Key Points

  • The Fifth Appellate District affirmed a judgment rejecting privacy and equal protection challenges to the Abortion Accessibility Act of 2022, which bars cost sharing for abortion and abortion-related services.
  • Plaintiffs bringing a state constitutional privacy claim bear the burden of proving a serious invasion of privacy by a preponderance of the evidence; the state's justification is an affirmative defense reached only after that showing.
  • For the right to choose, an actual impairment means a law causes an unwanted abortion, an unwanted child, or a nontrivial unwanted delay in obtaining an abortion; unequal funding alone does not qualify.
  • Because plaintiffs did not prove a significant interference with the right to choose, rational basis review applied to the equal protection claim, and removing cost barriers to abortion was a plausible legislative purpose.
  • The court expressly declined to decide how article I, section 1.1 of the California Constitution, adopted in November 2022, applies to the Act, because no party raised it.

A California appeals court on Nov. 17 upheld a state law that bars health plans from charging deductibles, copays and other out-of-pocket costs for abortion care. The ruling rejected a claim by a Bakersfield pregnancy center and three taxpayers that the law unconstitutionally favors abortion because those charges still apply to prenatal and maternity care.

A three-justice panel of the Fifth Appellate District affirmed a Kern County judgment for the state entered after a two-day bench trial. Justice Franson wrote the opinion, joined by Acting Presiding Justice Levy and Justice De Santos. The panel held that the challengers never proved the Abortion Accessibility Act of 2022 causes unwanted abortions or unwanted births.

The opinion, certified for publication, holds that plaintiffs bringing a privacy claim under the California Constitution must prove a serious invasion of privacy by a preponderance of the evidence. When the right at stake is the choice whether to have an abortion, the court held, that means proving the law actually distorts the choice.

The Act began as Senate Bill 245, introduced on Jan. 22, 2021, the 48th anniversary of Roe v. Wade. It took effect on Jan. 1, 2023, and prohibits health plans from "impos[ing] a deductible, coinsurance, copayment, or any other cost-sharing requirement on coverage for all abortion and abortion-related services, including preabortion and followup services."

The parties stipulated to figures from a report by the California Health Benefits Review Program. Before the Act, insured patients with cost sharing paid an average of $543 out of pocket for abortion services. The report estimated that 97 additional women would use abortion services in the Act's first year because cost sharing was eliminated. A separate stipulated study put average out-of-pocket costs for pregnancy, delivery and postpartum care at $2,854.

The plaintiffs were Bakersfield Crisis Pregnancy Center, a nonprofit religious corporation, along with Erin Rogers and two obstetricians, Patrick Baggot and Steven Braatz, who sued as state taxpayers in October 2022. They argued the Act violates women's privacy right to choose by failing to treat abortion and childbirth neutrally, and denies equal protection to women who carry pregnancies to term. The trial court summarized their reading of the data as "the State is intruding into private matters by encouraging (or worse) 97 women who would not otherwise desire or choose an abortion to have an abortion."

Kern County Superior Court Judge Thomas S. Clark rejected that account. "Plaintiffs have certainly not shown by any standard of proof that the Act interferes with the right of California women to choose to continue their pregnancies," the trial judge wrote. Because the plaintiffs did not argue on appeal that the evidence compelled contrary findings, the panel treated those findings as binding. "In short, plaintiffs did not prove their factual claim that the Act will result in unwanted children or unwanted abortions," Franson wrote.

The plaintiffs had argued that the burden was on the state, not on them, to justify the law. Franson rejected that argument to the extent it asserted that the plaintiffs did not have to prove a serious invasion of privacy, relying on the California Supreme Court's 1994 decision in Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Association and the Evidence Code's default rule that a party proves the facts essential to its own claim. Because Hill treats the state's justification as an affirmative defense, "we infer that the factual basis for the three essential elements of a privacy claim must be proven by the plaintiff asserting the claim," Franson wrote.

The panel then defined what counts as an injury to the right to choose, drawing on Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, the high court's 1981 decision on limits to Medi-Cal funding for abortion. Under that reading, "an actual impairment of the procreative choice occurs if the Act causes a woman to have an unwanted abortion, to forego an abortion and have an unwanted child, or to experience a nontrivial, unwanted delay in having an abortion."

The plaintiffs had argued that Myers "plainly equated unequal funding with 'intrusion'" into a pregnant woman's choice. "Difference in funding for the different choices women make do not automatically result in the requisite adverse influence upon the right to choose between the two alternatives," Franson wrote. The opinion noted that the Myers court had found the funding limits would induce some women to carry unwanted pregnancies to term, a finding absent here.

On equal protection, the panel applied rational basis review rather than strict scrutiny. Citing the state Supreme Court's 2025 decision in People v. Cannon, it held that strict scrutiny applies only when a law has a "real and appreciable impact on, or a significant interference with the exercise of the fundamental right," which the trial court found the plaintiffs had not shown. Relying on a legislative committee analysis, the panel held that "a plausible reason for the Act's elimination of cost sharing for women choosing abortion services was to remove cost barriers that might prevent or delay access to those services."

The plaintiffs also argued that leaving miscarriage care out of the Act, "although the medical care for both is virtually identical, defies logic." The trial court had reasoned that women who miscarry "are not facing a decision—the decision has been made for them." The panel agreed. In the arena of reproductive choice, Franson wrote, "it is rational to adopt classifications that reflect the choice (i.e., intent) of a particular individual."

Voters amended the state constitution in November 2022 to bar the state from denying or interfering with reproductive freedom, but no party invoked that provision, article I, section 1.1. The court wrote that "this opinion is not authority for how section 1.1 of article I of the California Constitution applies to the Act."

Lawyers for the plaintiffs included Catherine W. Short. The state agencies were represented by the office of Attorney General Rob Bonta.

The court affirmed the judgment for the Department of Managed Health Care, the California Department of Insurance and Bonta, and awarded them their costs on appeal.