Key Points
- The court granted the Texas Department of Transportation's motion for summary judgment (ECF No. 39) on all counts and dismissed all of Lynn Phillips' claims with prejudice.
- Phillips' Rehabilitation Act failure-to-accommodate and discrimination claims failed because the undisputed record showed she could not perform her job's essential functions even while approved to work remotely full time, and she could not show her disability was the sole cause of the agency's actions.
- Her Rehabilitation Act retaliation claim failed because two years passed between her first accommodation request and her firing, too long to show a causal connection by timing.
- Her Title VII claims failed because she identified no job requirement that conflicted with her Christian beliefs, and her supervisor's three instances of praying for her were mere utterances that did not alter her conditions of employment.
- Her ADA and FMLA claims were dismissed on sovereign immunity grounds, which she did not contest.
A federal judge in Fort Worth has granted the Texas Department of Transportation summary judgment against a landscape architect who was fired after cancer treatment, holding that an undisputed record of missed deadlines and unfinished work, compiled while the agency let her work remotely nearly full time, showed she could not perform the essential functions of her job. Summary judgment is available when there is no genuine dispute over the material facts.
The Nov. 19 opinion and order from the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas granted the agency's motion on every count and dismissed all claims by Lynn Phillips with prejudice. The court also rejected her religious hostile work environment claim, which rested on a supervisor's prayers for her, describing those episodes as "mere utterances . . . which engender[ed] offensive feelings" that did not alter her conditions of employment.
The decision turns on the Rehabilitation Act's requirement that a disability plaintiff be a "qualified individual," someone who can perform a job's essential functions with or without reasonable accommodation. The court held that Phillips' promotion and positive reviews from 2013 to 2018 did not carry that burden for the years in dispute, and that the same performance record also defeated her disability discrimination and Title VII religious discrimination claims.
According to the order, Phillips was hired in September 2013 and worked at the agency's Fort Worth District Headquarters, most recently as a Transportation Landscape Architect III. Her amended complaint states that she was diagnosed with anal cancer in October 2018 and that treatment left her with severe long-term side effects, including unpredictable fecal incontinence.
The order recounts that the agency, whose policy was to evaluate telework requests case by case, first allowed her to work from home two days a week in 2021. In September 2021 it approved her to work remotely "100% except for occasional site visits and drug testing," and it extended that arrangement in April 2022. She received a disciplinary letter in July 2022, was placed on 12-month probation in March 2023, signed a performance improvement plan in April 2023 and was fired on Aug. 28, 2023.
Phillips had argued that her earlier promotion and reviews showed she was qualified. The court disagreed. "Although she may have once been a qualified individual, before her cancer and related cancer treatments, the present dispute arises out of events that took place between 2021 to 2023," the order states. "The summary judgment record shows that Plaintiff could not perform her essential functions."
The order cites an agency affidavit stating that, after the improvement plan, Phillips "continued to fail to respond to requests, complete required course, perform requested work" and canceled standing meetings with her supervisor. "Plaintiff does not dispute the above characterization of her performance issues—in fact she raises no evidence that suggests she performed adequately during the disputed time," the court wrote. Because she was not qualified, the court did not reach whether the agency knew of her limitations or failed to accommodate them.
The same record sank her Rehabilitation Act discrimination claim. That statute requires a plaintiff to show she was discriminated against "solely by reason of her or his disability," a standard Phillips conceded applies. Given the evidence that she routinely missed deadlines and did not follow the improvement plan, the court held, she could not show the agency acted against her "solely" because of her disability.
Her retaliation claim failed on timing. Phillips first requested an accommodation in August 2021 and was fired two years later. Citing a 2026 Fifth Circuit decision, Hayes v. GStek Inc., which found in the ADA context that a three-month gap between an initial accommodation request and termination did not satisfy the "very close" standard, the court wrote that "the two years that elapsed between the initial accommodation requested and Plaintiff's termination is not close enough to establish liability."
The Title VII claims stemmed from Phillips' allegations that her supervisor, Matt Evans, prayed with and over her, in the office and by phone, for good outcomes from her cancer treatment, and that in February 2021 he prayed over her and her husband by phone after her then-husband suffered a heart attack. The order notes that she never asked Evans to stop and never reported the prayers to anyone at the agency.
On the religious discrimination claim, the court held that Phillips, who is Christian, identified no job requirement that conflicted with her beliefs. "Plaintiff merely alleges that although she is a Christian, she was very uncomfortable with Mr. Evans' religious activity at work," the order states. It added that "the summary judgment evidence shows that Plaintiff was fired for a myriad of performance issues."
On the hostile work environment claim, the court weighed the frequency and severity of the conduct and whether it was threatening or humiliating. It found that "Plaintiff's own testimony raises only three specific instances of religious conduct by her supervisor, Evans," and that "each instance came at a time where Plaintiff or her husband struggled with their health or relationship." Asked about the prayers at her deposition, Phillips said only that "it made me uncomfortable and didn't seem appropriate," according to the order.
Phillips' claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Family and Medical Leave Act fell without contest. The agency argued that both were barred by sovereign immunity, and Phillips did not dispute it, the order states.
Phillips filed the suit on Aug. 26, 2025, and amended her complaint in September 2025. The order, entered as ECF No. 58, grants the agency's motion in full and dismisses all of her claims with prejudice.