Key Points
- The Supreme Court of Texas conditionally granted mandamus relief to Marquez AD, LLC and directed the district court to vacate its September 2024 order and reinstate the November 2023 final judgment.
- The court held that the district court's plenary power to modify the judgment beyond clerical errors expired in December 2023, and Adreon had not filed a bill of review.
- The court held that the trial judge's equivocal bench remarks about nominal fees were not an oral rendition of judgment, so any error in the signed fee award was judicial rather than clerical and could not be corrected by judgment nunc pro tunc.
- Because Adreon's counsel never filed a response, the court held Adreon forfeited his argument and cautioned that the opinion resolves this case only and does not alter the law on judgments nunc pro tunc.
- In a footnote, the court expressed no view on the judgment's validity or enforceability in the face of fraud allegations.
The Supreme Court of Texas held that a trial judge had no power to cut a landscaping company's attorney's fee award from almost $82,000 to roughly $2,000 more than nine months after signing a final judgment, because the court's authority to change that judgment had expired and the reduction corrected a judicial decision rather than a clerical mistake.
In an unsigned per curiam opinion delivered Nov. 20, the court conditionally granted mandamus relief to Marquez AD, LLC. It directed the district court to vacate its September 2024 order and reinstate the November 2023 judgment in Marquez's favor.
The ruling restores a fee award the trial court tried to undo long after the 30-day window for revising a judgment. The justices decided the case without hearing from the other side: counsel for the defendant, Jarrod Adreon, never filed a response, and on one attempt submitted a "blank piece of paper, which we struck before again requesting the correct document," the court wrote.
Marquez, which the opinion describes as a landscaping business, sued Adreon in May 2021 over a contract dispute. The parties agreed that the court would decide attorney's fees after a jury trial, and Marquez prevailed at trial in August 2023. It then moved for fees of almost $82,000 and attached a proposed final judgment.
At an Oct. 16, 2023, hearing on fees, the judge said from the bench that the court was inclined to let each party recover only a nominal amount. According to the opinion, the judge described that view as "that’s what I’m feeling" and "that’s what I feel is just at this point." About a month later, on Nov. 20, 2023, the court signed Marquez's proposed judgment, which awarded almost $82,000 in fees and stated that it "finally disposes of all claims and all parties and is appealable."
The case then sat dormant for eight months. In July 2024, Adreon moved to reform the judgment, and on Sept. 3, 2024, the court signed an order prepared by Adreon that vacated the "erroneous" judgment, lowered the fees to roughly $2,000 and required Marquez to "immediately return all funds seized under the erroneous judgment." A handwritten notation on the order said the earlier judgment "was obtained by misleading the court," but the justices wrote that "the record and argument before us lacks any explanation of how the district court was misled into signing the judgment."
Marquez sought mandamus relief in the court of appeals in Austin, without success, and then petitioned the Supreme Court, arguing that the September order was void because the trial court had lost plenary power before signing it. Plenary power is a trial court's authority to vacate, modify, correct or reform its judgment, which lasts for 30 days after the judgment is signed under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 329b.
"Attempting to set aside a final judgment after plenary power has expired is a serious jurisdictional overstep for which a writ of mandamus is an appropriate remedy," the court wrote. After plenary power ends, the opinion said, a court may change a final judgment only through a bill of review or through a judgment nunc pro tunc, a device for correcting clerical errors. Adreon had not filed a bill of review, so the trial court's power to go beyond clerical corrections expired in December 2023, the court concluded.
The court then took up the argument that Adreon "might have argued" had he responded: that the September order was a valid correction nunc pro tunc. Citing its 1986 decision in Escobar v. Escobar, the court explained that a judge may fix a written judgment that misstates what was actually decided, but if a court "renders [judgment] incorrectly, it cannot alter a written judgment which precisely reflects the incorrect rendition."
Applying that line, the court held that the judge's bench remarks did not count as a decision. "The equivocal statements at the October 16 hearing were plainly not a firm decision by the court, much less an oral rendition of judgment," the opinion said. Instead, it said, the signed judgment was "the first and only indication in the record of a decision by the court on the amount of attorney’s fees." Any mistake in the amount, the court wrote, "was a judicial error in the substance of the court’s announced decision—not a clerical error in the memorialization of the court’s decision," and fixing it required plenary power the trial court no longer had.
Adreon's silence figured in the result. The court said his counsel twice missed the deadline to respond and did not file despite "numerous polite reminders from our patient and professional Clerk’s office." "Our conclusion might be different if Adreon had complied with directives from this Court," the justices wrote, and had defended his position persuasively. Citing the equitable principle that "equity aids the diligent and not those who slumber on their rights," the court held that Adreon had forfeited the right to argue that the fee award was a clerical error.
The court also limited the reach of its ruling. Because there was no adversarial presentation, it cautioned that the opinion "resolves this case only, and nothing herein should be understood to alter in any way the law regarding judgments nunc pro tunc."
In a footnote, the court said that "there may be plenty of blame to go around in this curious case," noting that the district court believed the original judgment had been procured by fraud. By granting relief based on the judgment's finality, the justices wrote, "we express no view on its validity or enforceability in the face of fraud allegations."
Karalynn C. Cromeens of The Cromeens Law Firm, PLLC represented Marquez. John Cook of The Moster Law Firm, P.C. represented Adreon, according to court filings.
The district court must now vacate its September 2024 order and reinstate the November 2023 judgment. "We are confident the court will comply, and the writ will issue only if it does not," the court wrote. The case is In re Marquez AD, LLC, No. 25-0175.