Key Points

  • The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed a judgment confirming a FINRA arbitration award that gave DriveWealth LLC a total of $1,359,223.56 against Interest Financial LLC.
  • The court held that Interest Financial failed to show the arbitrators acted in manifest disregard of the law, either by knowingly ignoring a governing legal principle or by making an obvious error.
  • A standard FINRA award that announced only the result did not undermine the award's colorable justification because neither party requested an explained decision under FINRA's arbitration rules.
  • The panel's exclusion of Interest Financial's liability expert did not warrant vacatur because arbitrators have broad evidentiary discretion and no inadequacy in the record was shown.
  • The public-policy exception did not apply because enforcing the award does not clearly conflict with any well-defined public policy or endorse illegal conduct.

A New York appeals court on Tuesday upheld a $1.36 million arbitration award to broker-dealer DriveWealth LLC in its contract dispute with Interest Financial LLC, holding that the arbitrators' failure to explain their decision was no reason to set it aside because neither company had asked for an explanation.

A five-justice panel of the Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed a judgment of Justice Melissa Crane of Supreme Court, New York County. That judgment confirmed the award and gave DriveWealth a total of $1,359,223.56. The Nov. 17 decision was unsigned. The panel consisted of Justices Moulton, Scarpulla, Shulman, Pitt-Burke and Michael.

The ruling leaves the award in place and turns in part on a procedural choice the parties made in arbitration. When a FINRA panel issues a standard award announcing only the result, the First Department held, the absence of reasons does not undermine the award if neither party requested an explained decision under FINRA's arbitration rules.

The dispute arose from a Carrying Agreement, a contract under which DriveWealth, a FINRA-registered broker-dealer, provided execution, clearing, custody and related back-office services for Interest Financial's investment platform. The agreement required the companies to arbitrate their disputes.

DriveWealth filed a FINRA arbitration seeking unpaid invoices it said Interest Financial owed under the agreement. Interest Financial filed counterclaims alleging that DriveWealth's performance was deficient. Before the arbitrators, the companies litigated whether DriveWealth had materially breached the agreement by failing to meet its regulatory, execution, custody and service-level obligations.

After a seven-day hearing and extensive briefing, the FINRA panel rejected the counterclaims and awarded DriveWealth the unpaid invoices. Interest Financial then filed an article 75 petition in Supreme Court to vacate the award. DriveWealth cross-moved to confirm it.

Justice Crane denied the petition and granted the cross-motion in an order entered on or about Sept. 8, 2025. The judgment for DriveWealth followed on or about Oct. 3, 2025, and Interest Financial appealed both.

On appeal, the First Department took up Interest Financial's challenges to the arbitrators' treatment of the law, the bare form of the award, the exclusion of an expert witness and public policy. It rejected each.

Manifest disregard of the law is a ground for vacating an award that, under the standard the court applied, requires proof that the arbitrators "knew of a governing legal principle yet refused to apply it or ignored it altogether." The court held that Interest Financial had not made that showing, citing the 2006 decision in Wien & Malkin LLP v. Helmsley-Spear Inc.

Nor did the record show that the arbitrators made an error "so obvious that it would be instantly perceived by the average person qualified to serve as an arbitrator," the court held. It drew that test from its own 2003 decision in Sawtelle v. Waddell & Reed.

The court then addressed the form of the award. The FINRA panel had issued what the decision called "a standard award that simply announced the result." That did not undermine the court's determination "that the award had at least a barely colorable justification, because neither party made a request for an explained decision as required by the FINRA arbitration rules," the court wrote, citing its 2025 decision in Matter of CLSA Americas LLC v. Mayo.

Interest Financial's challenge to the exclusion of its proposed expert witness on liability fared no better. "Arbitrators possess broad discretion with respect to evidentiary rulings," the court wrote. It held that Interest Financial "has not shown that the exclusion rendered the record legally inadequate to support the panel's findings or, standing alone, establishes manifest disregard."

The court also rejected Interest Financial's contention that public policy required vacatur. The public-policy exception is narrow, the court wrote, and "applies only where enforcement of an award would violate an explicit statutory or decisional prohibition," citing the 2005 decision in Matter of Buffalo Police Benevolent Assn. [City of Buffalo]. "On this record, enforcing the award does not clearly conflict with any well-defined public policy or endorse illegal conduct," the court held.

The First Department dismissed Interest Financial's separate appeal from the September 2025 order as subsumed in the appeal from the judgment. That dismissal carried no costs.

Interest Financial was represented by Deborah Renner of Dentons US LLP. DriveWealth was represented by Michael J. Watling of Seward & Kissel, LLP.

The decision leaves in force the October 2025 judgment awarding DriveWealth $1,359,223.56, and the court awarded DriveWealth its costs on the appeal from that judgment. The decision, reported as 2026 NY Slip Op 06771, was released uncorrected and is subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.