Key Points

  • The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously reversed a Supreme Court, New York County order that had renewed Indigo Secured High Income Note, Ltd.'s money judgment against Steven Nitsberg under CPLR 5014.
  • Because Indigo was incorporated in the Bahamas and the action concerned its internal affairs, the court applied Bahamian substantive law, citing Ezrasons, Inc. v Rudd (2025).
  • Section 167(1) of the Bahamian International Business Companies Act bars a struck-off company from commencing legal proceedings; Indigo was struck off on April 21, 2023, and filed the renewal action on October 16, 2024, without being restored.
  • The court rejected Indigo's argument that the renewal suit continued its original action under Section 167(2)(c), holding under Gletzer v Harris that a CPLR 5014 renewal action requires commencement of a new plenary action.
  • The court granted Nitsberg's motion for summary judgment, denied Indigo's cross-motion, and dismissed the complaint with costs.

A company that had been struck from the Bahamian corporate register had no legal power to sue in New York to renew a money judgment it held against Steven Nitsberg, a state appeals court ruled Tuesday, reversing a New York County trial court that had granted the renewal.

The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously reversed an order of Justice Arthur F. Engoron of Supreme Court, New York County, and directed that the complaint brought by Indigo Secured High Income Note, Ltd. be dismissed, with costs. The four-justice panel of Justices Mendez, who presided, Gesmer, Rosado and Hagler issued the ruling as a decision and order that names no author.

The case turned on whether a renewal action under CPLR 5014 continues the original lawsuit or starts a new one. The panel held that it starts a new one. That meant Bahamian law barring a struck-off company from commencing legal proceedings applied in full, and an exception for lawsuits already under way before the strike-off did not help Indigo.

According to the decision, Indigo was struck off the Bahamian register on April 21, 2023. It did not commence the renewal action until October 16, 2024, and it "was never restored to the registry prior to commencing this action," the court wrote.

The panel first settled which country's law governed. It cited the 2025 decision in Ezrasons, Inc. v. Rudd. Indigo "was incorporated in the Bahamas and this action concerns matters relating to plaintiff's internal affairs," the court wrote, and "Thus, Bahamian substantive law applies to this action."

Under that law, the panel held, Indigo lacked capacity to commence the action. The governing statute is the Bahamas' International Business Companies Act. The decision quoted Section 167(1) of the act, which provides in part that "[w]here the name of a company has been struck-off the Register, the company . . . may not legally (a) commence legal proceedings, carry on any business or in any way deal with the assets of the company."

The same provision also bars a struck-off company from acting "in any way with respect to the affairs of the company," according to the passage the court quoted. On that basis, the panel concluded that the trial court "should have dismissed the complaint because plaintiff did not have capacity to commence this action."

Indigo had argued that its renewal suit was "merely a continuation of the underlying action in which it obtained the money judgment," as the court described the position. Under that view, the company could proceed under Section 167(2)(c) of the Bahamian act, which allows struck-off companies to "continue to carry on legal proceedings that were instituted on behalf of the company prior to the date of strike off."

The panel called that argument "unavailing." It relied on its own 2008 decision in Gletzer v. Harris, which was affirmed in 2009, for the rule that a CPLR 5014 action for a renewal judgment "requires commencement of a new plenary action between the same parties."

The court also pointed to the text of CPLR 5014 itself, which speaks of an action being commenced. The decision quoted the rule as providing that "[a]n action may be commenced under subdivision one of this section during the year prior to the expiration of ten years since the first docketing of the judgment."

Indigo's own filings matched that reading, the panel found. "Here, plaintiff filed a new action, and obtained a new index number to pursue CPLR 5014 relief, which it lacked capacity to do under International Business Companies Act ยง 167(1)," the court wrote.

The ruling undoes the result below. In an order entered on or about December 1, 2025, Justice Engoron had denied Nitsberg's motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint and granted Indigo's cross-motion for summary judgment renewing the money judgment under CPLR 5014.

The First Department reversed that order "on the law," granted Nitsberg's motion and denied Indigo's cross-motion. The decision does not describe the underlying dispute between Indigo and Nitsberg, the amount of the original money judgment or the date it was first docketed.

Nitsberg was represented by Gary L. Franklin of Primmer Piper Eggleston & Cramer P.C. Indigo was represented by Shane R. Heskin of Heskin & Proper PLLC.

The appeal was docketed as Appeal No. 7525 and Case No. 2026-02765, arising from Index No. 665475/24. The court directed its clerk "to enter judgment accordingly," dismissing Indigo's complaint. The decision, reported as 2026 NY Slip Op 06770, is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.