Key Points
- A hospital cannot assert a Hospital Lien Act lien for services provided to a Medi-Cal beneficiary, because the Medi-Cal Act bars providers from collecting from the patient and a lien requires an underlying debt owed by the patient.
- A settling tortfeasor and its insurer are not a 'third-party payor' under Welfare and Institutions Code section 14019.4, subdivision (a), so that exception does not authorize the lien.
- Assertion of the invalid lien can support an unlawful-practice claim under the Unfair Competition Law, and the Hospital Lien Act provides no safe harbor in the Medi-Cal context.
- The court refused to give its holding prospective-only effect, distinguishing Olszewski v. Scripps Health because no statute was found invalid or preempted.
- The judgment was reversed and the case remanded for the putative class UCL claim to proceed; the court deemed any litigation-privilege argument forfeited.
A hospital cannot use California's Hospital Lien Act to claim part of a Medi-Cal patient's settlement with the driver who injured her, a state appeals court held in a published opinion filed Nov. 16. The ruling revives a proposed class action against Long Beach Memorial Medical Center and Yoshida & Garcia, Inc., the firm that sent a lien notice on the hospital's behalf.
A three-justice panel of the Second Appellate District, Division Five, reversed a Los Angeles County Superior Court judgment that had thrown out the suit brought by patient Sunfa Reneau. Justice Moor wrote the unanimous opinion, joined by Presiding Justice Hoffstadt and Justice Kim.
The decision means a hospital that treats a Medi-Cal patient has no lien to assert against the patient's recovery from a tortfeasor, the person legally responsible for an injury. Medi-Cal is California's version of Medicaid, the federal-state health program for low-income people. Under the Medi-Cal Act, the panel wrote, the state agency, not the provider, holds the right to seek repayment from a liable third party. Reneau may now press her claim under the Unfair Competition Law, the state statute that bars unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business practices.
According to the complaint, whose allegations the court accepted as true at this stage, Reneau was injured in a car accident with Andre Hernandez on June 3, 2020, and sought treatment at the hospital two days later. She presented her Medi-Cal card, and the admissions manager acknowledged she was eligible. The hospital billed Medi-Cal for some services, but $7,683 in other charges were never submitted to the program.
On July 24, 2020, Yoshida & Garcia mailed Hernandez's insurer, Alliance United, a notice of hospital lien and threatened to sue Hernandez and the insurer to enforce it. In March 2021, Reneau agreed to release her claims against Hernandez for $7,500. The firm kept trying to collect on the lien, and Alliance United has withheld the settlement money from Reneau as a result, the complaint alleges.
Reneau sued in June 2021 and later pressed class claims on behalf of Medi-Cal-eligible California residents who received hospital lien notices. The defendants removed the case to federal court, which dismissed a federal debt collection claim in May 2024 and sent the remaining claims back to state court.
Judge Kenneth R. Freeman then sustained the defendants' demurrer, a challenge to the legal sufficiency of a complaint, without leave to amend. He reasoned that a Medi-Cal provision allowing providers to collect from a "third-party payor who provides a contractual or legal entitlement to health care services" authorized the lien. He also concluded that Reneau "may not invoke the UCL to assault the 'safe harbor' provided under the HLA." Reneau appealed only the ruling on her unfair competition claim.
"Because we conclude a hospital cannot assert an HLA lien for services provided to a Medi-Cal beneficiary, we find the lien to be invalid," Justice Moor wrote. The panel built on Parnell v. Adventist Health System/West, a 2005 decision in which the California Supreme Court held that "a lien under the HLA requires the existence of an underlying debt owed by the patient to the hospital and that, absent such a debt, no lien may attach." Parnell involved a privately insured patient whose hospital had already accepted a negotiated rate as full payment.
"The reasoning in Parnell is equally applicable in the Medi-Cal context as in the context of a private insurer: if the patient does not owe money to the hospital, the hospital lacks authority to assert an HLA lien," the opinion said. Two Medi-Cal provisions require providers to bill the program and forbid them from seeking payment from the patient, the court noted, and the defendants did not argue that Reneau owed the hospital money.
The panel rejected the trial court's reading of the third-party payor exception, citing a 1983 appellate decision, Palumbo v. Myers, which held that a settling tortfeasor does not qualify. The defendants had argued that Palumbo and a 2025 decision, Dameron Hospital Assn. v. Progressive Casualty Ins. Co., were distinguishable because neither involved the lien law. The court answered that under Parnell, "if the hospital lacks authority under the HLA to collect from the patient directly, it also lacks authority to collect from the third party tortfeasor."
The panel also rejected the defendants' fallback arguments, holding that the lien law provides no safe harbor, a doctrine that bars use of the Unfair Competition Law against conduct the Legislature has permitted or concluded should not be actionable.
The defendants had argued that holding them liable for conduct they believed lawful would give the ruling "retroactive" or "ex post facto" effect. "Nothing about our holding regarding the legal limitations on the Hospital's HLA lien authority is novel or groundbreaking," Justice Moor wrote. "Instead, we apply long-standing case law to a set of facts that has not yet been the subject of a published opinion."
The defendants had relied on Olszewski v. Scripps Health, a 2003 Supreme Court decision that declined to impose retroactive liability on a provider that relied on a Medi-Cal lien statute later found preempted by federal law. The panel called the difference material. "In contrast here, we are not finding any statute to be invalid or preempted; instead, we have determined that the defendants' use of a facially valid statute (the HLA) is invalid in the context where the patient is a Medi-Cal beneficiary," the opinion said.
The court also rejected the argument that Reneau needed a separate claim for declaratory relief, because her complaint already seeks a declaration that the lien was invalid.
Lawyers for Reneau included Anthony T. Nehme of Nehme Law Firm. The hospital and Yoshida & Garcia were represented by Nicholas M. Gross of Foley & Lardner.
The court reversed the judgment and sent the case back to the superior court for further proceedings on the unfair competition claim alone. Reneau was awarded her costs on appeal.