Key Points
- The court affirmed the denial of arbitration as to the father's wrongful death claim because he did not sign the arbitration agreement and the claim's primary basis is custodial failure, not medical malpractice.
- Applying Holland v. Silverscreen Healthcare, the panel held that the type of conduct alleged, not the type of facility, determines whether the Ruiz v. Podolsky exception under MICRA can bind a nonsignatory heir.
- The court reversed the denial as to the negligence, dependent adult abuse and pain-and-suffering claims, holding they are survivor claims belonging to the son, who signed the agreement.
- Because the agreement expressly excluded Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.2(c), and the father did not respond to that argument on appeal, the trial court had no discretion under that section to deny arbitration of the survivor claims.
A California appeals court held that a father cannot be compelled to arbitrate his wrongful death claim against the skilled nursing facility where his paralyzed son was shot and killed, because the claim accuses the facility of failing in its custodial duties rather than of medical malpractice. The son's signature on an arbitration agreement, the court ruled, did not bind his father on that claim.
The First Appellate District, Division One, affirmed in part and reversed in part an Alameda County Superior Court order that had denied the defendants' motion to compel arbitration. Presiding Justice Humes wrote the opinion, joined by Justices Banke and Langhorne Wilson. The panel held that the son's own claims, which the father brought as his successor, must be arbitrated.
The panel relied on the California Supreme Court's 2025 decision in Holland v. Silverscreen Healthcare, Inc., which held that the exception binding non-signatory heirs to arbitrate wrongful death claims alleging medical malpractice does not bind heirs whose wrongful death claims sound in elder or dependent adult abuse. The defendants characterized the father's claim as "arising out of medical malpractice" because, they argued, the allegations implicated the facility's status as a health care provider. "Holland makes clear that what matters is the type of conduct alleged—not the type of facility in which the conduct occurred," Humes wrote.
According to the opinion, Paris Moffett was shot and paralyzed from the waist down in September 2022, while in his early 20s. The next month he was admitted to Lake Merritt Healthcare Center, LLC, a skilled nursing facility owned by Crystal Solorzano, who is also a defendant. In early March 2023 he signed an arbitration agreement with the facility. His father, Paris D'Marco Moffett, did not sign it.
The agreement stated it was binding on "all parties, including the Resident's representatives, executors, family members, and heirs who bring any claims individually or in any representative capacity." Several days after signing, the son was shot again, fatally, "by two people who entered the facility in the middle of the night through an unlocked rear door," the opinion said.
The father sued the facility and Solorzano in his own right and as his son's successor. He alleged negligence, negligent abuse of a dependent adult under the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, a claim for the "extreme pain suffered" by his son before he died, and wrongful death. The trial court, Judge Han Tran presiding, denied the motion to compel arbitration "largely because Moffett had not signed the arbitration agreement," the appellate opinion said.
"As a general rule, plaintiffs cannot be compelled to arbitrate their disputes if they have not previously agreed to arbitration," the panel wrote, quoting Holland. A wrongful death claim, the court explained, is an independent statutory action belonging to the heirs, not a claim derived from the decedent's own. The Supreme Court's 2010 decision in Ruiz v. Podolsky recognized an exception under the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act, letting a patient bind heirs to arbitrate wrongful death claims alleging medical malpractice. Holland held that the exception does not reach heirs whose wrongful death claims sound in elder or dependent adult abuse.
Holland acknowledged "there is potential for confusion" because "some health care institutions, such as nursing homes, perform custodial functions and provide professional medical care." It explained "that only acts or omissions by a skilled nursing facility in its capacity as a health care provider fall under the banner of professional negligence," while failures to provide basic necessities, habitable living space or protection from routine safety hazards fall on the custodial side. Courts look to "the primary basis" of the claim, the panel wrote.
The father's complaint alleged that the defendants failed to check adequately on his son the night he was killed, failed to lock and secure exterior access to the facility, and failed to provide adequate security personnel, supervision and staffing. Humes wrote that "there can be no question" the claim's primary basis is that the defendants "failed in their custodial care of Paris." The panel said it would "flatly reject defendants' characterization of the claim" as "arising out of medical malpractice."
The other three claims came out differently. A survivor claim, unlike a wrongful death claim, "belonged to the decedent before death but, by statute, survives that event," the court wrote, quoting a 2006 appellate decision, Quiroz v. Seventh Ave. Center. The panel held that the negligence and pain-and-suffering counts were pleaded as survivor claims, and that the elder abuse count was one as a matter of law because the act's remedies belong only to abuse victims. Those claims belonged to the son, who signed the agreement.
The defendants argued the trial court had no discretion to keep those claims out of arbitration. Section 1281.2(c) of the California Arbitration Act lets trial courts stay or deny arbitration when a party to the agreement is also in litigation with a third party over the same transaction and conflicting rulings are possible. The agreement provided that the provision "is excluded from this Agreement" and added: "The parties do not want any claims not subject to arbitration to impede any and all other claims from being ordered to binding arbitration."
The father, acting as his son's successor, did not respond to that contention in his appellate briefing, and the panel considered the issue submitted on the defendants' brief. "Having no reason to decide otherwise," the court concluded that the son and the facility had expressly agreed that section 1281.2(c) would not apply, so the trial court had "no discretion to deny arbitration of the three survivor causes of action under any ostensible authority conferred by that section."
Tracy D. Forbath of Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith represented the appellant. Eileen Burke of Burke Law Offices represented the respondent.
The panel filed its opinion on Oct. 22 without certifying it for publication, then certified it for publication on Nov. 18 at the request of the Orange County Trial Lawyers Association, with no change in the judgment. The parties will bear their own appellate costs. Under the disposition, the denial of arbitration stands only for the wrongful death claim, and the order is reversed as to the three survivor claims.