Key Points
- The First District denied the Florida Center for Government Accountability and Michael Barfield leave to appear as appellees, to withhold the mandate, or to obtain rehearing, clarification, rehearing en banc, or certification.
- Under section 905.28, only the individual a grand jury report relates to and the State have a cognizable interest in repression and expungement proceedings; the statute confers no standing on a stranger to the report.
- Limited intervention granted to test a closure order did not make the movants parties to the repression and expungement merits, and the court's October 7 reversal of the March 25 order left them with no subsisting grant of intervention.
- The rehearing request independently failed because it raised new issues and relied on matters outside the record.
- The court said the statute may need legislative refinement to protect presentment confidentiality and pointed to criminal sanctions for unlawful disclosure of grand jury material.
A Florida appeals court on Nov. 16 refused to let a government-accountability group and its director challenge the court's decision to expunge a Leon County grand jury report, holding that the state law protecting people criticized in such reports gives no voice to outsiders the report does not concern.
A three-judge panel of the First District Court of Appeal denied every part of a motion filed by the Florida Center for Government Accountability Inc. and Michael Barfield. They had asked to appear as appellees, to have the court withhold its mandate and keep the report under seal, and to obtain rehearing, clarification, rehearing en banc and certification. Judge Neff wrote the order, and Judges Bilbrey and M.K. Thomas concurred.
The ruling leaves in place the court's Oct. 7 opinion, which reversed a trial judge's refusal to expunge the report entirely and sent the case back with directions to expunge it in full. Under the order, only the people a report concerns and the State may litigate whether it should be suppressed. A news organization allowed into the case for the narrow purpose of challenging a closure order does not become a party to that dispute.
The case turns on section 905.28 of the Florida Statutes, which governs a presentment, or grand jury report, that relates to an individual but is not accompanied by a true bill or indictment. Such a report is confidential until "the individual concerned" receives a copy and has 15 days to ask the circuit court to repress or expunge any portion that is improper and unlawful. That motion delays release until any appeal ends. The Legislature created the process, Judge Neff wrote, "so that those impugned in a Presentment may have adequate process to clear their names."
The Leon County Circuit Court granted the group and Barfield limited intervention on March 25, 2026, "to test the correctness of the trial court's closure order (if any)," while denying them access to the presentment, the repression and expungement motions and the hearings. On July 8, the circuit court reaffirmed those limits and directed the State Attorney to notify them within three days of any appeal. On July 29, it repressed and expunged most of the presentment but denied full expungement. The Oct. 7 opinion reversed the notification orders, including the March 25 order, so the movants, the court said in a footnote, "no longer hold a subsisting grant of intervention."
The panel held that only two kinds of participants have a cognizable interest in a section 905.28 proceeding: the person or entity the report relates to and whose character it impugns, and the State, acting through the state attorney as the grand jury's legal adviser and the attorney general on appeal. The movants, the court said, fit neither category. They "do not contend that the Presentment relates to them or impugns their character" and are a "news organization" and its "director" seeking access to the proceeding.
"Section 905.28 confers no standing on a stranger to the report," Judge Neff wrote.
The court grounded its reasoning in grand jury secrecy, quoting the U.S. Supreme Court's observation that "there are some kinds of government operations that would be totally frustrated if conducted openly," with the grand jury as a classic example. Judge Neff wrote that "extending access, or a merits role, to a person who is a stranger to the proceeding and holds no statutory interest in it would place confidential grand jury material in the hands of one with no corresponding incentive to preserve its confidentiality."
A circuit court's "ability to preserve the confidentiality of a presentment while the statutory process runs its course may require legislative refinement," the order said. Until lawmakers act, it added, vigorous enforcement of criminal penalties against those who unlawfully disclose grand jury testimony or evidence, and against those who solicit or conspire to obtain such disclosures, "would go far in curing the statutory shortcomings." A footnote cautioned against giving such materials to strangers to the proceeding, adding that "this caution carries added weight where, for example, such a person has a history of misconduct before a grand jury."
The court found the group's position foreclosed by a 1988 Second District decision from Pinellas County, in which a newspaper and one of its reporters were granted intervention only to seek review of an order blocking access to repression motions. That court held the newspaper had no First Amendment right of access to those motions. The limited intervention there, Judge Neff wrote, was "precisely the limited intervention the circuit court granted here."
The group cited precedent holding that intervenors are ordinarily parties who may be designated appellees. The panel responded that an intervenor's participation extends only as far as the interest supporting it. "An intervenor cannot bootstrap a limited procedural interest into standing to relitigate a determination on interests the statute does not assign to the intervenor," the order said. The court likewise rejected the argument that the group had been denied notice of the appeal, writing that "service and notice follow party status in the proceeding; they do not create it."
The rehearing request failed for separate reasons as well. The court held that an intervenor admitted for a limited purpose cannot seek rehearing of matters outside it and that rehearing motions may not raise new issues. The movants concede they have not seen the record, the briefs or the exhibits, and they "instead rest on extensive argument and materials never presented to this court," Judge Neff wrote.
The order lists counsel for other participants, including Katie Strickland, James Uthmeier and Jason Weida, without describing their connection to the presentment. Lawyers for Strickland included Jesse Panuccio of Boies Schiller Flexner LLP, and the State was represented by Acting Attorney General Bradford L. Thomas. Barfield represented himself. The Florida Center for Government Accountability was represented by Barbara A. Petersen of Tallahassee and Robert Craig Waters of Pensacola.
The order states that it is not final until the court disposes of any timely and authorized motion under Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure 9.330 or 9.331. The denial leaves undisturbed the Oct. 7 directions to the circuit court to expunge the presentment in full.