Key Points

  • The EFAA's exception for sexual harassment disputes is not limited to allegations of lewd or lascivious behavior; it adopts the definition of sexual harassment in the federal, tribal or state law the plaintiff invokes.
  • Under FEHA, sexual harassment includes harassment based on gender or pregnancy, and sexually harassing conduct need not be motivated by sexual desire.
  • Federal, not California, pleading standards govern whether a complaint triggers the EFAA, under 9 U.S.C. section 402(b) and the need for uniform application of federal law.
  • The court did not choose among competing federal standards because Doe's complaint satisfied even the most stringent Twombly/Iqbal plausibility test, counting biased personnel decisions toward the hostile-environment showing under Roby v. McKesson Corp.
  • The order denying Maybourne's motion to compel arbitration was affirmed as to the entire case, and Doe was awarded costs on appeal.

A federal law that lets workers escape forced arbitration of sexual harassment claims also covers harassment based on gender or pregnancy, even when no sexual advances or lewd conduct are alleged, a California appeals court held on Nov. 17. The ruling keeps a former luxury hotel manager's lawsuit against her employer in court.

A three-justice panel of the Second Appellate District, Division Seven, unanimously affirmed a Los Angeles County Superior Court order denying The Maybourne Beverly Hills Operator, LLC's motion to compel arbitration, which sought to send former employee Jane Doe's claims to private arbitration. Justice Stone wrote the opinion, joined by Presiding Justice Martinez and Justice Feuer. The court certified the opinion for publication.

The decision addresses two questions for California courts. The panel held that the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021, known as the EFAA, adopts state law's definition of sexual harassment, which in California includes gender- and pregnancy-based harassment. It also held that federal rather than state pleading standards decide whether a complaint invokes the law, a question the court said no California court had yet decided.

Congress enacted the EFAA in 2022 as an amendment to the Federal Arbitration Act. At the plaintiff's election, it makes predispute arbitration agreements unenforceable in cases relating to a "sexual harassment dispute," which the statute defines as "a dispute relating to conduct that is alleged to constitute sexual harassment under applicable Federal, Tribal, or State law."

Doe worked as a guest reception manager at The Maybourne Beverly Hills from May 2015 to January 2024 and signed an arbitration agreement in June 2020. Her March 2024 complaint alleged that after she disclosed her first pregnancy in October 2020, she was told "she would not be able to be a career woman once she had children and related gender responsibilities." She alleged that she was never interviewed for a director of front office opening and that the hotel hired a man.

In December 2023, the complaint said, a regional director told Doe "that she was a mother and that her first priority would always be her children." After she sought a meeting with human resources, its director falsely accused her of a sexual relationship with a coworker, the complaint alleged. The hotel suspended her without pay and fired her five days later. Doe sued under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act, or FEHA, alleging harassment, sex discrimination and retaliation.

Maybourne argued that the EFAA reaches only claims of sexual misconduct, contending that "the #MeToo movement giving rise to the EFAA stemmed from horrific instances of suppressed misconduct of a sexual nature." "We conclude that the EFAA's exception for sexual harassment disputes is not limited to allegations of lewd or lascivious behavior," Justice Stone wrote.

The statute's text, the court said, points to the definition of sexual harassment in the law the plaintiff invokes. It relied on Bostock v. Clayton County, the 2020 U.S. Supreme Court decision applying Title VII to gay and transgender workers, and quoted its statement that "the limits of the drafters' imagination supply no reason to ignore the law's demands."

The hotel also argued that FEHA treats sexual harassment as narrower than gender or pregnancy harassment because the statute lists them separately. The panel noted that FEHA provides that "[s]exually harassing conduct need not be motivated by sexual desire." The Legislature "did not intend to draw any meaningful distinction between conduct that constitutes 'sexual harassment' and conduct that constitutes gender- or pregnancy-based harassment," the court held.

Federal courts have split on the pleading question. Many require allegations that would survive a motion to dismiss under the Twombly/Iqbal standard, which requires a claim that is "plausible on its face." Others require only "nonfrivolous" allegations. On Nov. 10, a divided Ninth Circuit panel in Holland-Thielen v. SpaceX asked only whether the complaint describes conduct asserted to be sexual harassment, an approach its dissent said created "a gaping door no litigant can miss." The California panel said it was not bound by the Ninth Circuit majority.

Doe urged the court to apply California's demurrer standard, which the opinion described as "somewhat less stringent than the Twombly/Iqbal plausibility standard." The court declined, citing the EFAA's directive that whether it applies "shall be determined under Federal law." State standards could make the outcome turn on whether a case is filed in or removed to federal court, "leading to inconsistent application of the EFAA as well as forum shopping," the court wrote.

The panel did not choose among the federal tests, concluding that "the allegations of Doe's complaint satisfy even the most stringent Twombly/Iqbal plausibility standard." Maybourne had argued that "[a]t most, she has alleged two comments regarding her being a mother and focusing on her children." The court wrote that the comments "reinforce the stereotype that women, and mothers in particular, are less committed and less deserving of advancement in the workplace."

The court also counted the hotel's personnel decisions toward the harassment claim, over Maybourne's objection that such managerial actions support only a discrimination claim. The panel relied on Roby v. McKesson Corp., a 2010 California Supreme Court decision explaining that "in some cases the hostile message that constitutes the harassment is conveyed through official employment actions."

Accepting the allegations as true, the court concluded that Doe plausibly alleged "an objectively hostile or abusive work environment," though a trier of fact may ultimately find otherwise.

Lawyers for Maybourne included Todd B. Scherwin of Fisher & Phillips. Doe was represented by Carney R. Shegerian of Shegerian & Associates.

The panel held that the trial court properly denied arbitration as to the entire case, so all of Doe's claims against Maybourne remain in Los Angeles County Superior Court. The court awarded Doe her costs on appeal.