Key Points
- The Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed the Appellate Division's order, with costs, and answered the certified question in the affirmative, leaving in place the denial of the defendants' CPLR 3211 (a) (7) motion to dismiss a podiatric malpractice complaint.
- The court held the defendants failed to establish as a matter of law that they were entitled to immunity under the Emergency or Disaster Treatment Protection Act in effect at the relevant time.
- Podiatrists are not listed health care professionals under Public Health Law former § 3081 (4) (a), and they do not qualify under paragraphs (4) (b), (c), (d) or (f).
- The defendants did not show that their April 6, 2020 treatment rested on COVID-19 emergency rules relaxing HIPAA compliance.
- Executive Order 202.1's suspension of Public Health Law § 2999-cc did not bring the April 8, 2020 treatment within an emergency rule's authority, because § 2999-cc governed Medicaid reimbursement for telehealth and never prohibited care by telephone.
New York's highest court ruled Nov. 19 that a podiatry practice sued for malpractice had failed to show it was immune under the Emergency or Disaster Treatment Protection Act, a 2020 law, since repealed, that offered immunity to health care professionals as the statute defined them. The Court of Appeals held that podiatrists are not among the professionals the law listed, and that the practice had not shown its treatment fell "within the scope of authority permitted by a COVID-19 emergency rule," the statute's remaining route to coverage.
The decision was unanimous and issued as a memorandum, with Chief Judge Wilson and Judges Rivera, Garcia, Singas, Cannataro, Troutman and Halligan concurring. The court affirmed the order of the Appellate Division "with costs" and answered a certified question in the affirmative. The result leaves in place the lower courts' refusal to dismiss the podiatric malpractice complaint that plaintiff Robert Zain brought against Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, P.C., and other defendants.
The core of the ruling concerns that remaining route, a catch-all provision for care provided under a COVID-19 emergency rule. The practice had pointed to a March 2020 executive order suspending part of a telehealth statute, but the court held that statute had never barred the care at issue. "Section 2999-cc did not, even before the executive order at issue, prohibit podiatrists or other health care professionals from providing medical care via telephone," the memorandum said.
The case reached the high court on the defendants' CPLR 3211 (a) (7) motion to dismiss the complaint for failure to state a cause of action. The lower courts properly denied that motion, the court held, because the defendants "failed to establish as a matter of law that they are entitled to immunity" under the act "in effect at the relevant time." The memorandum cites the statute as Public Health Law former §§ 3080-3082, enacted as part of chapter 56 of the Laws of 2020.
The court first disposed of the statute's list of covered professionals. "As defendants acknowledge, podiatrists are not among the listed health care professionals in Public Health Law former § 3081 (4) (a)," the court wrote. It added that podiatrists also do not qualify under paragraphs (4) (b), (c), (d) or (f), the definition's other categories.
That left paragraph (4) (e), which reached those "providing health care services within the scope of authority permitted by a COVID-19 emergency rule." The court did not decide whether the practice's work counted as "health care services" under the statute's then-current definition in former § 3081 (5). Instead it assumed so "for the sake of argument" and held that the defendants still had not shown that their services fell within an emergency rule's authority.
The memorandum took the two treatments at issue separately. As to the practice's April 6, 2020 treatment of Zain, the court held that the defendants "did not establish that this treatment was pursuant to COVID-19 emergency rules relaxing compliance with the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA)." The memorandum does not elaborate further on that date.
For the April 8, 2020 treatment, the defendants relied on Executive Order No. 202.1, which the memorandum cites as issued by A. Cuomo and effective March 12, 2020. Among other things, the order suspended Public Health Law § 2999-cc "to the extent necessary to allow additional telehealth provider categories and modalities," according to the memorandum.
The court agreed with part of the defendants' reading. It wrote that the defendants "are correct that the definition of 'telehealth'" in the version of § 2999-cc (4) then in effect "did not include 'audio-only telephone communication,'" unless that communication was used in conjunction with "telemedicine."
But the court held that the definition did not control what care a provider could lawfully give. Section 2999-cc, the court wrote, "governed which telehealth services were reimbursable by Medicaid pursuant to Public Health Law former § 2999-dd (1)." Because the statute never barred care by telephone, the court reasoned, the order's suspension of it did not supply the authority the immunity provision required. "Defendants therefore failed to establish that their April 8 treatment of plaintiff was within the scope of authority permitted by a COVID-19 emergency rule," the court concluded.
A footnote traces the law's later history. After the events in the case, the court noted, the Legislature narrowed the definition of "health care services" in former § 3081 (5) through chapter 134 of the Laws of 2020. The Legislature then "repealed the EDTPA in its entirety in 2021," in chapter 96 of the Laws of 2021, according to the footnote. The court applied the version of the law in effect when the treatment occurred.
The memorandum does not describe the treatment Zain received or the injury alleged, and it does not address whether the practice's care met the professional standard. Its holding is limited to the immunity defense raised on the motion to dismiss, which it held the defendants had not established as a matter of law.
Megan A. Lawless represented the appellants. Jonathan R. Ratchik represented the respondent.
With the Appellate Division's order affirmed, the denial of the motion to dismiss stands, and Zain's podiatric malpractice claim remains in the case. The memorandum, issued as 2026 NY Slip Op 06860, is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.