Key Points

  • The Supreme Court of Alabama affirmed the Madison Circuit Court's summary judgment for Duda Energy, LLC, on all claims brought by representatives of four people who bought its sodium nitrite online and used it to take their own lives.
  • Under Florida and Minnesota law, the court held, general knowledge that a lawful product can be misused does not create a duty to screen purchasers or refuse sales to buyers who intend to misuse it.
  • Under Florida and Tennessee law, the court held, the suicides were not reasonably foreseeable because the record showed no knowledge specific to the individual buyers, despite evidence that Duda Energy had received reports of 11 earlier suicides.
  • The court held that the Florida plaintiffs and Adebara waived their theory that Duda Energy assumed a duty by adopting an internal policy for checking on buyers' intended use, because they did not present it to the circuit court.
  • Justice Parker wrote the opinion; Chief Justice Stewart and Justices Wise, Bryan and Sellers concurred, and Justice Cook recused himself.

The Supreme Court of Alabama upheld a judgment for Duda Energy, LLC, in a lawsuit by legal representatives of four people who bought its sodium nitrite online and used it to take their own lives, holding that the company's awareness of earlier suicides did not make it legally responsible for these deaths. Justice Parker wrote that "knowledge that a product can be misused does not demonstrate knowledge that any particular customer will misuse the product."

The court affirmed the Madison Circuit Court's summary judgment on every claim the plaintiffs brought. Chief Justice Stewart and Justices Wise, Bryan and Sellers concurred in Parker's opinion, and Justice Cook recused himself.

The case turned on the law of Florida, Tennessee and Minnesota, where the decedents lived. Under Florida and Minnesota law, the court held, Duda Energy owed no duty to screen buyers of a lawful product for their intended use. Under Florida and Tennessee law, it held, the suicides were not reasonably foreseeable, because the record contained no evidence that the company knew anything specific about the individual buyers.

Sodium nitrite has legitimate uses such as curing and preserving meat, Parker wrote. "But when consumed at high enough quantities, sodium nitrite starves the body of oxygen, rapidly leading to death," Parker added. The four decedents, Malik William Rodriguez, Patrikios Papasavas, Elisabeth "Blaise" Martin and Kaitlyn "Felix" Pohl, each bought the product online from Duda Energy, which is headquartered and incorporated in Alabama.

Their representatives produced evidence that, between October 2019 and February 2022, Duda Energy received reports of 11 suicides by people around the country who had bought its sodium nitrite online. The company responded by adopting an internal policy of additional precautions for selling the product. Yet "the evidence suggested," Parker wrote, that Duda Energy did not follow that policy for the four sales at issue.

The plaintiffs sued for negligence, wantonness, wrongful death, loss of consortium and outrage. Because their appellate arguments addressed only negligence, the court assumed that if summary judgment was correct on that claim, it was correct on the others.

Suzanne and John Pohl and Holly Papasavas sued under Florida law, where, the court noted, "there is no liability for the suicide of another in the absence of a specific duty of care." The court rejected their argument that the earlier suicides made these deaths foreseeable, holding that mere knowledge "of a product's potential misuse does not give rise to a duty to avoid selling to buyers who intend to misuse the product."

Parker relied on Jenkins v. W.L. Roberts Inc., a Florida appellate decision rejecting a claim that a nitrous oxide seller had to ensure the gas was used to enhance race car engines rather than as an inhalant. That court held that "[a]bsent special circumstances, there is no legal duty requiring a store to ensure that a product lawfully sold will ultimately be used by a customer or unknown third party for a lawful purpose." Parker wrote that a specific statutory restriction on the sale of a product "might impose greater duties," but that the plaintiffs had presented no such statute regarding sodium nitrite.

The Florida claims also failed on proximate cause. The plaintiffs' evidence showed Duda Energy "had a general awareness that some people had purchased its sodium nitrite for use in suicide," Parker wrote, but none of it "supports an inference of knowledge specific to Patrikios Papasavas or Kaitlyn Pohl." Parker distinguished a Florida gun-sale case in which a suicide was foreseeable only "by virtue of the ordinance" requiring a three-day waiting period. This case, the court said, involved neither an ordinance nor decedent-specific knowledge.

Natalie Martin's Tennessee claims turned on proximate cause alone, the only element argued in the circuit court. Tennessee treats suicide as a superseding cause when it is "a willful, calculated, and deliberate act of one who has the power of choice." The court followed Rains v. Bend of the River, a Tennessee appellate decision approved by the state's Supreme Court, which involved an ammunition sale to an 18-year-old and held that "the foreseeability question hinges on the victim's behavior and demeanor at the time of the sale."

Parker concluded that no evidence in the record "indicates that Elisabeth Martin gave any indication to Duda Energy" that would have made her suicide reasonably foreseeable. "Duda Energy thus cannot be held liable for any resulting harm," the court held.

Calida Adebara, suing under Minnesota law over Rodriguez's death, argued that the company's continued sale of high-purity sodium nitrite after notice of its use for suicide was misfeasance that required it to adopt "adequate safeguards." "The problem with Adebara's theory is less about the existence of a duty than the scope of the duty," Parker wrote.

Minnesota law requires suppliers of potentially dangerous goods to warn of foreseeable misuse, the court said, and Adebara had raised no failure-to-warn theory. Under her theory, Parker wrote, "Anytime a dangerous misuse became foreseeable, the manufacturer's duty would expand dramatically to ensure that every purchaser had legitimate reasons and would abide by the product's warnings." The opinion then stated that "Minnesota law imposes no such duty."

The court held waived the Florida plaintiffs' argument that Duda Energy took on a duty by adopting its internal policy for checking on the intended use of its sodium nitrite orders, a theory Florida calls the undertaking doctrine, because they never presented it to the circuit court. In footnotes, the court held Adebara's version of that argument waived on the same ground and said Martin's version was irrelevant given the proximate-cause ruling and had not been raised in the circuit court.

"The facts underlying these claims are tragic, but they do not support negligence claims under the relevant state laws," Parker wrote.

The affirmance leaves the circuit court's judgment for Duda Energy in place on all claims. The opinion is subject to formal revision before publication in the Southern Reporter.