Key Points
- The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed the CPLR 3211(a)(2) dismissal of a former employee's religious discrimination claims under the New York State and New York City Human Rights Laws.
- The court held that the impact of the termination occurred in Nevada, where the plaintiff lived and worked, so New York courts lacked subject matter jurisdiction over the claims.
- Payment through a New York payroll system and operational support and training from the New York office were insufficient to plead a discriminatory impact in New York.
- The court found the plaintiff's reliance on Syeed v. Bloomberg L.P. misplaced because she did not plead that she sought and was denied an opportunity to work in New York.
A New York appeals court ruled on Nov. 17 that a former fundraiser for Breakthrough T1D who lived and worked in Nevada cannot pursue religious discrimination claims against the organization under New York's state and city human rights laws, because the effect of her firing was felt in Nevada rather than New York.
A four-justice panel of the Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed a trial judge's dismissal of the suit brought by Cortney Lidder, formerly known as Cortney Cortez-Huth. Breakthrough T1D, the defendant, was formerly known as Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation International. The decision was unsigned and issued as a decision and order of the court.
The ruling holds that a remote employee's administrative ties to an employer's New York office do not, on their own, bring an out-of-state firing within the reach of the New York State Human Rights Law and the New York City Human Rights Law. Those ties, as the panel described them, were a New York payroll system and operational support and training supplied from the New York office.
The panel also rejected Lidder's reliance on Syeed v. Bloomberg L.P., a 2024 decision of the Court of Appeals. Her reliance on that case was "misplaced, as she does not plead that she sought and was denied an opportunity to work in New York," the court wrote.
According to the allegations recounted in the decision, Lidder's role with the organization involved overseeing fundraising efforts in Nevada, Arizona and New Mexico. Her only in-person event was a fundraising gala in Las Vegas. She went to the organization's New York City office only once, for a training session.
Lidder sued her former employer in Supreme Court, New York County. She alleged that her termination amounted to religious discrimination in violation of the state and city laws. The decision does not describe the conduct she alleged to be discriminatory.
Breakthrough T1D moved to dismiss under CPLR 3211(a)(2). The motion court (Paul A. Goetz, J.) granted the motion in an order entered Dec. 12, 2025, and Lidder appealed.
The appellate panel was listed as Mendez, J.P., Gesmer, Rosado, Hagler, JJ. The panel held that the motion court "properly found that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction over plaintiff's religious discrimination claims against her former employer." The reason, the court wrote, was that "the impact on plaintiff of her termination occurred in Nevada, where she lived and worked."
For that rule the panel cited Hoffman v. Parade Publications, a 2010 Court of Appeals decision. It also cited two of the First Department's own rulings, Pakniat v. Moor from 2021 and Wolf v. Imus from 2019. The decision notes that the Court of Appeals denied leave to appeal in both of those cases.
The panel then addressed the New York connections in the complaint. It treated the payroll and support ties as given for purposes of the ruling and held that they did not change the outcome. Lidder's allegations about her work in Nevada, Arizona and New Mexico "are insufficient to plead a discriminatory impact in New York even if she was paid through a New York payroll system, and her operational support and training were obtained from the New York office," the court wrote.
For that point the panel relied on Pakniat and on Kingston v. International Business Machines Corp., a 2020 First Department decision. In Lidder's case, the single training trip to New York City and the administrative functions handled there were not enough to move the place of impact from Nevada to New York.
The court's treatment of Syeed occupied a single sentence. The distinction it drew turned on a missing allegation: Lidder's complaint did not say that she had sought a chance to work in New York and been turned down. The panel did not otherwise discuss the facts or reasoning of the Court of Appeals decision.
The ruling addressed only where the effect of the termination was felt. Because the panel resolved the appeal on subject matter jurisdiction, it did not reach whether Breakthrough T1D discriminated against Lidder or whether her claims had any merit.
The panel affirmed the order without costs. The appellate decision came about 11 months after the trial court's order.
Lidder was represented on appeal by Patricia Finn of Patricia Finn, P.C., in Pearl River. Breakthrough T1D was represented by Christopher R. Dyess of Epstein Becker Green, P.C., in New York.
The affirmance leaves the dismissal of Lidder's complaint in place. The decision does not say whether the dismissal bars her from pursuing the claims elsewhere. The New York State Law Reporting Bureau published the decision as 2026 NY Slip Op 06776 and marked it uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.