Key Points

  • The Supreme Court of Texas granted Santander's petition for review, reversed the Fifth District Court of Appeals' judgment and remanded for that court to consider Santander's jury-charge complaints in the first instance.
  • The court held that Santander preserved its objection that Question 8B permitted an award of lost-profits damages unsupported by evidence, and that Santander did not also have to request separate answer blanks for direct and consequential damages.
  • The court held that, under the specific facts of the case, the trial court's global "Refused" notation on Santander's pretrial proposed charge, together with the judge's assurances that the record was protected, preserved Santander's requests for limiting instructions on Question 1 and a separate waiver question.
  • The court distinguished Cruz v. Andrews Restoration, Inc., where the trial court had never refused the requested questions and the complaining party never objected.
  • The court declined to address Santander's separate challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence supporting the $5 million damages award and expressed no opinion on whether the charge was erroneous or harmful.

The Supreme Court of Texas held on Nov. 20 that Santander Consumer USA Inc. raised its objections to the jury instructions at trial clearly enough to have them heard on appeal, reversing a Dallas appeals court that had refused to consider them in a contract dispute that ended in a $5 million judgment for Enterprise Financial Group Inc.

In an unsigned per curiam opinion issued without oral argument, the court granted Santander's petition for review, reversed the judgment of the Court of Appeals for the Fifth District of Texas and remanded. That court must now decide whether the jury charge was erroneous and, if so, whether any error caused harm.

The case turned on error preservation. The court held that Santander's objection that there was no evidence of lost profits was enough to challenge a damages question with a single answer blank, without a request for separate blanks. It also held that, on these facts, a judge's global "Refused" notation on Santander's pretrial proposed charge, paired with assurances that the record was protected, preserved the requests in that proposal.

According to the opinion, Santander makes auto loans to dealerships nationwide, and Enterprise sells consumer protection products, including guaranteed asset protection, or GAP, policies that help pay for losses not covered by insurance when a car is totaled or stolen. Under a 2012 agreement, Santander marketed and sold Enterprise's GAP policies as add-ons to car loans. The arrangement proved unsuccessful, and Enterprise terminated the agreement in 2017 and sued for breach of contract. Santander counterclaimed.

At the charge conference, Santander objected to Question 8B, which asked what sum would compensate Enterprise and gave a single answer blank without defining "damages." Santander argued that the agreement allowed consequential damages only upon a finding of gross negligence, bad faith or willful misconduct, the subject of Question 8A, and that the question "opens it up to an award of either direct or consequential" damages without that finding. It also argued that Enterprise's evidence could not support lost profits from future contracts and asked that the jury be told to consider only direct damages.

Enterprise responded that the parties "[d]o not agree what damages are what" and that the charge would let the court "revisit the damages number after trial." The trial court overruled the objection.

The jury found that both companies breached the agreement, that Santander breached first and that Enterprise's breach was excused. It put Enterprise's damages at $5 million and Santander's at $4.2 million. Because Enterprise's breach was excused, the trial court disregarded Santander's damages and entered a $5 million judgment for Enterprise, plus interest and attorney's fees.

The Dallas court affirmed in June 2025, concluding that none of Santander's three charge complaints was preserved and that Santander should have asked for separate blanks for direct and consequential damages.

The Supreme Court disagreed on preservation. Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 274, the court noted, a party objecting to a charge "must point out distinctly the objectionable matter and the grounds of the objection." Santander did both, the court held, by identifying the "submission of a damages question that permitted an award of lost profits" and stating as its ground "that there was no evidence of lost profits."

Enterprise's own answer at the conference "confirms that Santander's objection was sufficiently plain to make the trial court aware of its complaint," the court wrote. Nor did Santander need to request separate blanks, the court said: "it would have been inconsistent for Santander to request a separate blank for consequential damages when it was objecting that they could not be submitted to the jury at all."

The second issue concerned limiting instructions on Question 1, the breach-of-contract question and a separate question on a waiver defense concerning continued operations. Santander requested both in its pretrial proposed charge but did not object to their omission at the charge conference. On the last day of trial, the judge marked the cover pages of both sides' proposed charges "Refused," signed them and told the parties the notation protected their record "that the Court refused" their "particular jury charges."

The appeals court had held that a global denial "based solely on the parties' pretrial submission of proposed jury charges does not preserve issues of charge error for appellate review." The Supreme Court answered: "In this case, at least, the pretrial proposed charge does not stand alone."

The court distinguished its 2012 decision in Cruz v. Andrews Restoration, Inc., which held that filing a pretrial charge did not preserve error because the trial court never refused the requested questions and the complaining party never objected despite "ample time to review the draft charge." Here, the court pointed to the express refusal, the judge's assurances and "the quite short time between the refusal and the charge conference," which took place later that same day. It held the refusals preserved in a case "where a global refusal was accompanied by assurances that the trial court was aware of and the record protected as to particular charge requests."

James D. Nelson of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP represented Santander. Charles E. Fowler of McKool Smith, P.C. represented Enterprise.

On remand, the Fifth District is to decide whether overruling the Question 8B objection was error for lack of evidence of lost profits and, if so, whether it was harmful. The Supreme Court cited its 2024 decision in Horton v. Kansas City Southern Railway, which held that error is not presumed harmful when a question includes a theory lacking legally sufficient evidentiary support. The appeals court must also decide whether each refused request was erroneous and harmful. The Supreme Court declined to reach Santander's separate sufficiency challenge because Santander seeks only a new trial on that ground, the same remedy that would follow harmful charge error.