Key Points
- The Federal Circuit affirmed a District of Colorado judgment that claims 1, 38 and 39 of Cocona's U.S. Patent No. 8,945,287 are invalid as indefinite.
- Each asserted claim requires a moisture vapor transmission rate of about 600 to about 11,000 g/m2/day, but the patent does not say whether to use the upright or inverted cup method or which temperature and humidity conditions to apply.
- The patent's Figure 2 and a table in its provisional application show samples falling inside the claimed range under one method and outside it under the other, which the court found relevant even if those samples do not practice the claims.
- The court said it was not holding that disclosure of multiple measurement methods makes a claim per se indefinite, and it distinguished Presidio and Ethicon as cases involving a single established method or adequate guidance on method choice.
- The court found no clear error in the district court's crediting of the defendants' expert and its rejection of Cocona's expert testimony as conclusory.
A federal appeals court on Nov. 17 upheld a ruling that invalidated three claims of a patent on waterproof, breathable fabric that Cocona Inc. had asserted against The North Face and Columbia Sportswear Co. The court held that the patent never told readers how to measure the breathability range its claims required.
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed a District of Colorado judgment for VF Outdoor LLC, which does business as The North Face, and Columbia. Circuit Judge Stark wrote the opinion for a panel that also included Circuit Judges Lourie and Stoll.
Every claim Cocona asserted requires a moisture vapor transmission rate, or MVTR, a measure of how fast water vapor such as sweat passes through a material, of about 600 to about 11,000 grams per square meter per day. The panel held that the patent described more than one way to measure that rate, that the methods could produce results an order of magnitude apart, and that the patent never said which to use. As a result, the court concluded, a skilled reader could not tell with reasonable certainty which products the claims covered.
Under the Supreme Court's 2014 decision in Nautilus Inc. v. Biosig Instruments Inc., which the panel quoted, a patent is invalid for indefiniteness under 35 U.S.C. § 112 if its claims "fail to inform, with reasonable certainty, those skilled in the art about the scope of the invention."
The patent at issue, U.S. Patent No. 8,945,287, covers a membrane for materials such as outdoor apparel. The membrane embeds active particles, such as activated carbon, to let water vapor such as sweat escape while repelling rain.
The patent's specification, the written description that accompanies the claims, named three ways to measure MVTR: the Mocon method, the upright cup method and the inverted cup method. In the upright test, an air gap sits above water in a dish. In the inverted test, the water rests directly on the material. The specification said MVTR "may be measured" under a standard protocol, ASTM E96-94, at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20% relative humidity. The opinion noted that the standard itself allows testing at 23 to 38 degrees and requires relative humidity of either 50% or 90%, within 2 points, depending on the material's intended use.
During claim construction, Cocona asked Judge Christine M. Arguello to read the 40-degree, 20% humidity conditions into the claims, along with the upright method for low moisture contact and the inverted method for high moisture contact. Judge Arguello rejected the proposal and held claims 1, 38 and 39 invalid as indefinite.
Judge Stark wrote that "the claims are utterly devoid of all of the detail Cocona asked the district court to read into them." He added, "The claims give no clue as to whether to use the upright or inverted cup method, or both, or what temperature and humidity conditions to set for whichever test one performs."
The panel found the specification no more helpful. It said the patent's only guidance tied the upright method to "low moisture contact" and the inverted method to "high moisture contact," without explaining how to tell the two apart.
The patent's own data drew particular attention. In Figure 2, a control sample without active particles measured 470 grams per square meter per day by the upright method, outside the claimed range, and 6,356 by the inverted method, inside it. "These data would do nothing to reassure a skilled artisan as to how to discern the scope of the MVTR limitation," Judge Stark wrote. A table in Cocona's provisional application, which the patent incorporates, reported a carbon-containing sample at 1,394 by the inverted method and 223 by the upright method.
The panel relied on its 2015 decision in Dow Chemical Co. v. Nova Chemicals Corp. Citing that decision, the panel wrote that its precedents establish that "the existence of multiple methods leading to different results without guidance in the patent or the prosecution history as to which method should be used renders the claims indefinite."
The court cast its ruling as limited to this patent. Cocona had warned against a rule that any patent contemplating more than one measurement method is automatically indefinite. Judge Stark wrote that the panel's "holding is that, in the specific context of the ’287 patent, the intrinsic evidence as a whole demonstrates, to a clear and convincing level, that a skilled artisan would be unable to determine with reasonable certainty the scope of the asserted claims."
Expert testimony, the panel said, confirmed that conclusion. Judge Arguello credited the defendants' expert, Dr. Abigail Oelker, and dismissed the testimony of Cocona's expert, Dr. Stephen McCarthy, as "quintessentially conclusory." The appeals court found no clear error in those findings.
The panel turned aside Cocona's other arguments. Cocona said the divergent samples did not practice the claims, but the court held that when different methods "could result in the same item both meeting and not meeting a claim limitation, that fact is relevant to indefiniteness." The court called the 40-degree, 20% humidity settings "non-mandatory examples of testing conditions." It also rejected Cocona's claim that Judge Arguello had demanded mandatory language, writing that "the district court is not guilty of the charge levelled at it."
VF Outdoor had earlier challenged claims 27-28, 30, 32-33 and 35-39 through inter partes review at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. The board found all but claims 38 and 39 obvious, and the Federal Circuit affirmed in 2021.
Chad T. Nitta of Kutak Rock LLP argued for Cocona. Columbia's lawyers included Bart Starr of Sheridan Ross PC.
The affirmance, in appeal Nos. 2025-1458 and 2025-1462, leaves in place the district court's final judgment for VF Outdoor and Columbia on all three asserted claims.