Key Points

  • The Supreme Court of Texas granted Jorge Arellano's motion for rehearing and his petition for review, vacated the Third Court of Appeals' judgment and remanded without oral argument.
  • The court held that Magdaleno Villegas's confession of error, read against Huffman Asset Management, LLC v. Colter, meant the judgments below could not stand.
  • Villegas acknowledged, in responding to the rehearing motion and seemingly for the first time, that the record did not support the lost-wage and medical-expense awards the appeals court had affirmed.
  • The court said Huffman leaves no doubt that no-answer default judgments require enhanced scrutiny.
  • The appeals court must reassess the evidence and Villegas's concessions, including whether the concessions bear on the $50,000 pain-and-suffering award, on which the Supreme Court expressed no view.

The Supreme Court of Texas on Nov. 20 threw out an appeals court ruling that left part of a car-wreck default judgment intact, holding that the plaintiff's own admission that the record did not support some of her damages, combined with the court's recent warnings about default judgments, meant the rulings could not survive. "Villegas's confession of error, read against the principles Huffman articulated, compels us to conclude that the judgments below cannot stand," the court wrote.

The per curiam opinion granted a motion for rehearing filed by the defendant, Jorge Arellano, granted the petition for review without hearing oral argument, vacated the judgment of the Third Court of Appeals in Austin and sent the case back to that court. The justices directed the appeals court to reassess the evidence offered by the plaintiff, Magdaleno Villegas, and the concessions she has made along the way.

The decision applies Huffman Asset Management, LLC v. Colter, a 2026 ruling in which the court expressed heightened skepticism of default judgments. Under the order, the appeals court is expected to take a second look not only at the awards Villegas has conceded but also at a $50,000 pain-and-suffering award she still seeks to keep, which the appeals court had upheld partly on the same evidence offered for awards she now concedes the record does not support.

Villegas sued Arellano over injuries sustained in connection with a car wreck. The trial court entered a no-answer default judgment and awarded Villegas $605.44 for past lost wages, $4,233 for past medical expenses, $15,000 for past mental anguish, $35,000 for past physical impairment, $50,000 for past physical pain and suffering and $150,000 in exemplary damages.

On appeal, Villegas asked the Austin court for a remittitur. She stated that she "does not contest Arellano's [evidentiary-sufficiency] complaints about the trial court's award of damages for lost wages, medical expenses, mental anguish[,] and physical impairment," and asked the court to cut the judgment by $54,838.44.

The court of appeals took a different path. It held the evidence legally insufficient to support the mental-anguish, physical-impairment and exemplary-damages awards and remanded those issues for a new trial. It affirmed the awards for lost wages, medical expenses and pain and suffering, including the two smaller categories Villegas had said she did not contest.

Before the Supreme Court, Villegas went further. In her merits briefing, she asked the justices to "reverse and render a judgment that [she] take[] nothing on all other categories of damages" except pain and suffering, because she "does not wish to pursue a new trial" on those damages.

The Supreme Court's citation to the appeals court's decision records that review had been denied. Arellano then moved for rehearing. In her response to that motion, Villegas reiterated that she is "willing to abandon the opportunity for a new trial" on the remanded categories and seeks affirmance only of the pain-and-suffering award. She also said she "does not disagree" with Arellano's contention that, at a minimum, the court should have reduced the award in line with her concessions.

The response went a step beyond her earlier filings. Villegas acknowledged that "the record did not contain sufficient evidence to support some of the damages that the court of appeals affirmed," meaning the lost-wage and medical-expense awards. The court noted that she made that acknowledgment "seemingly for the first time" and that it "appears Villegas did not offer that express concession in her prior briefing."

Meanwhile, the legal backdrop had shifted. About two months after merits briefing closed, and more than a year after the appeals court ruled, the Supreme Court decided Huffman. In that case, the court expressed heightened skepticism "of default judgments, regardless of the precise legal issue under consideration or the procedural posture in which the case arises." A concurrence by Justice Huddle in Huffman described default judgments as "barely tolerable" and said that in recent years they have become "nearly verboten."

The Nov. 20 opinion drew a direct line from Huffman to this case. "If it were not clear previously, Huffman leaves no doubt that no-answer default judgments require enhanced scrutiny," the court wrote, adding that such scrutiny serves to safeguard what Huffman called "the legitimacy of our legal system."

The justices gave the appeals court specific instructions. It must reassess Villegas's evidentiary submissions and her concessions, "including whether her abandonment of a new trial on the remanded categories depends on affirmance of the pain-and-suffering award." The opinion also observed that the appeals court's analysis of the pain-and-suffering award "relied in part on the same evidence offered to support the lost-wage and medical-expense awards," which Villegas now concedes the record does not support, so the lower court may consider whether her concessions bear on that analysis too.

The court stopped short of deciding whether the pain-and-suffering award should stand. "Although we express no view on the merits of the pain-and-suffering award, we expect the court of appeals on remand to carefully assess and explain whether sufficient evidence supports that portion of the judgment," the opinion said, citing Huffman.

David L. Plaut of Hanna & Plaut, LLP represented Arellano. Matthew J. Kita represented Villegas.

The case, No. 25-0207, now returns to the Third Court of Appeals for further proceedings consistent with the Supreme Court's opinion, including a reassessment of Villegas's evidentiary submissions and her concessions.