Key Points

  • The Supreme Court of Alabama granted the NCAA's petition for a writ of mandamus and directed the DeKalb Circuit Court to dismiss Jeremy Pruitt's suit for lack of specific personal jurisdiction.
  • The majority held that Pruitt's claims concern the NCAA's investigation, hearing and penalty in Tennessee, Indiana and Ohio, not conduct the NCAA purposefully directed at Alabama.
  • The court held that the NCAA's contact with Jacksonville State responded to the school's own request and that the show-cause order's effects on Pruitt in Alabama did not create jurisdiction.
  • The court held that Ford Motor does not make the NCAA's regulation of its 18 Alabama member institutions sufficient for specific jurisdiction and placed no weight on the Appellate Court of Maryland's Haw decision.
  • Justices Bryan, Wise and Parker dissented, and Justice McCool, concurring in the result, wrote that there is an argument for general jurisdiction over the NCAA in Alabama that was not before the court.

The Supreme Court of Alabama on Friday ordered the DeKalb Circuit Court to dismiss former University of Tennessee football coach Jeremy Pruitt's lawsuit against the National Collegiate Athletic Association, holding that his claims concern an investigation, a hearing and a penalty that took place in Tennessee, Indiana and Ohio rather than Alabama. The court held that the NCAA's regulation of member schools in Alabama does not, by itself, let the state's courts hear his challenge to the association's discipline.

Justice Cook wrote for the court in a 6-3 decision granting the NCAA's petition for a writ of mandamus. Chief Justice Stewart and Justice Mendheim joined Cook's opinion, and Justices Shaw, Sellers and McCool concurred only in the result. Justice Bryan, joined by Justice Wise, and Justice Parker dissented.

The dispute turned on specific personal jurisdiction, the power of a state's courts to hear claims against an out-of-state defendant when the claims arise out of or relate to the defendant's own contacts with the state. Pruitt argued that the NCAA's regulation of its 18 member institutions in Alabama was enough under Ford Motor Co. v. Montana Eighth Judicial District Court, a 2021 U.S. Supreme Court decision. "To hold otherwise would be to improperly subject the NCAA to jurisdiction anywhere," Cook wrote in rejecting that argument.

Pruitt coached Tennessee from December 2017 until January 2021, when the university fired him. The university had reported rule violations to the NCAA in December 2020, and the association's staff in Indiana, where it is headquartered, investigated. After a hearing in Ohio, the NCAA's Committee on Infractions found in July 2023 that Pruitt and his wife had provided "substantial amounts of cash to certain prospects, student-athletes and their family members." It issued a six-year show-cause order, running through July 13, 2029, requiring any member school seeking to hire him to "show cause why restrictions on all athletically related activity should not apply."

Pruitt, who moved to DeKalb County, where he grew up, while the NCAA's case was pending, sued in March 2025 for negligence, wantonness, tortious interference, conspiracy and bad faith. He alleged that the NCAA conspired "to scapegoat and blame Jeremy Pruitt for allegations and misconduct, which he did not commit."

The trial court denied the NCAA's motion to dismiss in December 2025, finding that the association "has inserted itself into Alabama, holding the power to allow or disallow an Alabama resident to coach at an Alabama school." It also enjoined enforcement of the show-cause order, then dissolved the injunction at Pruitt's request in April 2026, after he resigned as an analyst at Jacksonville State University.

Cook wrote that "none of Pruitt's claims quoted above allege any suit-related conduct that the NCAA purposefully directed to Alabama." Instead, the opinion said, "each of these claims concern only the NCAA's suit-related conduct in other states."

The court also rejected Pruitt's argument that he is feeling the order's "effects" in Alabama, applying the "effects test" of Calder v. Jones, a 1984 U.S. Supreme Court libel case, which weighs the effects of a defendant's intentional conduct aimed at the forum state. Unlike the magazine article in Calder, Cook wrote, "the show-cause order against Pruitt does not concern the Alabama activities of an Alabama resident."

Jacksonville State, which hired Pruitt after the NCAA approved the hire with conditions, had initiated contact with the association through a June 24, 2025, letter. The court held that the NCAA's response could not support jurisdiction because "that contact would not have occurred absent initial contact from JSU." Nor could a lost opportunity at the University of Alabama, because Coach Nick Saban's testimony did not attribute his decision not to hire Pruitt to any direct contact by the NCAA.

On Ford, Cook wrote that "the essential feature of the Supreme Court's holding was that the accidents occurred in each of the forum states." The court rejected Haw v. National Collegiate Athletic Association, a 2024 Appellate Court of Maryland decision that found jurisdiction over the NCAA based on its rulemaking. The rule adopted in Haw and advocated by Pruitt, Cook wrote, "collapses specific personal jurisdiction into general personal jurisdiction," which reaches claims unrelated to a defendant's contacts with the state. "Due to its flawed reasoning, we place no weight on Haw," the opinion said.

Justice Sellers, concurring in the result, wrote that Ford does not allow jurisdiction over out-of-state defendants "merely because those defendants maintain extensive commercial or regulatory relationships with the forum state." Sellers was "not convinced of the necessity to distinguish or criticize" the Maryland ruling, however.

Justice McCool, who agreed with "only" the majority's conclusion, wrote that general jurisdiction was not properly before the court because Pruitt had not challenged the NCAA's contention that he conceded the point. Even so, McCool wrote, "there is at least an argument to be made that Alabama courts have general personal jurisdiction over the NCAA," pointing to "something inherently unfair in the NCAA's continuously and systematically enforcing its rules against its member institutions in this state."

In dissent, Bryan wrote that the NCAA "did reach into the state when it sent the show-cause order to 18 member institutions." Bryan added: "It would be incongruous to say that the NCAA did not enjoy the benefits and protections of Alabama laws when it imposed a sanction to be implemented here and then implemented enforcement of the same here."

Parker, dissenting separately, wrote that "according to the NCAA and the main opinion, no Alabama court can decide this case" brought by an Alabama resident claiming harm in Alabama. Parker read Ford to let a state court hear a case "when an in-state plaintiff suffers harm in the forum state based on the kind of conduct the defendant carries out in the forum state." The majority, Parker wrote, "imposes restrictions upon the jurisdiction of Alabama courts that no constitutional provision or statute requires."

The writ directs the DeKalb Circuit Court to vacate its order denying the NCAA's motion and to dismiss Pruitt's action against the association for lack of specific personal jurisdiction. The majority did not reach the NCAA's arguments on venue and forum non conveniens. McCool wrote that the general-jurisdiction question "will have to wait for another case."