Key Points
- The Federal Circuit vacated a Western District of Texas judgment in Traxcell's independent action against Verizon and remanded with instructions to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction.
- The panel held it had appellate jurisdiction because a suit to set aside a 35 U.S.C. § 285 fee award arises under the Patent Act, rejecting Verizon's argument that only the mandate rule was at issue.
- Raising the issue on its own, the panel held a district court lacks jurisdiction over an independent action whose complaint fails Beggerly's grave-miscarriage-of-justice standard, and called Traxcell's theory that the Eastern District lacked power to award fees frivolous.
- As a separate ground, the panel held one district court may not entertain an independent action to set aside another district court's judgment that has been affirmed on appeal, whether or not Beggerly is satisfied.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit on Nov. 16 threw out a lawsuit by patent owner Traxcell Technologies LLC that sought to wipe out an attorneys' fee award Verizon won in an earlier infringement case, holding that the Texas federal court that heard the suit had no power to decide it.
Writing for a panel that also included Circuit Judges Chen and Stoll, Circuit Judge Dyk vacated a judgment of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, where Judge Alan D Albright had rejected Traxcell's challenge on the merits. The panel sent the case back with instructions to dismiss it for lack of jurisdiction and awarded costs to Verizon.
The decision limits the use of the independent action, an old equitable remedy preserved in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(d)(1) that lets a party file a new lawsuit seeking relief from a judgment. The panel held that a district court lacks jurisdiction over such a suit if the complaint fails the Supreme Court's demanding standard in United States v. Beggerly, and that one district court may not hear an independent action against another district court's judgment that an appeals court has already affirmed.
The dispute began on Oct. 31, 2017, when Traxcell sued Verizon in the Eastern District of Texas, alleging infringement of four patents. That court held some of the asserted claims indefinite and in April 2020 granted Verizon summary judgment of noninfringement on the rest. The Federal Circuit affirmed in October 2021.
Verizon's request for attorneys' fees was pending during that appeal. On Dec. 22, 2022, the Eastern District awarded Verizon fees under 35 U.S.C. § 285, a provision of the Patent Act, and ordered Traxcell to pay within 30 days. Traxcell appealed, arguing the court wrongly found it knew or should have known its infringement theories were baseless, but it did not argue that the court lacked jurisdiction to award fees. The Federal Circuit affirmed again in a Rule 36 judgment in July 2023, and the Supreme Court denied review.
Traxcell then filed an emergency motion in the Eastern District arguing, for the first time, that the Federal Circuit's mandate in the merits appeal had stripped the trial court of jurisdiction to award fees. That motion is still pending, according to the opinion. "Apparently seeking another avenue to block the fee award," Judge Dyk wrote, Traxcell filed the independent action in the Western District, making substantially the same arguments.
Judge Albright denied Traxcell's December 2024 request for a preliminary injunction barring Verizon from enforcing the award, concluding that "Traxcell has no reasonable likelihood of prevailing in this case because the Verizon [fee award] is not void." The parties then stipulated to a final judgment against Traxcell, preserving its right to appeal.
On appeal, Verizon argued that the Federal Circuit lacked jurisdiction because the case turned only on the mandate rule rather than on patent law. The panel disagreed, holding that Traxcell's suit was "on its face, an action to set aside a judgment for attorneys' fees under 35 U.S.C. § 285, a provision of the Patent Act," and likening it to a suit seeking a declaration that Traxcell owed no fees.
Neither side had questioned the Western District's own jurisdiction. The panel raised the issue itself, writing that "although not raised by the parties, we are obligated to consider whether the Western District had jurisdiction."
Under Beggerly, a 1998 Supreme Court decision quoted in the opinion, an independent action "should be available only to prevent a grave miscarriage of justice." Judge Dyk wrote that Traxcell's briefing "does not cite Beggerly, makes no mention of the grave-miscarriage standard, and does nothing to support the notion that the award works a grave miscarriage of justice."
The panel also rejected the premise of Traxcell's mandate argument. It held that a district court may properly take up fees after a final judgment on the merits, noting that the Federal Circuit "routinely reviews awards of fees under § 285 after it previously ruled on the merits." "The frivolous theory that the Eastern District of Texas lacked jurisdiction to award attorneys' fees does not come close to satisfying the grave-miscarriage-of-justice standard," Judge Dyk wrote.
The panel relied on decisions from the First and Third Circuits treating a failure to meet that standard as a jurisdictional defect. It added that Traxcell never raised its jurisdictional objection in the earlier fee appeal, citing Supreme Court precedent that a party that had the chance to litigate subject-matter jurisdiction may not reopen the question "in a collateral attack upon an adverse judgment."
In a second, separate holding, the panel concluded the Western District lacked jurisdiction "whether or not the Beggerly standard is satisfied," because one district court may not entertain an independent action to set aside another district court's judgment once it has been affirmed on appeal. The court that issued a judgment can hear independent actions against it, the panel explained, but the Supreme Court has not decided whether such an action may be brought in a different court.
"Even if the jurisdiction of the second federal court exists, it cannot extend to this case," Judge Dyk wrote, because Traxcell's suit "seeks to countermand a judgment already affirmed by this court." The panel cited rulings from the D.C. Circuit and the Fifth Circuit holding that a district court cannot overturn an appeals court's order, including the Fifth Circuit's statement that Rule 60(b)(6) "certainly does not confer super-appellate jurisdiction on the district court."
William Peterson Ramey III of Ramey LLP argued for Traxcell. Jacob Kevin Baron of Holland & Knight LLP argued for Verizon, which was sued as Cellco Partnership, doing business as Verizon Wireless.
The case now returns to the Western District of Texas for dismissal. Traxcell's emergency motion challenging the fee award remains pending in the Eastern District, according to the opinion. The appeals are Traxcell Technologies LLC v. Cellco Partnership, Nos. 2025-1496 and 2025-1683.