Key Points

  • The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed a trial court order denying a petition to vacate, and granting a cross-petition to confirm, a Diamond Dealers Club arbitration award.
  • The court held that the sellers' disagreement with the outcome did not place the award outside the arbitrators' authority, and the sellers identified no specifically enumerated limitation the arbitrators failed to observe.
  • The court held that arbitrators may issue an award without providing their underlying reasoning.
  • The court held the award rational because the arbitrators could have found that the sellers of the purportedly stolen gem should bear the forfeiture loss, whether or not the federal court's finding that the diamond was cut from the stolen stone was correct.

A New York appeals court on Tuesday upheld an arbitration award in favor of a diamond buyer who sought the return of the price it paid for a 15.88-carat stone that a federal court ordered forfeited after investigators linked it to a gem stolen in Qatar. The court held that the arbitrators did not have to explain their decision and that the sellers' attack on the forensic evidence did not justify setting the award aside.

A four-justice panel of the Appellate Division, First Department, consisting of Justices Mendez, Gesmer, Rosado and Hagler, with Justice Mendez presiding, unanimously affirmed an Oct. 7, 2025, order by Justice James d'Auguste of Supreme Court, New York County. That order denied the sellers' petition to vacate the award and granted the buyers' cross-petition to confirm it. The appellate decision is unsigned.

The ruling leaves the sellers, Australian Diamond Supply, Ltd. and its co-petitioners, including Lajb Blatman, bound by an award that a three-person panel of the New York Diamond Dealers Club, Inc. issued without stating any reasons. It also holds that the award could stand even if the federal finding that the diamond came from the stolen stone was wrong, because the arbitrators may simply have decided that the seller of a forfeited gem should bear the loss.

The dispute began with the sale of a 15.88-carat diamond, which the parties call the gray diamond, from Australian Diamond Supply to L.J. West Diamonds, Inc., one of the respondents in the case, which is captioned Matter of Blatman v. West. After the sale, according to the decision, L.J. West received a grand jury subpoena in a federal criminal investigation into the theft of precious stones from their owner in Qatar, and it gave the gray diamond to the U.S. Attorney's office for inspection.

The Gemological Institute of America examined the stone and concluded that it had been cut from one of the stolen gems, a 17.42-carat marquise-shaped diamond, the court wrote. The federal investigation showed that the stolen marquise diamond had been sent to a buyer in the United States who was not a party to the New York case. That buyer eventually pleaded guilty to mail fraud and interstate transportation of stolen property.

In an ancillary federal forfeiture proceeding, the federal court found that L.J. West lacked standing to contest the forfeiture. As the appeals court summarized the federal court's reasoning, "a thief cannot pass good title," so Australian Diamond Supply, as a purchaser of the stolen diamond, never acquired good title that it could convey to L.J. West. The federal court ordered the West parties to surrender the gray diamond to the Federal Bureau of Investigation, which returned the stone to its original owner.

L.J. West and the other respondents then went to arbitration before the Diamond Dealers Club, seeking return of the purchase price. On March 5, 2025, the club's three-member panel ruled in their favor. The decision, the appeals court noted, "did not include a written basis for its determination."

The sellers sued to vacate the award under Article 75 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules. They argued that the arbitrators exceeded their authority by issuing an irrational award, because physical differences between the gray diamond and the stolen marquise diamond showed that the gray diamond could not have been cut from the stolen gem.

The First Department rejected that argument. "Petitioners' disagreement with the outcome does not place it outside the arbitrators' authority," the court wrote, adding that the sellers did not identify any rule or "specifically enumerated limitation" that the arbitrators had failed to observe. The court cited its 2010 decision in Frankel v. Sardis for that standard and in agreeing with Justice d'Auguste that the sellers offered no argument that would warrant upsetting the award.

The court also held that the lack of a written explanation was no defect. "It was not improper to issue an award without providing underlying reasoning," the panel wrote, citing its 1981 decision in Tilbury Fabrics v. Stillwater, Inc., which the New York Court of Appeals affirmed in 1982.

The panel then addressed the sellers' central factual claim without deciding it. The court wrote that the arbitrators "did not necessarily rely on the findings in the federal forfeiture proceeding that the gray diamond was cut from the stolen diamond." Instead, the court reasoned, the arbitrators could have concluded that "the loss from the resulting forfeiture of the gray diamond properly was borne by petitioners as the sellers of the purportedly stolen gem, regardless of whether the federal court's determination was factually correct."

For that alternative ground, the court cited Menzel v. List, a 1969 decision of the Court of Appeals. On that basis, the panel held, the trial court "properly concluded that the award was not just plausible but rational," a standard the First Department drew from its 2002 decision in Azrielant v. Azrielant.

The appeals court disposed of the sellers' other arguments in a single sentence. "We have considered petitioners' remaining contentions and find them unavailing," the panel wrote. The decision does not state the purchase price of the gray diamond or the amount of the award.

Lawyers for the appellants included Brian K. Bernstein of The Law Offices of Brian K. Bernstein, PC. The respondents were represented by Lauren Martin of Clayman Rosenberg Kirshner & Linder, LLP.

The First Department affirmed without awarding costs to either side, leaving in place the trial court's order confirming the Diamond Dealers Club award. The decision, entered Nov. 17, 2026, is marked as uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.