Key Points
- The Fourth District held that an attorney is subject to sanctions for briefs that cite real cases for propositions they do not support, and that counsel's lack of bad faith or intent to mislead is no excuse.
- The court said attorneys who use artificial intelligence to assist them are responsible for the content of their briefs and must ensure their accuracy.
- The court found that the appellee's response to its show-cause order, a table that mostly reformatted citations, did not correct any misstated legal holdings.
- In a companion eviction appeal, the same panel said inaccurate case law is sanctionable even when filed by a pro se litigant.
- The court affirmed both judgments and declined sanctions, but cautioned both parties that future citation problems may lead to sanctions under Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.410(a).
A Florida appeals court on Nov. 18 warned a litigant whose lawyer admitted using artificial intelligence for legal research that citing real cases for holdings they do not contain can draw sanctions whether or not the lawyer acted in bad faith.
The Fourth District Court of Appeal affirmed the lower court's ruling in Beavers v. Pond without discussing the merits and declined to impose sanctions. But Judge Shaw, writing for a panel that included Judges May and Shepherd, held that counsel's claimed lack of bad faith was irrelevant and cautioned the appellee that future citation problems may result in sanctions under Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.410(a).
The same panel issued a parallel opinion the same day, also by Judge Shaw, in an eviction appeal brought by a tenant without a lawyer. The two rulings apply the court's holding earlier this year in Eclectic Synergy, LLC v. Seredin, that citing actual cases for propositions they do not support is as serious as citing cases that do not exist.
Archie Beavers appealed a ruling from the Broward County Circuit Court, where Judge Natasha DePrimo presided. The Fourth District wrote to address the answer brief filed for the appellee, Melissa D. Pond, which the court said "contained multiple citations to cases that are real, but do not stand for the proposition ascribed to them."
"These citations do not assist the court and, in fact, create more work for the court and the opposing party," Judge Shaw wrote. In affirming, the panel "expressly disregarded the citations that misstated court holdings."
On Oct. 21, the court ordered the appellee to show cause why sanctions should not be imposed for a brief that appeared to include "fabricated or 'hallucinated' references to non-existent or inaccurately-cited legal authorities." The response recognized "errors in the case citations" and stated that "the research utilized to gather those citations were partially computer aided intelligence programs."
The response also argued that the brief's arguments were neither frivolous nor made in bad faith, and that none of the citations had been "hallucinated" but were instead inaccurately cited. It closed with a table pairing each citation as originally written with a "correct(ed)" version.
The court found that the table did not offer "substantive corrections to citations" except in one instance and did not "correct any misstated legal holdings." Instead, Judge Shaw wrote, "the table only updated the format of citations—curiously changing the format from Bluebook-approved to another format." The lone substantive change, according to a footnote, replaced a citation to Fla. Air Academy, Inc. v. McKinley at 697 So. 2d 534 with one at 688 So. 2d 359.
"The appellee's response missed the point," Judge Shaw wrote. Quoting Eclectic Synergy, the court said "an attorney is subject to sanctions for filings that … 'cite actual cases for inaccurate legal propositions.'" Such errors "are just as egregious as citations to non-existent cases," the panel wrote, again quoting Eclectic Synergy, which cited a 2025 Second District decision that sanctioned counsel for a brief that "misstated court holdings."
The panel also rejected the idea that good intentions matter, stating through a further quotation in Eclectic Synergy that it is not an "excuse that the attorney did not intend to mislead the court." "Counsel's alleged lack of 'bad faith' is irrelevant, as is counsel's contention that the arguments made were not frivolous," Judge Shaw wrote. A footnote added that "briefs that are filed in bad faith or contain frivolous arguments can be subject to sanctions."
"Attorneys who use artificial intelligence to assist them, like appellee's counsel admittedly did here, are responsible for the content of their briefs and must ensure their accuracy," the opinion said. The court declined to issue sanctions "at this time."
In the second case, Narinesingh v. Brickbox Federal, LLC, the panel affirmed without discussion a final judgment of eviction that Broward County Court Judge Jackie Powell entered for the landlord, Brickbox Federal LLC, and against the tenant, Terrence Narinesingh.
Narinesingh, who is proceeding pro se, meaning without a lawyer, had filed an amended initial brief to correct one hallucinated citation. The court said that brief "still contained multiple citations to real cases that did not actually stand for the propositions cited." That opinion does not say whether the tenant used artificial intelligence.
After an Oct. 14 order to show cause, Narinesingh accepted responsibility, acknowledging that "certain authorities in the Amended Initial Brief were not adequately verified and that some citations, quotations, and propositions attributed to judicial decisions require correction or withdrawal," according to a footnote in the opinion.
"It is well-established that the submission of fictitious, fabricated, or otherwise inaccurate case law is sanctionable, even where a party is not an attorney and is proceeding pro se," Judge Shaw wrote, citing two earlier 2026 Fourth District decisions and a 2024 Third District ruling. "This includes citations to cases that do not stand for what is argued," the court added, again quoting Eclectic Synergy. The panel declined to sanction the tenant but issued the same Rule 9.410(a) caution.
Beavers was represented by Dexter F. George of the Law Office of Dexter F. George in Plantation. Pond was represented by Marla J. Ferguson of Marla J. Ferguson Law, P.A., in Davie. In the eviction appeal, Brickbox Federal was represented by Darren Ayoub of Barfield McCain Ayoub, P.A., in West Palm Beach; Narinesingh represented himself.
Both opinions, in case Nos. 4D2025-1473 and 4D2025-3787, state that they are not final until the court disposes of any timely-filed motion for rehearing.