Key Points
- The First Department held that the MTA respondents waived their objection to untimely service under CPLR 306-b when their counsel confirmed by email that they did not intend to contest service.
- The court found the waiver unequivocal and not limited to the form or location of service, and found that the email misled LoRusso to his prejudice by inducing him to agree to a new return date and delay seeking a retroactive extension.
- The court held the article 78 petition timely filed within four months of the MTA's June 5, 2024, letter terminating LoRusso's health coverage, the only unambiguously final determination in the record.
- The petition was reinstated against the MTA respondents and remanded for a hearing on factual issues including the MTA's eligibility criteria and whether LoRusso knowingly waived pension plan membership.
- The court affirmed the denial of an extension of time to serve NYSHIP, which was served 58 days late, and dismissed co-petitioner Edward Kramer's appeal as abandoned.
A New York appeals court on Tuesday revived a retiree's challenge to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's denial of his post-retirement health insurance, ruling that an email from the authority's lawyers promising not to contest service barred it from later seeking dismissal because the court papers had been served late.
A five-justice panel of the Appellate Division, First Department, ruled unanimously in an unsigned decision that a Manhattan trial judge should not have thrown out the case brought by Vincent LoRusso. The panel reinstated LoRusso's petition against the MTA and four related respondents and sent the case back for a hearing on the merits. The panel was made up of Justices Moulton, who presided, Scarpulla, Shulman, Pitt-Burke and Michael.
The ruling turns on a scheduling exchange between opposing lawyers. The court held that the MTA side's written confirmation that it would not contest service was a binding waiver, even though the same respondents later moved to dismiss on that ground. The panel left in place, however, the dismissal of LoRusso's claims against the New York State Health Insurance Program, a separate respondent that was served 58 days late and had made no such promise.
LoRusso brought the case under CPLR article 78. He sought to annul a June 5, 2024, determination by the MTA denying him post-retirement health insurance benefits. Besides the MTA, the petition named the New York City Transit Authority, the Long Island Rail Road, the MTA Defined Benefit Pension Plan and John Nathan Lieber, the authority's chairman and chief executive, a group the court referred to as the MTA respondents.
"It is undisputed that the petition was not timely served on any party," the panel wrote, citing CPLR 306-b.
According to the decision, after the petition was served on the MTA respondents, their counsel asked LoRusso to agree to adjourn the return date, and the lawyers conferred by phone. The MTA respondents' counsel then confirmed a new briefing schedule by email, writing, "We confirm[] that we do not intend to contest service as to the parties that we represent," and proposing new response and return dates.
LoRusso then filed an amended notice of petition with a return date of February 6. The MTA respondents moved to dismiss the petition on several grounds, including untimely service.
Justice Alexander M. Tisch of State Supreme Court in Manhattan granted that motion, denied LoRusso's cross-motion for more time to serve, denied the petition and dismissed the proceeding in a judgment entered Oct. 9, 2025.
The appeals court disagreed. "Supreme Court should have denied the MTA respondents' motion to dismiss," the panel wrote. It held that the email confirming the lawyers' telephone discussion "contained a clear manifestation of intent to relinquish that right," citing the First Department's 2021 decision in Homapour v. Harounian.
The panel also rejected any reading of the email as a narrower concession. "The waiver was unequivocal and did not suggest it was limited to the form or location of service," the court wrote.
The court found that LoRusso had relied on the promise to his detriment. He "was misled to his prejudice into believing that the MTA respondents intended a waiver insofar as counsel's email induced him to consent to an extension of the return date and to delay moving for a retroactive extension of time to serve," the panel wrote.
The MTA respondents had also argued that the petition itself was filed too late. The panel rejected that contention, holding that LoRusso filed within four months of the MTA's June 5, 2024, letter telling him that his health insurance coverage would be terminated. The court called that letter "the only unambiguously final determination in the record," citing the four-month limit in CPLR 217(1) and the Court of Appeals' 2000 decision in Matter of Carter v. State of N.Y., Exec. Dept., Div. of Parole.
The panel ordered a hearing on remand because factual disputes remain. It said the hearing must resolve "issues as to the MTA's asserted eligibility criteria and whether petitioner's waiver of membership in the MTA Defined Benefits Pension Plan was knowing."
LoRusso fared differently against the state health insurance program, known as NYSHIP. The panel held that the trial court "providently exercised its discretion" in refusing to extend his time to serve that respondent. LoRusso failed to show good cause, the court said, "because he did not attempt to serve any party until after the deadline."
The panel also found that the interest of justice factors weighed against LoRusso as to NYSHIP. NYSHIP did not know of his claims until it was served, and it did not induce him to delay. He did not seek an extension until four months after the service deadline, the court wrote, citing the Court of Appeals' 2001 decision in Leader v. Maroney, Ponzini & Spencer.
A second petitioner, Edward Kramer, had filed a notice of appeal from the same judgment, but his counsel told the court he was not pursuing it. The panel dismissed Kramer's appeal as abandoned. In light of its rulings, the court said it did not need to consider his remaining arguments.
Lawyers for LoRusso included James M. Thayer of Gordon, Gordon & Thayer P.C. The MTA respondents were represented by Myron D. Rumeld of Proskauer Rose LLP, and Samantha Neal of the state Attorney General's office represented NYSHIP.
The case now returns to State Supreme Court in Manhattan for a hearing on the merits of LoRusso's petition against the MTA respondents, while his claims against NYSHIP remain dismissed. The appellate court awarded no costs to either side. The decision is marked uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.