Key Points

  • The First Circuit reversed class certification of the homeowners' negligence and negligent-failure-to-warn claims against Saint-Gobain because injury and causation would require property-by-property proof.
  • The court affirmed certification of the trespass claim because New Hampshire trespass liability requires only an intentional intrusion, and whether Saint-Gobain's PFOA reached every class property is a common question.
  • Individualized damages did not defeat predominance for the trespass claim, and the bifurcated plan limited to trespass does not necessarily violate the Seventh Amendment.
  • The court did not decide whether Rule 23(c)(4) permits issue classes for claims that fail Rule 23(b)(3) as a whole, or whether a trespass claim based on invisible particulate matter requires some additional showing under New Hampshire law.

A federal appeals court ruled Nov. 17 that homeowners near a Saint-Gobain plant in Merrimack, N.H., may pursue a trespass claim as a class over a toxic chemical they say the plant's emissions carried into their drinking water, but it stripped class status from their negligence claims.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit affirmed in part and reversed in part a December 2023 class-certification order by U.S. District Judge Joseph N. Laplante of the District of New Hampshire. Circuit Judge Kayatta wrote for a panel that also included Chief Judge Barron and Circuit Judge Montecalvo. Trespass liability can now be tried class-wide, but the negligence and negligent-failure-to-warn claims cannot proceed as a class.

The split turned on what each tort requires under New Hampshire law. Negligence requires proof that the contamination harmed each property and that Saint-Gobain caused that harm, and the panel found those questions would demand property-by-property evidence. Trespass requires only an intentional intrusion, so "how much PFOA attributable to Saint-Gobain has intruded on a particular property has no bearing on whether Saint-Gobain is liable for trespass," Judge Kayatta wrote.

The case concerns perfluorooctanoic acid, or PFOA, a persistent human-made chemical in the family known as PFAS. The plaintiffs allege that PFOA used at the Merrimack facility, which makes fiberglass and films, was released through stack emissions, carried by wind, deposited on the ground and dissolved into groundwater. That groundwater feeds private wells and the Merrimack Village District Water Works, which serves 25,000 customers.

New Hampshire environmental regulators announced on March 4, 2016, that Saint-Gobain had detected PFOA in water from faucets at the plant. Testing later found PFOA in private wells at up to 1,600 parts per trillion, against a state groundwater standard of 70 parts per trillion. In 2018, Saint-Gobain agreed in a consent decree with the state to pay certain remediation costs for select properties, without admitting liability.

The homeowners sued in state court in May 2016, and Saint-Gobain removed the case to federal court. A real estate economist retained by the plaintiffs put the total loss in property value across the class area at not less than $577,935,862.

Judge Laplante certified a class under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(b)(3), which permits class treatment when common questions predominate over individual ones, on liability for the trespass, negligence and failure-to-warn claims. He found that damages would vary by household and planned a bifurcated trial, with liability tried for the class first. The First Circuit then granted Saint-Gobain permission to appeal under Rule 23(f).

On the negligence claims, the panel agreed with Judge Laplante that duty and breach turn on Saint-Gobain's own conduct and could be tried on common proof. But contamination levels varied across properties, and neither the district court nor the plaintiffs had explained how to show in common which properties, "particularly among those with little but not negligible contamination," were actually harmed. "Proof of causation would likely depend on individualized evidence," Judge Kayatta added, because the plaintiffs' own experts agreed that other sources may have contributed to local contamination.

"And neither injury nor causation is a sideshow here," the opinion said, rejecting the district court's view that individual questions would not overwhelm common ones. Even if duty and breach were decided class-wide, the court wrote, "proceedings would then be overwhelmed with individualized questions as to whether each plaintiff was harmed by the presence of PFOA" on each property.

The trespass claim fared differently. The plaintiffs' meteorology expert, David Sullivan, testified that PFOA "has fallen on every property within the class geographic area." Saint-Gobain disputes that opinion, "but its validity is itself a common question," the court held. Because trespass requires no injury beyond the intrusion, the company's arguments about other polluters, economic losses and rising home values failed. Judge Kayatta wrote that "the individualized issues to which Saint-Gobain directs our attention are entirely irrelevant to whether Saint-Gobain is liable for trespass."

The panel flagged a question it chose not to answer: whether a trespass claim based on invisible, particulate matter requires some additional showing. Other states' courts have split, and the opinion said the panel was "aware of no New Hampshire state court ruling addressing the issue." Because Saint-Gobain had not preserved the argument, "we decline to wade into these muddy waters sua sponte," the court wrote.

The court also rejected Saint-Gobain's argument that Judge Laplante had misused Rule 23(c)(4), which allows class treatment of particular issues, to certify a liability-only class. "But the district court did no such thing," the opinion said, because he had found Rule 23's requirements met for each claim as a whole. That left open a "question subject to significant debate": whether issues may be certified from a claim that fails that test.

On damages, the panel reaffirmed that the need for individual damages findings does not necessarily defeat class certification. The opinion noted that Saint-Gobain's counsel conceded at oral argument that "if all elements of liability are established, the law is well settled that damages can be different."

The panel also rejected Saint-Gobain's argument that a later damages jury would re-examine the liability jury's findings, saying it could not agree that the order, now limited to trespass, "necessarily contravenes the Seventh Amendment."

Mark S. Cheffo represented Saint-Gobain, and Kevin S. Hannon represented the homeowners.

The First Circuit remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with its opinion, with each side bearing its own costs. Under Judge Laplante's bifurcated plan, a class-wide liability phase, now limited to trespass, would come first. He wrote that "[f]urther discovery and findings from the liability phase will inform the format of the damages phase."