Key Points

  • The Sixth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the non-Michigan offense subclass, holding that the Michigan State Police must provide additional pre-deprivation procedures before requiring registration and assigning tiers based on out-of-state convictions.
  • The court vacated the ex post facto rulings (Counts I and II) and the plea-agreement claim (Count VI) and remanded for the district court to decide whether People v. Smith moots them.
  • The panel unanimously held that SORA 2021's offense-based tiers and limits on petitioning for removal survive rational-basis review, and that the challenged education, employment and vehicle reporting provisions are not facially vague.
  • Judge Nalbandian dissented from the procedural-due-process holding, saying the district court failed to identify the liberty interests at stake and the issue should be remanded.
  • In a companion case, the same panel held that SORA's in-person reporting requirements are not Fourth Amendment seizures and affirmed dismissal.

A federal appeals court held on Nov. 13 that the Michigan State Police must give people convicted of sex offenses in other states notice and a chance to be heard before deciding whether they must register in Michigan and at what tier. The same ruling rejected a broader constitutional attack on the registry's design.

Judge Karen Nelson Moore wrote for a divided U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit panel, joined by Judge Mathis. Judge Nalbandian joined most of the opinion but dissented from the out-of-state holding and would have sent that issue back to the trial court.

The decision leaves Michigan's 2021 rewrite of its Sex Offenders Registration Act, known as SORA 2021, intact against challenges to its offense-based tiers, its limits on petitioning for removal and the clarity of its reporting duties. The panel also vacated a ruling that the law's retroactive reach violates the Ex Post Facto Clause, which bars laws that increase punishment for past crimes, because the Michigan Supreme Court has since reached the same conclusion.

The registrants sued in February 2022 on behalf of everyone who is or will be subject to registration under SORA 2021. U.S. District Judge Mark A. Goldsmith in Detroit ruled for them on the ex post facto and out-of-state claims, and the Sixth Circuit stayed that judgment in June 2025.

After oral argument in July, the Michigan Supreme Court held in People v. Smith that SORA 2021 cannot be applied retroactively to registrants whose offenses predate the law's 2011 amendments. The state police said they had removed more than 20,000 offenders from the registry in September but that "these numbers could change."

The state argued that Smith was not final because it could still be reconsidered or reviewed by the U.S. Supreme Court. Moore wrote that "as MSP continues to adjust its practices in light of Smith, the facts underlying Counts I and II present" what an earlier decision called "a moving target." Agreeing with the registrants, the panel sent those claims back for the district court to decide whether they are moot and returned a related plea-agreement claim for consideration in light of Smith.

SORA 2021 requires people with out-of-state sex-offense convictions who move to, work in or study in Michigan to register if the offense is "substantially similar" to a Michigan registrable offense or if the convicting state requires registration. The statute defines neither standard. The state police apply them without regulations, using a spreadsheet of more than 2,200 out-of-state offenses on which only 18 comparisons are marked as approved by the agency's legal office.

The agency gives those registrants no notice or opportunity to be heard and has no formal appeal process, the court said. Quoting the record, the opinion said the agency "does not monitor other states' registry laws, does not know when other states change their laws, and thus does not remove people with non-Michigan convictions who are no longer subject to registration in their convicting jurisdiction." The subclass representatives, Mary Doe and John Doe G, say their registration terms expired in their convicting states but continue in Michigan because the agency wrongly placed them in tier III.

Moore wrote that misclassification implicates a liberty interest under the stigma-plus test, which asks whether government action both damaged a person's reputation and removed a right previously held under state law. Even tier I registrants kept off the public website must report in person and pay fees, the court said. The state conceded at oral argument that registrants have "an interest in not being misclassified."

The panel rejected the state's argument that a criminal conviction supplies all the process due, because "for individuals with non-Michigan convictions, their convictions alone do not determine their reporting requirements under SORA 2021." It also rejected the argument that a later lawsuit was enough. "Here, nothing about the MSP's process is random or unauthorized," Moore wrote.

Nalbandian wrote that the trial court never identified what liberty interest was at stake. The dissent said SORA 2021 differs from the law the circuit reviewed in its 2020 decision in Hart v. Hillsdale County because it dropped student safety zones and stopped publishing tiers online. "SORA is not what it used to be," Nalbandian wrote, adding that "a court cannot properly apply the Mathews balancing test without a clear view of what it is that it's balancing." That test weighs the private interest, the risk of error and the government's interest.

On the registry's structure, the panel unanimously upheld tiers based on the offense of conviction rather than individual risk assessments. It applied rational-basis review. The registrants offered data suggesting that public registries may increase recidivism. Moore wrote that the scholarly consensus they identified "may well establish that an offense-based public registry like SORA 2021's is unwise, even foolish," but, quoting circuit precedent, that such review "is not a license for courts to judge the wisdom, fairness or logic of legislative choices."

The court also upheld limits on which registrants may petition for removal from the registry. It rejected vagueness challenges to reporting duties tied to education, employment and vehicles.

In a companion opinion for the same panel, Moore wrote that SORA's in-person reporting requirements are not Fourth Amendment seizures, and the court affirmed dismissal of a separate suit. Comparing the requirements to a court summons, Moore wrote that "if anything, the reporting requirements restrain the plaintiffs' liberty less than being required to appear in court," because registrants can choose the day they report.

Miriam Aukerman of the American Civil Liberties Union Fund of Michigan argued for the registrants. Eric Jamison of the Michigan Attorney General's office argued for the state. Sarah Prescott of Salvatore Prescott Porter & Porter PLLC was among the lawyers for amici curiae.

The case now returns to the district court, which must decide whether Smith moots the ex post facto claims and consider the plea-agreement claim in light of Smith. The judgment requiring additional procedures before the state police register people with out-of-state convictions stands affirmed. The state did not challenge a separate ruling that the process violates equal protection, so the panel did not address it.