disagreed. "In fact, as the Defendants' argument makes clear, their immunity defense as to that claim depends on unresolved and disputed factual issues," Lohier wrote. "In that regard, not much has changed since we last considered this case on appeal." The court added that the new-trial order itself was not a final decision it could review.
The post-2017 due process claim came out differently because the parties agreed that no factual disputes affected immunity, and neither side challenged the jury's interrogatory answers. The panel assumed without deciding that the statute gave Reynolds a protected liberty interest. Reynolds had asserted a due process right to an individualized reclassification process and meaningful annual review.
Lohier wrote that the court's own 2021 reading of the statute as imposing a "permanent and unreviewable assignment to the Special Circumstances Unit" cut against Reynolds. That reading "confirms that Connecticut's statutory scheme could be reasonably understood to require the very conditions of confinement that Reynolds contests," the opinion said, so "not every reasonable official would have been on notice" that enforcing the statute violated due process.
The panel also found no precedent on Reynolds's side. "We are not aware of any court that held that enforcing § 18-10b or an analogous statute violated a prisoner's right to due process," Lohier wrote, adding that the 2021 ruling struck down the statute "because it constituted an unconstitutional bill of attainder, not because it violated due process." The presumption favoring immunity yields only when officials are "plainly incompetent or . . . knowingly violate the law," the court said, and Reynolds had not overcome it.
Two other parts of the case were not at issue. The parties had stipulated to dismissing the due process claim for conduct between October 2010 and April 2017, so the panel dismissed that part of the appeal as moot. The officials also did not contest the findings of liability and damages on the equal protection claim, the opinion noted.
The officials were represented by Assistant Attorney General James M. Belforti, for Connecticut Attorney General William Tong. Reynolds was represented by Tyler M. Finn of Dynamis LLP.
The panel remanded the case to the district court for further proceedings consistent with its opinion. The Eighth Amendment claim remains subject to the new trial Judge Underhill ordered.