Key Points
- The Second Circuit denied rehearing en banc in Miller v. McDonald after a poll in which no majority favored review.
- Judges Park and Menashi each wrote a dissent, and each was joined by the other and by Judge Bianco; Judge Schwartz took no part.
- The denial leaves in place a panel ruling that Mahmoud v. Taylor does not require strict scrutiny of New York's school vaccine law, which has had no religious exemption since 2019.
- Judge Park argued the panel wrongly limited Mahmoud to ideological indoctrination and weighed the state's health interest before deciding whether the law burdens religion.
- Judge Menashi argued the law is not generally applicable because it keeps a medical exemption, and wrote that the decision entrenches a circuit split.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on Nov. 17 refused to reconsider its decision upholding New York's school vaccination law against a challenge by three Amish schools. Since 2019 the law has allowed no religious exemptions, and the state fined the schools $118,000 for a single day of noncompliance.
The court's order said an active judge had requested a poll on rehearing the case en banc and that no majority favored it. Judges Michael H. Park and Steven J. Menashi each wrote a dissent joined by the other and by Judge Joseph F. Bianco. Judge Matthew A. Schwartz took no part.
The denial leaves in place a June 30 panel ruling that the Supreme Court's 2025 decision in Mahmoud v. Taylor does not reach New York's vaccine requirement. Mahmoud held that laws substantially interfering with parents' religious upbringing of their children face strict scrutiny, which requires a state to show its law is narrowly tailored to a compelling interest. Judge Menashi wrote that the panel's ruling also entrenches a split among appeals courts over vaccine mandates with medical but not religious exemptions.
"The panel’s errors misstate First Amendment law and threaten dire consequences for Amish families in New York," Judge Park wrote.
According to Judge Park's dissent, New York's compulsory school vaccination law, Public Health Law § 2164 (PHL 2164), dates to 1966. It originally exempted children whose parents held "genuine and sincere religious beliefs" against vaccination. The legislature repealed that exemption in 2019, after measles outbreaks in Brooklyn and Rockland County. Judge Park wrote that New York thereby became the second state, after California, to disallow religious exemptions.
The plaintiffs are Old Order Amish parents Joseph Miller, Ezra Wengerd and Jonas Smucker and three one- or two-room schools: Dygert Road School, Pleasant View School and Shady Lane School. The parents told the court that "We believe it would be an abomination to our Creator to inject such [vaccines] into our bodies." They said that homeschooling "is not an option" because it would cut their children off from the community.
In 2021 the state Department of Health audited the schools, according to Judge Park's dissent. No case of measles had been reported in New York's Amish community, but the legislature had directed the department to target private schools with high rates of religious exemptions. The department fined the schools $118,000, representing "one day of noncompliance, for each school, respectively," at $2,000 per student per day.
The parents and schools sued Health Commissioner James V. McDonald and Education Commissioner Betty A. Rosa under Section 1983, claiming the law violated the First Amendment's Free Exercise Clause. A federal district court dismissed the complaint, finding the law neutral and generally applicable. In March 2025 a Second Circuit panel affirmed under rational-basis review.
The Supreme Court then granted the plaintiffs' petition, vacated the panel's ruling and sent the case back for reconsideration in light of Mahmoud. On remand the panel affirmed again, holding that Mahmoud is limited to cases involving "ideological indoctrination" and that the state's interest in health and safety set vaccination apart. The panel wrote, quoting the Fourth Circuit, that "The need for some to protect the health and well-being of all was not present in Yoder or Mahmoud." Yoder was the Supreme Court's 1972 decision holding that Wisconsin's compulsory-schooling law unconstitutionally burdened Amish families' religious practice.
Judge Park called that reasoning "backwards." "Protecting the health and well-being of students may well be a state interest of the highest order. But that enters into the analysis only after deciding whether the law burdens the free exercise of religion," he wrote. Otherwise, he added, "the free exercise right under Yoder and Mahmoud would end wherever government’s good intentions begin."
The panel had distinguished the Supreme Court's 2026 decision in Mirabelli v. Bonta, which Judge Park cited, as "a case about school officials concealing from parents a matter central to their child’s identity and upbringing." Judge Menashi responded that "It is not the role of a secular court to tell Amish parents that their beliefs about vaccination and communal schooling do not even implicate 'a matter central to their child’s identity and upbringing.'"
Judge Menashi's dissent offered a second ground. He wrote that "even if the panel were correct that Mahmoud and Yoder do not apply in this case, strict scrutiny would still be required because § 2164 is not generally applicable." The law still exempts children for medical reasons, he noted. "A medically unvaccinated child attending school and a religiously unvaccinated child attending school will both pose the same risk of facilitating disease transmission," he wrote.
"The panel’s decision entrenches a circuit split," Judge Menashi wrote. By his account, the First and Tenth Circuits have recognized that granting medical but not religious exemptions can defeat a policy's general applicability, while the Second Circuit has joined the Third, Fourth and Ninth Circuits in allowing the government to pursue its interests only against religiously motivated conduct.
"If the panel decision stands, PHL 2164 appears likely to result in the closure of every Amish school in the state," Judge Park wrote in closing.
Lawyers for the Amish parents and schools included Shannon G. Denmark of Lehotsky Keller Cohn LLP. Mark S. Grube, a senior assistant solicitor general appearing for New York Attorney General Letitia James, represented the health commissioner. Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall filed an amicus brief for Alabama and 19 other states in support of the plaintiffs.
The case is already back at the Supreme Court. Judge Menashi's dissent cites an amicus brief filed there on Nov. 2, 2026, supporting the petitioners in Miller v. McDonald, No. 26-438.