Key Points

  • The Fourth District reversed a Broward County small claims court's with-prejudice dismissal of a suit alleging that a website's third-party tracking scripts violated Florida's Security of Communications Act and invaded visitors' privacy.
  • The Florida Small Claims Rules do not authorize a defendant to move to dismiss before the plaintiff presents evidence and do not incorporate Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.140(b).
  • A pre-evidence motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim is authorized in small claims court only if the court has invoked the civil rules under Small Claims Rule 7.020(c) through an affirmative act, such as a case-specific order or a standing administrative order.
  • Granting a motion brought under the civil rules does not by itself invoke those rules, and parties cannot invoke them unilaterally by filing such a motion.
  • The panel did not reach the merits of the wiretap or privacy claims and held that its ruling mooted the plaintiff's second issue.

A Florida appeals court on Wednesday revived a lawsuit accusing a nutrition company's website of tracking visitors without their consent, holding that a Broward County small claims judge had no procedural basis to throw the case out before the plaintiff presented any evidence.

A three-judge panel of the Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed an order dismissing Heriberto Valiente's complaint against 5 Star Nutrition, LLC with prejudice. Judge May wrote the opinion, and Judges Shepherd and Shaw concurred. The case now returns to the county court for further proceedings.

The decision turns on procedure, not on whether website tracking violates Florida's wiretap law. The panel held that the rules governing small claims cases do not allow the early motion to dismiss that the civil rules permit at the outset of a case unless the court has taken an affirmative step to apply the civil rules. A judge's act of granting such a motion, the court said, is not that step.

Valiente sued in small claims court, alleging violations of Florida's Security of Communications Act, chapter 934 of the Florida Statutes, and invasion of privacy. According to the opinion, he alleged that the company operated a commercial website that "installed third-party scripts on visitors' web browsers without their consent," allowing the company and third parties to collect personal information, intercept electronic communications and monitor visitors' internet activity.

5 Star Nutrition moved to dismiss for failure to state a cause of action. It argued that standard analytics and advertising tools were not unlawful interception under the statute because they collected routing and identifying information rather than the contents of electronic communications. The company also argued that it could not unlawfully intercept communications directed to itself, that the conduct alleged was not an actionable invasion of privacy, and that the dismissal should be with prejudice.

The company submitted a proposed order granting its motion. Two days later, and 17 days after the motion was filed, Judge Woody R. Clermont entered an order dismissing the complaint with prejudice. The order concluded that collecting IP addresses, routing data and related technical information was not interception of the contents of communications under chapter 934. As the appellate opinion described it, the trial court further determined that "ordinary website analytics did not constitute unlawful wiretapping." It also found that Valiente had failed to state a privacy claim and that any amendment would be futile because the problems were legal rather than factual.

Judge Clermont ruled without a hearing. The appellate court noted that the record did not show Valiente had filed a response or asked for a hearing in the 17 days the motion was pending. In a footnote, the panel added that a hearing on a separate defense motion to continue a pretrial conference had been set for later that day, but the motion to dismiss "was never noticed for hearing."

On appeal, Valiente argued that the Florida Small Claims Rules do not authorize a motion to dismiss before the plaintiff presents evidence, and that the trial court never invoked Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.140(b)(6), the civil rule that permits a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. The panel agreed. It reviewed the question de novo.

Judge May contrasted the two sets of rules. The civil rules let a defendant seek dismissal at the outset, but "the Florida Small Claims Rules do not authorize a defendant to move to dismiss an action before the plaintiff's presentation of evidence," the opinion said. The small claims rules, the court added, do not incorporate rule 1.140(b).

A small claims court may still choose to apply the civil rules. Under Small Claims Rule 7.020(c), it can do so on a party's application, by stipulation of all parties, or on its own motion. But the panel held that "unless the court has invoked the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, pursuant to rule 7.020(c), a pre-evidence motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim is not authorized in small claims court."

The court then set out what counts as invoking the civil rules. "Court invocation under rule 7.020(c) requires an affirmative act, such as a case-specific order or a standing administrative order applying the Rules of Civil Procedure to designated cases," Judge May wrote, citing the Fourth District's 2022 decision in Mech v. Brazilian Waxing By Sisters, Inc., where the trial court had entered a written order invoking those rules.

Neither a ruling nor a filing is enough, the panel held. "Merely granting a motion brought under the Rules of Civil Procedure does not itself establish that the court invoked those rules," the opinion said. Relying on another 2022 Fourth District decision, Fisher v. Aberdeen Golf & Country Club, Inc., the court added that parties "cannot unilaterally invoke the Rules of Civil Procedure by filing a motion premised on those rules' application."

Applying those principles, the panel called 5 Star Nutrition's motion "procedurally improper." The company filed it before Valiente had presented any evidence, and the record did not show that rule 1.140(b) had been invoked by motion, stipulation or order. "Thus, the trial court lacked a procedural basis to grant the defendant's motion to dismiss," Judge May wrote.

The appellate court did not address the trial judge's conclusions about whether website analytics can amount to interception under chapter 934. It also declined to reach a second issue Valiente raised, writing that "Our decision on the first issue moots the plaintiff's second issue." The opinion does not describe that second issue.

Valiente was represented on appeal by James P. Gitkin of Salpeter Gitkin, LLP, in Hollywood. The opinion records no appearance for 5 Star Nutrition.

The Fourth District reversed the dismissal order and remanded the case to the county court for further proceedings. The opinion states that it is not final until the disposition of any timely-filed motion for rehearing.