Key Points

  • The Sixth Circuit held that the district court's burden-shifting jury instructions under the Michigan Uniform Trade Secrets Act were not erroneous: InterMotive had to prove sales caused by the misappropriation, and Ford then had to prove setoffs and deductions.
  • The court rejected Ford's argument that the statute's 'caused by' language required InterMotive to apportion profits between protected and unprotected features, and found the evidence sufficient to support an award of Ford's entire $13,209,300 in module profits.
  • The court held that the jury could reasonably find InterMotive's trade secret, the use of programmable inputs in an upfitter interface module, was not publicly disclosed by InterMotive's 2014 power center product.
  • On InterMotive's cross-appeal, the court affirmed cancellation of a $349,867 Lanham Act award as a duplicative recovery of the same profits, the denial of enhanced damages and of prejudgment interest on that award, the ruling that Michigan law does not permit disgorgement for breach of a nondisclosure agreement, and the exclusion of an implied-in-law contract theory for lack of notice.

A federal appeals court on Nov. 16 upheld a $13.2 million jury verdict that strips Ford Motor Co. of its entire profits from a vehicle electronics module, ruling that Ford, rather than the company whose trade secret the jury found it misappropriated, bore the burden of proving which of those profits came from something else.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the judgment for InterMotive Inc. and its founder, Gregory E. Schafer, on every issue raised by both sides. Judge Clay wrote the opinion for a panel that also included Chief Judge Kethledge and Judge Nalbandian. No judge wrote separately.

The ruling upholds the trial court's use of burden-shifting under the Michigan Uniform Trade Secrets Act for InterMotive's disgorgement claim in this case. The plaintiff proves the sales the misappropriation caused, and the defendant then proves its costs and any profit owed to other features. Ford had argued that the statute required InterMotive to make that split, known as apportionment, under a rule borrowed from patent law.

The dispute concerns the Upfitter Interface Module, an electronic control unit that lets specialty vehicle builders, known as upfitters, plug added equipment into a vehicle's onboard network without splicing its wiring. Schafer, a former Ford engineer, founded InterMotive in 1996. In 2011 the two companies began working on a module InterMotive would design for Ford, under a confidential disclosure agreement.

In December 2012, InterMotive gave Ford the specification for a second-phase module that contained the trade secret at issue: the use of programmable inputs in the device. Ford told InterMotive in early 2013 that it would not go forward. Ford announced in 2016 that several 2017 vehicles would carry its own module. When InterMotive raised concerns, Ford sued it on trademark claims. InterMotive counterclaimed, alleging trade secret misappropriation and other claims.

After a trial in the Eastern District of Michigan before U.S. District Judge Terrence George Berg, a jury in November 2023 found that $13,209,300 of Ford's module profits were caused by the misappropriation. That figure matched, to the dollar, the worldwide module profits calculated by Ford's own damages expert, Sara Rinke. The district court later added $3,011,092 in prejudgment interest.

On appeal, Ford challenged the jury instruction that told jurors to award its profits from sales caused by the misappropriation "after deducting any setoffs or costs that Ford has shown should not be included in calculating the net profit." "The Court finds that the district court's burden-shifting approach and instructions to the jury were not erroneous, as they were tailored to the circumstances presented by this particular case," Judge Clay wrote.

The court likened the framework to the rule for recovering an infringer's profits in copyright cases, citing its own 2024 copyright precedent. It said the approach also "accounts for the reality that Ford is in a better position to provide an apportionment analysis to the jury," because Ford could more easily review its own profits and design costs.

The instructions still "adequately required InterMotive to prove that any unjust enrichment the jury finds Ford acquired was 'caused by' Ford's misappropriation as required by the MUTSA," the opinion said. Ford remained free to present its own apportionment evidence, Judge Clay wrote; "the burden just did not rest with InterMotive to adduce such evidence in this case."

Ford also argued that nothing in the record showed that all of its module sales were driven by programmable inputs. The panel pointed to Ford advertisements promoting the feature and to testimony that "a customer who orders a Ford [UIM] has to specifically select that feature." It was "within the province of the jury to credit this testimony and these advertisements, and conclude from them that every module Ford sold was specifically selected by a customer due to its advertised programmable inputs feature," the court held.

The panel also rejected Ford's contention that InterMotive's own Programmable Relay Power Center, or PRPC, released in 2014, publicly disclosed the secret. InterMotive's expert, Professor Juan Pimentel, testified that it was "extremely hard to figure out how [the PRPC is] made." The jury "was permitted to credit such testimony from InterMotive's expert over other testimony and evidence," the court wrote.

The panel also rejected InterMotive's cross-appeal. The jury had separately awarded $349,867 for unfair competition under the Lanham Act, which matched Rinke's estimate of 3% of Ford's U.S. module profits. The district court struck that award as a double recovery, and the panel agreed, finding that the two wrongs "occurred at the same time and gave rise to the same pool of profits of which InterMotive sought disgorgement."

The court also upheld the denial of InterMotive's request to raise the Lanham Act award to $15 million, despite the jury's finding that Ford's infringement was willful. "Although the use of the word 'overturn' from the district court is not ideal, this Court is satisfied that it applied the correct law and did not abuse its discretion," Judge Clay wrote.

The panel further agreed that Michigan law does not allow disgorgement for breach of a nondisclosure agreement, noting that InterMotive "relies almost exclusively on a fifty-year-old district court case." Under Erie, "it is not advisable" for federal courts to expand the remedy without some express statement from a Michigan court. It also held that the district court acted within its discretion in barring an implied-in-law contract theory after finding that Ford had not been put on notice of it.

Jonathan D. Hacker of O'Melveny & Myers LLP argued for Ford. Andrew M. Grove of Howard & Howard Attorneys PLLC argued for InterMotive and Schafer.

The decision, recommended for publication, leaves the district court's judgment in place, including the $13.2 million disgorgement award and the $3,011,092 in prejudgment interest. The panel did not remand any issue.