Key Points

  • An arbitration clause making the award binding as to all claims that "could have been raised in connection with the dispute" is substantively unconscionable because it reaches claims involving distinct primary rights, beyond what res judicata bars.
  • The phrase "to the fullest extent permitted by law" did not cure the award clause, because "there is no evidence here that an employee would have knowledge about what this savings clause permits." A similar "to the extent permitted by law" phrase in the PAGA waiver did not negate that waiver's unconscionability either.
  • Following Ramirez v. Charter Communications, the agreement's prevailing-party attorney fee clause was substantively unconscionable, and its waiver of PAGA claims, whether individual or nonindividual, was unconscionable as a blanket PAGA waiver.
  • With three unconscionable provisions and a tainted central term, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to sever, and the class action waiver fell with the PAGA waiver because they shared the same sentences.
  • The Second District, Division Six, affirmed the order denying Art's Labor Service's and Glass House Camarillo Cultivation's motion to compel arbitration.

A California appeals court held on Nov. 19 that an employer's arbitration agreement may not give the arbitrator's award binding effect over every employment claim that "could have been raised," ruling that such a clause is unconscionable because it would extinguish claims resting on legal rights separate from the ones actually arbitrated.

"The provision would bar claims involving distinct primary rights simply because the employee could have asserted them in arbitration," Justice Baltodano wrote for a unanimous panel of the Second Appellate District, Division Six. Presiding Justice Cody and Justice Yegan concurred. The panel affirmed a Ventura County Superior Court order denying a motion by staffing agency Art's Labor Service and its client Glass House Camarillo Cultivation LLC to compel arbitration of a wage and hour suit filed by Yunuen S. Castillo Zamora.

The published decision holds that "could have been raised" language in an employment arbitration agreement reaches beyond res judicata, the doctrine that bars relitigating the same cause of action between the same parties. The panel also found the agreement's prevailing-party attorney fee clause and its waiver of claims under the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004, known as PAGA, unconscionable, and it upheld the trial court's refusal to cut out the defective terms and enforce the rest.

According to the opinion, Glass House operates a cannabis business and owns several cannabis farms in Southern California. Art's hired Castillo and staffed her at Glass House's Camarillo location as a nonexempt employee from around April to September 2024. Art's requires all new hires to sign the arbitration agreement as a condition of employment, and Castillo received English and Spanish versions of it in an onboarding packet she was allowed to take home.

In October 2024, Castillo sued on behalf of herself and others similarly situated, alleging wage and hour violations, and notified the Labor and Workforce Development Agency of potential PAGA claims. Her complaint did not plead a PAGA cause of action. Superior Court Judge Ronda J. McKaig found that the Federal Arbitration Act controls but that the agreement was "permeated with unconscionability."

Under California law, a contract is unconscionable if "one of the parties lacked a meaningful choice in deciding whether to agree and the contract contains terms that are unreasonably favorable to the other party." The panel said the agreement was a contract of adhesion, a take-it-or-leave-it form, which establishes only "a low degree of procedural unconscionability," and then turned to its terms.

The agreement made any award "final and binding between the parties as to all claims, which were or could have been raised in connection with the dispute to the fullest extent permitted by law." Art's and Glass House argued that the clause tracked ordinary res judicata principles and covered only claims that "arise from the same 'cause of action' or injury."

The panel disagreed, relying on California's primary rights theory, under which the invasion of one primary right gives rise to a single cause of action regardless of the legal theories pleaded. Baltodano wrote that two claims arising from the same employment relationship do not necessarily share a primary right. A discrimination claim under the Fair Employment and Housing Act, or FEHA, and a claim for unpaid wages do not implicate the same "harm suffered," Baltodano wrote.

"Had the parties here intended to adopt the principles of res judicata, they could have employed limiting language that only encompassed claims arising from the same cause of action or injury," Baltodano wrote. The phrase "extent permitted by law" did not save the clause, the panel held, because "there is no evidence here that an employee would have knowledge about what this savings clause permits."

The fee clause provided that if litigation was needed to enforce the arbitration agreement, "the prevailing party shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees." Citing the California Supreme Court's 2024 decision in Ramirez v. Charter Communications, the panel held: "The provision creates a potential obligation for an employee to pay attorney fees in arbitration—an obligation that would not exist if the action was litigated in superior court." That risk "could deter a plaintiff from bringing a legitimate lawsuit," the opinion said.

The agreement also barred "joint, class, representative or collective claims" over wages, hours or working conditions "in any forum, whether arbitral or judicial," and stated that the waiver included PAGA claims to the extent permitted by law. Relying on Adolph v. Uber Technologies, the panel said a waiver of representative PAGA actions is unenforceable and violates public policy. The companies argued that individual PAGA claims are arbitrable, but the panel read the language to waive PAGA actions "whether individual or nonindividual" and called it a "blanket PAGA waiver."

On severance, the panel reviewed the trial court's choice for abuse of discretion and found none. The trial judge found the award provision "central" to the agreement's purpose and concluded that it would have to reform the contract to make it lawful. The panel quoted a 2022 appellate decision: "[U]pholding this type of agreement with multiple unconscionable terms would create an incentive for an employer to draft a one-sided arbitration agreement in the hope employees would not challenge the unlawful provisions."

The panel rejected the companies' argument that the trial court ignored the Federal Arbitration Act, noting that the court had acknowledged the statute controls and quoting Ramirez: "[I]t was not Congress's intent to make arbitration agreements more enforceable than other contracts." It also declined to sever and enforce the class action waiver on its own, because that waiver appeared in the same sentences as the defective PAGA waiver.

Michele J. Beilke of Seyfarth Shaw represented appellant Glass House. Robert P. Roy of the Ventura County Agricultural Association represented appellant Art’s Labor Service. Joseph Lavi of Lavi & Ebrahimian represented the respondent.

The order denying the motion to compel arbitration stands, and Castillo is entitled to recover her costs on appeal. Because it resolved the appeal on unconscionability, the panel did not reach the other grounds Castillo raised in her brief.