Key Points

  • The Supreme Court denied certiorari in Novotny v. Moore, leaving in place the Fourth Circuit's decision in Kipke v. Moore upholding Maryland's bans on carrying firearms in various sensitive places.
  • Justice Thomas, writing alone in a statement respecting the denial, agreed with the decision not to grant review because each Maryland statute implicates a distinct historical tradition and the breadth of the challenge would complicate review.
  • Thomas wrote that he is skeptical each Maryland law is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation under Bruen and that similar laws in New Jersey, New York and California stand on questionable historical ground.
  • Thomas wrote that the Court should consider the scope of states' authority to ban firearms in sensitive places in an appropriate and more narrowly focused case.

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland's bans on carrying guns in a long list of public places, from bars and mass transit to state parks, leaving in place a federal appeals court decision that upheld the restrictions.

The Court's order in the case, Novotny v. Moore, gave no reasons. Justice Thomas agreed that the Court should not take up the case, but in a statement respecting the denial, which no other justice joined, he wrote that he is "skeptical" that each of Maryland's laws is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of gun regulation.

Thomas's objection to granting review went to the shape of the case, not its merits. "Because each Maryland statute implicates a distinct historical tradition of firearm regulation, the breadth of petitioners' challenge would complicate our review," he wrote. He added that "in an appropriate and more narrowly focused case, however, we should consider the scope of States' authority to ban firearms in 'sensitive places,'" the category of locations, such as courthouses, where the Court has recognized a history of weapons bans.

The challengers, led by Katherine Novotny, brought the case against Maryland Gov. Wes Moore and others. Under Maryland law, a person may not carry a firearm at public demonstrations, on mass transit, in places of amusement, in healthcare facilities, in locations that sell alcohol for onsite consumption, or on what Thomas described as "tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land."

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit upheld the restrictions in Kipke v. Moore, concluding that each law banned firearms in a "sensitive place." Thomas wrote that the appeals court "upheld all but one of Maryland's locational restrictions."

The governing test comes from New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, the Court's 2022 Second Amendment decision. Under Bruen, Thomas wrote, a state that restricts the right to bear arms, including by limiting where a law-abiding citizen may carry a gun, must show that the law is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. The Second Amendment, he wrote, recognizes an "inherent" right to keep and bear firearms, "a right that admits of only historically grounded exceptions."

Thomas wrote that the tradition of sensitive-place bans is narrow. He noted that Bruen observed that early American legislatures sometimes prohibited weapons in "legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses," and he quoted Bruen's statement that "[T]he historical record yields relatively few 18th- and 19th-century 'sensitive places' where weapons were altogether prohibited." Bruen also warned, he wrote, that expanding the category "to all places of public congregation . . . would eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense."

"Nevertheless, States have seized on the idea of 'sensitive places' to prohibit the peaceable carry of firearms in locations that bear little resemblance to legislatures, polling places, or courthouses," Thomas wrote. He cited New Jersey, which bars guns in at least 25 locations, including zoos, public libraries, casinos and state-owned beaches. New York has designated 20 locations as sensitive, he wrote, ranging from "any place of worship" to certain licensed residential settings.

California's 29 gun-free spaces, Thomas wrote, include athletic facilities, financial institutions and any government-permitted "public gathering or special event." In a footnote, he cited Illinois and Hawaii as other states that ban firearms in many public places.

"These restrictions stand on questionable historical ground," Thomas wrote. Their combined effect, he added, "is to prohibit firearms wherever people gather for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement, and free speech," which he called "an affront to the right of 'law-abiding citizens' to 'carr[y] arms in public for' their 'ordinary self-defense.'"

Thomas also faulted the federal appeals courts. "The lower courts have largely blessed these ahistorical ventures," he wrote. He pointed to a Third Circuit panel decision in Koons v. Attorney General of New Jersey that upheld many of that state's sensitive-place laws; the full Third Circuit later granted rehearing and vacated the decision.

He also cited the Second Circuit's 2024 ruling in Antonyuk v. James, which upheld New York laws barring guns in treatment centers, urban parks, zoos, places that serve alcohol and theaters. And he cited the Ninth Circuit's 2024 ruling in Wolford v. Lopez, which upheld bans in parks, playgrounds, bars and restaurants that serve alcohol, places of amusement, and parking areas connected to sensitive places. The Supreme Court reversed the Ninth Circuit's Wolford decision on other grounds this year.

"I harbor serious doubts that our Nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions," Thomas wrote in closing. "In an appropriate case, this Court should consider whether particular sensitive-place laws are consistent with the right to public carry."

David H. Thompson of Cooper & Kirk, PLLC is counsel of record for the challengers, and Ryan Robert Dietrich of the Office of the Attorney General of Maryland is counsel of record for the state officials, according to the Supreme Court's docket.

The denial leaves the Fourth Circuit's decision in Kipke in place. Under Thomas's statement, the kind of case he would have the Court hear is one aimed at particular sensitive-place laws rather than a state's full slate of location bans.