Key Points

  • The First Appellate District, Division One, affirmed the dismissal of TruConnect's suit against Maximus and Solix, the contractors that built the CPUC's 2019 LifeLine enrollment platform.
  • The court held that the contractors owed TruConnect no duty of care to prevent purely economic loss, so its negligence, negligent interference and unfair competition claims failed.
  • Although harm to TruConnect was foreseeable, the court found that the CPUC-Maximus contract was not intended to benefit TruConnect in particular and that a sophisticated plaintiff could protect itself through contract or insurance.
  • In an unpublished part of the opinion, the court held that TruConnect did not state a restitution claim based on mistake, and it did not decide whether the CPUC is an indispensable party.

Two companies the California Public Utilities Commission hired to design and implement a software platform for the state's government-subsidized LifeLine telephone program owed no duty to protect a LifeLine provider from purely economic losses it allegedly suffered because the platform was defective, a state appeals court ruled. The court held that the provider, TruConnect Communications Inc., and the contractors "were essentially separate subcontractors of the PUC in the effort to provide telephone service to lower-income Californians," not parties in a special relationship that would permit recovery for economic harm alone.

The First Appellate District, Division One, on Nov. 19 affirmed a San Francisco Superior Court judgment dismissing TruConnect's suit against Maximus Inc. and its subcontractor, Solix Inc. Humes wrote the opinion, and Justices Banke and Smiley concurred. Although harm to TruConnect from platform errors was foreseeable, the court concluded that "this is not one of those rare situations in which a duty can be found to have been owed to protect against the purely economic interests of a non-contracting plaintiff."

The decision leaves TruConnect without a negligence claim for more than $20 million in alleged lost revenue and more than $3 million in staff time it says it spent repairing the platform. The court acknowledged that, without a duty, "the company lacks a remedy for what is alleged to be a significant financial loss." But it agreed with the contractors that a duty would expose government contractors to claims from "all manner of participants in government programs, essentially making contractors like Maximus a guarantor for their revenues."

According to the complaint, whose allegations the court accepted as true at this stage, TruConnect provides free wireless telephone service to eligible low-income Californians through LifeLine, which the California Public Utilities Commission oversees in the state. The company earns more than 90 percent of its revenue from California LifeLine enrollees and is the state's second largest LifeLine provider.

The commission hired Maximus in summer 2018 as the program's third-party administrator, which processes enrollments and tracks reimbursements, and Maximus hired Solix as a subcontractor. The complaint alleges that the platform "proved grossly inadequate when the platform was launched on April 2, 2019," and that hundreds of thousands of TruConnect applicants and renewing subscribers who met the eligibility requirements were denied approval.

The commission approved some initial reimbursement claims but in September 2020 rejected reimbursement for lost-opportunity costs. TruConnect sued the contractors in February 2021. The trial court first dismissed the case after concluding that Public Utilities Code section 1759 barred the complaint, but the appeals court reversed in 2023. On remand, the trial court sustained Maximus's demurrer, which Solix had joined, without leave to amend and dismissed the complaint as to both defendants.

The appeals court started from what it called a "general rule of no recovery" in negligence for purely economic losses. The main exception applies when "the plaintiff was an intended beneficiary of a particular transaction but was harmed by the defendant's negligence in carrying it out." Courts weigh six factors from a 1958 decision, Biakanja v. Irving, beginning with the extent to which the transaction was intended to affect the plaintiff.

The court called that first factor "a close question" but found it weighed against TruConnect. "While it is no doubt true that Maximus's agreement with the CPUC necessarily affected TruConnect's economic interests, there is no indication that the parties entered into the agreement for the purpose of benefitting those interests," Humes wrote. Humes added that while "some telecommunications company (or companies) will benefit when a program administrator correctly identifies eligible customers, that company will not necessarily be TruConnect." The contract was meant to help the commission identify people who qualified for LifeLine, "but not to assign them to any particular carrier."

The panel faulted both sides on that factor. TruConnect's test, it said, would establish intent to benefit whenever harm to a third party was foreseeable, "which is not the law." And it called "an overstatement" the contractors' argument that a plaintiff who is not a third-party beneficiary of a contract can never satisfy the factor.

The court recognized "that some relevant factors weigh in favor of finding a duty." It agreed with the trial court that the contractors' conduct could be found to have injured TruConnect, and it noted that negligence in executing contractual duties is "generally held to be morally blameworthy conduct." But it concluded that the factors on balance did not support a duty, which it said would risk liability out of proportion to fault "where a relatively sophisticated plaintiff could take steps to protect itself in contract, either through its own agreement with the CPUC or through insurance."

The contractors and the commission, which filed an amicus brief supporting them, argued that liability would affect the availability of government contractors. The court agreed with the commission that a duty might "open the door to frequent litigation in excessive amounts, likely resulting in fewer applicants for contracts, less-qualified contractors, or higher fees." It added that if the Legislature wants to allow such recovery, "it knows how," pointing to a statute that lets homeowners sue negligent builders for economic loss without property damage.

TruConnect's claims for negligent interference with prospective economic relations and unfair competition fell with the negligence claim. In an unpublished portion of the opinion, the court rejected TruConnect's argument that it stated a restitution claim because it helped fix the platform under the mistaken belief that it would be paid, finding no "invalidating mistake." Having resolved the case on those grounds, it did not reach the contractors' argument that the commission was an indispensable party.

Thomas R. Freeman of Bird, Marella, Rhow, Lincenberg, Drooks & Nessim, LLP represented the appellant. Cynthia J. Larsen of Orric, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP represented respondent Solix. Nathaniel P. Garrett of Jones Day represented respondent Maximus. Christine J. Hammond of the California Public Utilities Commission represented amici.

The opinion is certified for publication except for its restitution and indispensable-party sections. The panel awarded Maximus and Solix their costs on appeal.