Key Points

  • A plaintiff seeking a preliminary injunction must show, and the district court must find, a reasonable likelihood that the court has personal jurisdiction, and the court need not accept the plaintiff's jurisdictional allegations as true when they are challenged.
  • False-advertising claims arise out of sales to deceived consumers, so test purchases by the plaintiff's own lawyers do not connect those claims to Pennsylvania.
  • Listing products on Amazon is not a contact with Pennsylvania, and a single shipment into the state is at most the bare minimum, requiring a closely related claim.
  • The Third Circuit vacated the denial of the preliminary injunction and remanded for the district court to decide whether some defendants waived personal jurisdiction and to allow further development of the jurisdictional record.
  • The opinion said district court standing orders in Schedule A cases on the test-buy question seemed to exceed those courts' authority to make procedural rules.

A federal appeals court held on Nov. 20 that a flashlight seller suing 153 Chinese competitors for false advertising had not shown, at the preliminary-injunction stage, a reasonable likelihood that flashlights its own lawyers bought on Amazon gave a Pennsylvania court power over them, because such claims arise from sales to consumers who were deceived, and the lawyers were not. "False-advertising claims arise out of sales to deceived consumers, not resourceful lawyers," Judge Bibas wrote for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit.

The panel, which also included Judges Hardiman and Rendell, said the trial judge "rightly found no reasonable likelihood of success on personal jurisdiction," and so denied Promier Products Inc. a preliminary injunction. Promier had asked for an order freezing the sellers' bank accounts and their access to Amazon and other online marketplaces. The panel nonetheless vacated the denial and sent the case back so the district court could decide whether some defendants waived the jurisdiction defense and could develop the record further.

The opinion holds that a plaintiff seeking a preliminary injunction must show, and the district court must find, "a reasonable likelihood that the court has personal jurisdiction." When a defendant challenges jurisdiction at that stage, the court need not accept the plaintiff's factual allegations as true. At the motion-to-dismiss stage, by contrast, a plaintiff needs only a prima facie case, and absent an evidentiary hearing the court must accept its jurisdictional allegations as true.

Promier, an Illinois company, sells flashlights on Amazon, and the opinion describes brightness as a flashlight's "big selling point." Suspecting that rival Amazon sellers were overstating how bright their products were, Promier hired a Pittsburgh law firm, which bought flashlights on Amazon and had them shipped to its office. Promier alleged that more than three-quarters of them "produced less than one percent of the lumens advertised," and it sued all 153 sellers in a single case in the Western District of Pennsylvania under state common law and the Lanham Act.

Judge Robert J. Colville first ordered Promier to show cause on venue and personal jurisdiction. He then issued the temporary restraining order Promier had sought ex parte, giving it the broad relief it requested. After a few dozen defendants appeared in three groups and contested the order, the judge reconsidered. He held, as the appeals court put it, that Promier's lawyers "could not use their own test buys to manufacture jurisdiction," and he also questioned whether joining all 153 defendants in one suit was proper. Promier did not challenge the joinder ruling on appeal.

Judge Bibas wrote that the injunction stage calls for closer scrutiny than a motion to dismiss. "A preliminary injunction is different: Like a binding judgment, it puts the defendant's liberty and property in present danger," he wrote. Such an order can also push a defendant to "bargain desperately to buy his way out of the injunction," he added, quoting a Tenth Circuit concurrence by Judge McConnell and citing a law review article for the point that plaintiffs "regularly get such settlements in Lanham Act suits like this one."

On the merits of jurisdiction, the panel held that listing a product on Amazon, which it called "a nationwide retailer," is not a contact with Pennsylvania. Shipping a single item into the state might be "the bare minimum," the court said, and so would have to be paired with a claim closely tied to that shipment. False advertising injures a competitor when deceived buyers withhold trade from it, the opinion said, and the law firm was not deceived.

Promier also argued that the test purchases suggested other sales to Pennsylvania consumers. The panel was not persuaded. "And here, the sales to Promier's lawyers add nothing beyond what a screenshot of an Amazon profile would reveal—that defendants are willing and able to ship to all fifty states," Judge Bibas wrote.

The panel said five other circuits had addressed similar facts on motions to dismiss and reached "four different holdings." The Second and Seventh circuits found jurisdiction even when the purchase was made on the plaintiff's behalf. The Ninth Circuit found jurisdiction where the plaintiff was from the forum state but suggested the result might differ if an item was bought on the plaintiff's behalf just to create jurisdiction. The Eighth and Fifth circuits found no jurisdiction where the plaintiff alleged only one sale into the state.

The opinion also criticized two district courts within the circuit, in New Jersey and western Pennsylvania, that had issued standing orders in what they captioned "Schedule A" cases, stating that a plaintiff cannot create jurisdiction by ordering a product shipped to the forum. The panel said those courts were "effectively trying to settle a contested question of constitutional law in the guise of administrative rules." Though "seemingly exceeding those courts' authority to make procedural rules," Judge Bibas wrote, the orders "highlight the need for guidance from this Court."

The panel faulted the district court on one point: it had not addressed whether some defendants gave up the jurisdiction defense. Promier argued that the two groups of defendants that answered the complaint waived it. The opinion notes that a defendant may forfeit the defense by asking for affirmative relief without first resolving jurisdiction, and it directs the district court to consider the injunction request "afresh" for any defendant that did so.

Stanley D. Ference, III of Ference & Associates represented the appellant. Shaoyi Che of YoungZeal LLP represented the appellee.

For defendants that did not waive the defense, the panel said the denial "does not end the case." It wrote that the district court would presumably revisit jurisdiction on remand, perhaps by allowing jurisdictional discovery or by holding an evidentiary hearing. Given the sellers' Amazon presence and evident willingness to ship to Pennsylvania, Promier's allegations of other sales "are not frivolous," the court said. To establish jurisdiction at trial, Promier will need to prove at least one sale to a deceived Pennsylvania consumer by a preponderance of the evidence; the panel did not decide whether one sale would be enough.