Key Points

  • The Fifth Appellate District held that Education Code section 44808's clause withdrawing immunity when a district "has failed to exercise reasonable care under the circumstances" is an independent exception that applies whether the injury occurs on or off campus.
  • The court reversed summary judgment for the Fresno Unified School District because the district's motion addressed only the location and timing of the alleged abuse, not whether the district exercised reasonable care, so it did not carry its initial burden.
  • The court adopted Justice Raphael's concurrence in Victor Valley Union High School Dist. v. Superior Court, now under review by the California Supreme Court, and declined to follow Torsiello, LeRoy, Cerna, Mosley and Taylor.
  • The court said a district loses immunity only for its own failure of care, acting through administrators and supervisors, and that an employee's off-campus negligence alone does not withdraw immunity.
  • The court did not decide the trial court's evidentiary rulings, leaving admissibility of S.N.'s evidence to the trial court on remand.

A California appeals court ruled Nov. 18 that a state law limiting school districts' liability for students who are off campus gives way whenever the district itself fails to use reasonable care, reversing a judgment that had ended a former Fresno elementary student's lawsuit over sexual abuse by her teacher.

The Fifth Appellate District held that the reasonable-care clause in Education Code section 44808 "is an independent exception to the immunity under section 44808, and it applies whether the resulting injury occurs on or off campus." Because the Fresno Unified School District's motion for summary judgment showed only where and when the abuse occurred, the court held that the district never carried its initial burden. Justice Franson wrote the opinion, and Acting Presiding Justice Levy and Justice Snauffer concurred.

The decision breaks with what the court acknowledged is the view of most Courts of Appeal, which read the clause as a standard of care for the specific undertakings the statute lists. The panel instead adopted a concurrence in Victor Valley Union High School District v. Superior Court, a Fourth District case the California Supreme Court agreed on Sept. 23 to review, and declined to follow Torsiello, LeRoy, Cerna, Mosley and Taylor.

Section 44808 provides that no school district is liable for the conduct or safety of a pupil "at any time when such pupil is not on school property," unless the district has undertaken to provide transportation, has undertaken a school-sponsored activity off the premises, has otherwise specifically assumed responsibility, "or has failed to exercise reasonable care under the circumstances."

The plaintiff, identified as S.N., sued in 2022 under a former version of Code of Civil Procedure section 340.1, which revived otherwise time-barred childhood sexual assault claims. She alleged that Maximo Parayno III, her fifth-grade teacher and basketball coach at Vinland Elementary School, abused her when she was 10 and 11, and that the district had settled a 1999 lawsuit by another student accusing him of molestation and left him in the classroom.

The district moved for summary judgment on immunity alone. It relied on S.N.'s 2024 deposition, in which she testified that Parayno drove her home from school on more than 10 occasions and first touched her during one of those rides. Fresno County Superior Court Judge Kristi C. Kapetan granted the motion, excluded a 2003 police report in which S.N. said the first touching happened on school property after school, and ruled that the immunity "necessarily must extend to negligent hiring, supervision, and retention."

The statute's four exceptions are joined by the disjunctive "or," Justice Franson wrote, and the district's reading would change that word to "and." In 1972, the court noted, the Senate first attached the reasonable-care language to a paragraph limiting liability for specific undertakings, then moved it 19 days later into the list of exceptions. "The Legislature thus considered the reading that District urges, a reasonable care requirement qualifying the specific undertakings, and replaced it with an independent exception," the court wrote.

Most appellate courts, the court wrote, reason that "an immunity that yields whenever a district is negligent immunizes nothing, because a district that exercised reasonable care would not be liable in negligence in any event." That argument, the court wrote, "overlooks what section 44808 and its predecessor were enacted to change," namely district responsibility flowing from a separate duty on teachers to hold pupils "to a strict account for their conduct on the way to and from school."

The court relied on Hoyem v. Manhattan Beach City School District, a 1978 California Supreme Court decision stating that "when a school district fails to exercise reasonable care the immunity of this section evaporates."

Reading the statute as the district urged, Franson wrote, "would mean that the district's liability depends not on whether it acted reasonably but on where the teacher chose to complete the abuse." Under that reading, the same teacher could relieve the district of liability "simply by taking the pupil elsewhere after school," the court said, adding: "An immunity that turned on so arbitrary a distinction requires a clear statement from the Legislature."

"This rule does not make a district an insurer of its pupils' safety off campus. The failure of care must be the district's own," the opinion said. A district acts through its administrators and supervisors, the court explained, so an employee's off-campus negligence, without more, does not strip the district's immunity.

The Victor Valley majority held that the statute turns on where a district's negligence occurred, not where the injury occurred, and the Supreme Court's question on review concerns that rule. The Fifth District said it agreed with that result but rested on Justice Raphael's concurrence. "Our conclusion does not depend on where District's negligence occurred," the court wrote.

Applying its rule, the panel said it did not suggest the district was required to dismiss Parayno. But it said the allegations describe supervisors who knew a teacher had been accused of molesting a student, settled a lawsuit over that accusation and left him in a classroom. "Whether District exercised reasonable care under the circumstances is a question of fact, and District's motion did not put it at issue," the court wrote.

The court did not decide whether the trial judge properly excluded S.N.'s evidence that some abuse occurred on campus or her evidence of the district's notice of Parayno's earlier conduct, leaving admissibility to the trial court.

Britt Lacey Karp of Herman Law represented the appellant. Bruce J. Berger of Berger Milton represented the respondent.

The case returns to Fresno County Superior Court, which must vacate its summary judgment order and enter a new order denying the district's motion for summary judgment and summary adjudication. S.N. was awarded her costs on appeal. The panel said it would apply its rule while the Supreme Court's decision in Victor Valley is pending.