Key Points

  • The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed an order denying a motion to strike the answers of the Chase defendants and Jones Lang LaSalle Americas Inc.
  • The panel, citing CPLR 3126, held the motion court properly exercised its discretion by awarding monetary sanctions instead of striking the pleadings.
  • The court found that the lack of communication within and among the defendants, including between Chase's insurance claims and global security departments, and clearly inadequate search affidavits were improper discovery conduct.
  • The court held it was not an abuse of discretion to find that the conduct did not necessarily rise to willful, contumacious or bad faith misconduct, especially because the surveillance video was ultimately produced.
  • As to JLL, the court noted that emails indicated the fall was not visible on the video and that nothing showed JLL possessed or reviewed the footage.

A New York appeals court on Nov. 17 refused to strike the answers of JPMorgan Chase and Jones Lang LaSalle in a lawsuit over a fall, holding that the trial judge properly exercised discretion by imposing monetary sanctions on the companies rather than ending their defense, even though they mishandled surveillance video during discovery.

A four-justice panel of the Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed an order of Justice Gerald Lebovits of State Supreme Court in Manhattan. Lebovits had denied plaintiff Kumrija Kolenovic's motion to strike the defendants' answers and had instead imposed monetary sanctions. The unsigned decision was issued by Justices Mendez, Gesmer, Rosado and Hagler, with Justice Mendez presiding.

The panel found that a lack of communication within and among the defendants was improper discovery conduct, but held that the trial court could permissibly conclude it did not necessarily rise to willful misconduct. At Chase, according to the decision, one department handled the lawsuit while another held the video, and the two did not communicate about it. The panel also gave weight to the fact that the video was eventually produced.

Kolenovic had asked Lebovits to strike the answers. The appeals court described that remedy as a "drastic step."

"The motion court properly exercised its discretion by awarding monetary discovery sanctions against defendants but declining to take the drastic step of striking their pleadings," the panel wrote, citing CPLR 3126 and a 1999 decision in Kihl v. Pfeffer. The appellate decision does not state the amount of the monetary sanctions.

The panel addressed each defendant's conduct separately. As to Jones Lang LaSalle Americas Inc., referred to in the decision as JLL, the court described an email chain in which JLL's project manager took part along with the Chase defendants' head of global security. In those emails, the security chief "stated that there was surveillance video from the time period of plaintiff's accident," the court wrote.

The same emails cut the other way, the panel found. They "also indicated that plaintiff's fall itself was not visible on the video, and there is no indication that JLL ever actually possessed or that any JLL employee actually reviewed footage of the accident," the decision said.

The Chase defendants, as the decision defines them, are Chase Bank, also known as JPMorgan Chase & Co., and JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. For them, the problem was internal. "As to the Chase defendants, the evidence indicates that this litigation was addressed by its insurance claims department, while the video was preserved within its global security department," the panel wrote. "There was no communication between these departments regarding the matter."

The court did not excuse that gap. It also faulted the defendants' search affidavits. "The apparent lack of communication within and among defendants and the production of clearly inadequate search affidavits constituted improper conduct during discovery," the panel wrote.

That finding did not compel the harsher remedy. The panel framed the question as whether the conduct amounted to willful, contumacious or bad faith misconduct. The panel held that "it was not an abuse of discretion for the court to conclude that these factors did not necessarily rise to the level of willful, contumacious, or bad faith misconduct," citing the First Department's 2026 decision in Vera v. Xolle Demo LLC.

Applying the abuse-of-discretion standard, the panel declined to disturb Lebovits's choice of sanction.

The panel also pointed to the eventual production of the video. "Thus, the court did not abuse its discretion by awarding monetary sanctions rather than striking defendants' pleadings, especially given that the demanded video was ultimately produced," the panel wrote, citing its 2010 decision in De Socio v. 136 E. 56th St. Owners Inc. The decision does not say when the video was produced or describe its contents beyond the emails' account.

The panel disposed of Kolenovic's other contentions in a single sentence. "We have considered plaintiff's remaining arguments and find them unavailing," the court wrote, without describing those arguments. The affirmance was entered without costs.

Besides the two Chase entities and JLL, the respondents on appeal included Vornado Two Penn Property L.L.C. and Vornado Two Penn Plaza, L.L.C., which were represented by the same firm as the Chase defendants. Turner Construction Company and other defendants are named in the caption as defendants rather than respondents, and the case also includes a third-party action.

Kolenovic was represented by Brett J. Nomberg of the Law Office of Brett J. Nomberg, PLLC. The Chase and Vornado respondents were represented by Thomas E. Stagg of Stagg Wabnik Law Group LLP. JLL was represented by Judy R. Meisel of Sobel Pevzner, LLC.

The decision leaves both the monetary sanctions and the defendants' answers in place. The case bears Index No. 155021/24 in Manhattan Supreme Court, where Lebovits issued the order under review. The appellate decision, reported as 2026 NY Slip Op 06773, is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.