Key Points

  • The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed a judgment dismissing Corning's declaratory judgment action seeking defense and indemnity from National Union.
  • The court held that Corning's design and delivery of a faulty distributed antenna system for a football stadium was not a covered occurrence because Corning did not adequately identify damage to property other than its own work product.
  • A Corning vice president's testimony about collateral stadium damage, which he admitted was not told to him directly by IBM and which Corning could not corroborate, was conclusory and unavailing.
  • The court held that National Union properly disclaimed coverage under the policy's Exclusion D for impaired property.
  • Relying on Raymond Corp. v. National Union, the court held that the policy's Professional Liability Exclusion could not create coverage.

A New York appeals court ruled on Nov. 17 that National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, owes Corning Incorporated no coverage for claims arising from Corning's failure to deliver properly working distributed antenna systems, known as DAS, for a football stadium.

A four-justice panel of the Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed a trial court judgment dismissing Corning's lawsuit against the insurer. In an unsigned decision, the panel held that designing and delivering a faulty DAS was not a covered "occurrence" under National Union's liability policy. It also held that the policy's exclusion for "impaired property" barred coverage.

The decision leaves Corning without a defense or indemnity from National Union in the stadium dispute. The panel rejected Corning's argument that its work had damaged other property and upheld the insurer's reliance on the impaired-property exclusion. It also turned aside Corning's contention that a separate professional liability exclusion supplied coverage, and it awarded National Union costs.

Corning brought the case as a declaratory judgment action. It sought defense and indemnity coverage.

Justice Jennifer G. Schecter of the state Supreme Court in New York County ruled for the insurer in an order entered Jan. 8, 2025. The order denied Corning's motion for partial summary judgment and granted National Union's motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint. A judgment dismissing the complaint was entered May 1, 2025.

The appeal turned first on whether Corning's work counted as an "occurrence" under the policy. The panel wrote that the trial court "correctly determined that plaintiff's actions of designing and delivering a faulty DAS, was not a covered 'occurrence' as contemplated by defendant's liability policy."

The panel noted that the trial court had recognized that such a policy would apply if faulty workmanship caused "property damage to something other than the work product." But the trial court "correctly held that plaintiff did not adequately identify property damage to property that was not its own work product," the panel wrote, citing the First Department's 1994 decision in George A. Fuller Co. v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.

To show damage beyond its own work, Corning relied on testimony from its own vice president, whom the decision does not name. He testified that he believed the stadium had been damaged during "de-installation and re-installation" by "drilling holes or cutting concrete or mounting stuff in the wall."

The vice president admitted that the information was not told to him directly by IBM, according to the decision. Corning also could not provide evidence corroborating his account. "Therefore, plaintiff's allegations are conclusory and thus unavailing," the panel wrote.

The panel then held that National Union "properly disclaimed coverage under Exclusion D of the policy," which excludes impaired property. The policy defines that term as "tangible property," other than the insured's own product or work, that cannot be used or is less useful because it incorporates the insured's defective work or because the insured has "failed to fulfill the terms of a contract or agreement." The definition also requires that the property can be restored through specified means.

The panel found each part of that definition met. It held that the physical DAS and the stadium were tangible property and that Corning owned neither. Both were damaged after incorporating Corning's deficient DAS design, the panel wrote.

Corning, "who was ultimately responsible for the DAS project, did not fulfill its obligations to install a properly working DAS," the panel wrote. It added that the plaintiff in the underlying action was able to improve the damaged property and fix the deficient system.

For the exclusion ruling, the panel cited its own 2003 decision in Pavarini Construction Co. v. Continental Insurance Co. It also cited, for comparison, a 2015 decision of the federal district court for the Western District of New York, Thruway Produce, Inc. v. Massachusetts Bay Insurance Co.

Corning also relied on the policy's Professional Liability Exclusion, which Corning contended provides coverage. The panel called that contention "misplaced." It relied on the 2005 decision in Raymond Corp. v. National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh, Pa., another case involving the same insurer.

Quoting that decision, the panel held that "an exclusion from insurance coverage cannot create coverage."

The panel addressed Corning's other arguments in a single sentence. "We have considered plaintiff's remaining arguments and find them unavailing," it wrote, without describing them.

The panel consisted of Justices Mendez, Gesmer, Rosado and Hagler. The decision does not identify an author, and no justice wrote separately.

Lawyers for Corning included James H. Smith of McKool Smith, P.C. National Union was represented by Elizabeth F. Ahlstrand of Squire Patton Boggs (US) LLP.

The ruling leaves in place the May 1, 2025, judgment dismissing Corning's complaint, and the panel awarded National Union costs on the appeal. The decision, reported as 2026 NY Slip Op 06764, is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.