Key Points
- The Supreme Court of Alabama granted Meta's mandamus petition and issued a writ directing the St. Clair Circuit Court to dismiss a privacy suit by seven Facebook users who had opted out of a federal class action.
- The court held that Meta, a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business in California, is not subject to general jurisdiction in Alabama despite alleged business in the state and about 1.3 million Alabama users.
- The court held the users' allegations did not support specific jurisdiction because they did not allege that Meta marketed or promoted the Facebook app in Alabama or directed any suit-related conduct at the state, distinguishing Ford Motor Co. and Sawyer v. Cooper Tire.
- The court did not reach Meta's alternative argument based on an outbound forum-selection clause.
- Justice Sellers concurred in the result, agreeing with the distinction of Cooper Tire while maintaining that Cooper Tire was wrongly decided.
The Supreme Court of Alabama on Nov. 20 ordered a St. Clair County court to dismiss a privacy lawsuit that seven Facebook users filed against Meta Platforms Inc., holding that the users had alleged no conduct by the company directed at Alabama itself. Downloading the Facebook app onto phones in the state was not enough, the court held, because "Meta's actions appear to have been aimed at its users, not at Alabama as a forum."
Chief Justice Stewart wrote for the court, which granted Meta's petition for a writ of mandamus and issued the writ. Justices Wise, Mendheim, McCool and Parker concurred. Justices Shaw and Bryan concurred in the result, Justice Sellers concurred in the result with a separate opinion, and Justice Cook recused himself.
The decision means the users, who were permitted to opt out of a nationwide federal class action over Facebook data sharing, cannot pursue their claims in the Alabama court where they sued. The court held that more than 1.3 million Alabama users, without allegations that Meta marketed the app in the state or otherwise sought to exploit the Alabama market, did not give the state's courts power over the company.
The class action was filed in 2018 in the federal District Court for the Northern District of California and alleged that Meta "had improperly permitted Facebook users' private information to be shared with third parties," according to the opinion. After a proposed settlement, the plaintiffs were permitted to opt out. On Oct. 11, 2023, they sued Meta in St. Clair Circuit Court on tort theories including fraud, breach of privacy, conversion, outrage and wantonness, alleging that Meta improperly shared the personal information of about 87 million Facebook users, 1,385,169 of them from Alabama.
To tie the case to Alabama, the complaint stressed that the plaintiffs kept their phones and other devices in the state. "Without Plaintiffs' hardware device, [Meta] would have no means of distributing its software product known as 'Facebook'," the complaint said. After Meta moved to dismiss in September 2025, each plaintiff filed an affidavit saying the app and the plaintiff's data sat on a phone in Alabama, and the plaintiffs submitted documents about a Meta data center in Huntsville and plans for another in Montgomery. The circuit court denied Meta's motion on Feb. 27, 2026, finding that it had specific personal jurisdiction.
The Supreme Court first rejected general jurisdiction, which lets a court hear any claim against a corporation that is "at home" in the state, ordinarily where it is incorporated or keeps its principal place of business. Meta is a Delaware corporation based in California. After reviewing the U.S. Supreme Court's 2017 decision in BNSF Railway Co. v. Tyrrell, the court wrote that the complaint indicated Meta was a company "with tens of millions of users around the world," and held that the plaintiffs' submissions did not show "the 'exceptional case' where Meta's Alabama operations are so substantial as to render it 'at home' in an Alabama forum."
Most of the opinion addressed specific jurisdiction, which requires that the claims arise out of or relate to the defendant's own contacts with the state. The plaintiffs relied on Ford Motor Co. v. Montana Eighth Judicial District Court, a 2021 U.S. Supreme Court product-liability ruling, and on Sawyer v. Cooper Tire & Rubber Co., a 2024 Alabama decision involving a tire maker. They argued that the app was analogous to the vehicles and the tire, and that its Alabama users showed Meta had "served the [Alabama] market."
The court disagreed. The defendants in Ford and Sawyer "maintained in-state dealer networks and extensively marketed, sold, and/or serviced the allegedly defective products in the forum states," the chief justice wrote. Here, by contrast, "there are no allegations that Meta marketed or promoted the Facebook app in Alabama or that it otherwise sought to specifically exploit the Alabama market." Meta instead offered the app "for download to anyone in the country (or world)," the court wrote, and the complaint's own chart showed affected users in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.
The court also relied on its 2019 decision in Facebook, Inc. v. K.G.S., which held that Facebook's conduct aimed at an individual Alabama resident, not at the state, could not support jurisdiction. In a footnote, it said Meta's placement of data centers in Alabama "appears to have occurred after the events alleged in the plaintiffs' complaint" and that the plaintiffs had not tied them to the data-sharing claims.
The opinion cited First, Third and Fourth Circuit rulings declining jurisdiction over websites not aimed at a particular state, and flagged one contrary authority with a "but see" citation: a 2025 Vermont decision, State of Vermont v. Meta Platforms, Inc., that found specific jurisdiction where the state alleged Meta "purposefully cultivated the Vermont market for its Instagram social-media application," including by selling advertising to Vermont businesses and tracking engagement with Vermont users.
Justice Sellers agreed that the case differed from Cooper Tire but maintained that Cooper Tire "was wrongfully decided" and adhered to the dissent the justice filed in that case. Ford, Justice Sellers wrote, did not authorize specific jurisdiction "merely because a defendant conducts substantial business nationwide and its products or services are used by the forum's residents." The concurrence added: "The existence of historical or generalized commercial activity cannot serve as a substitute for a meaningful relationship between the defendant, the forum, and the litigation."
Because it held that the claims against Meta are "due to be dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction," the court did not address Meta's alternative argument that an outbound forum-selection clause also required dismissal. The writ directs the St. Clair Circuit Court to dismiss the action. The opinion remains subject to formal revision before publication in the Southern Reporter.